Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Fields of Progress:The Mechanization of Agriculture in Days of Heaven Benjamin S. Child (bio) Introduction The films of Terrence Malick actively resist summation, and his second full-length picture, Days of Heaven (1978), is no exception. Where Pauline Kael dismissed it as "all visual bombast," Dave Kehr, writing in the Chicago Reader, described it as "very possibly, a masterpiece"; Harold Schonberg complained that the plot is muddled by "all kinds of fancy, self-conscious cineaste techniques," while one enthusiastic partisan recently insists that it is the "greatest film ever made."1 And though commentators have creatively read Days of Heaven as a biblical allegory, have examined its technical innovations, and have deconstructed its relationship to frontier ideologies, little attention has been paid to the film's depictions of the rural terrain of the Texas Panhandle in 1916.2 Or, to be more specific, there has been little notice of its examination of laboring bodies inhabiting the edges of the agricultural zones of the South and the Midwest during a transitional period marked by the arrival of mechanized labor. Although the film has commonly been understood as a product of the postmodern, it most forcefully leverages a series of tensions, conflicts, and aesthetic techniques from the early twentieth century in order to register the expansive, period-straddling reverberations of industrial modernization. I argue below that this double interest in tactics of cultural production associated with both the early and the late twentieth century makes it possible to [End Page 79] use Days of Heaven as a means of assessing the continuities and discontinuities, the repetitions and diffusions, that characterize relationships between expressive artifacts of both the 1910s and 1920s and the 1970s, thereby revealing the sustained relevance of the unsettling modernity of the film's rural setting. In an incisive essay exploring poetic responses to scientific literatures about U.S. rurality, Maria Farland describes the complex of roles the countryside plays in early-twentieth-century cultural discourse, calling for work that fills the "void in the literary study of rural problems."3 This essay seeks to answer that call insofar as it demonstrates how Days of Heaven's destabilizing combination of the visual and the verbal, its distinctive strategies of representing the rural, can provide a critical lens for examining the persistence of the agricultural and the pastoral as a default mode of representation and analysis in American studies. To that end I argue that with its (south)western geographies, its dramatic visual iconography, and its ominous account of agricultural progress, Days of Heaven emerges from the same genealogy as such foundational myth-and-symbol studies as R. W. B. Lewis's The American Adam (1955), Nash Smith's Virgin Land (1950), and Leo Marx's The Machine in the Garden (1964).4 Yet the film offers a somber reconsideration of those earlier visions, narrativizing the mechanization of agriculture to emphasize the mutually destructive logic of exploitation and violence present in both its contemporary moment and its "historical" miseen-scène. One of Days of Heaven's most notable qualities, then, is its attention to emergent technologies of communication, mobility, and (re)production. Consequently the film's intertwining motifs of the natural and the technological provide a useful perspective on Leigh Anne Duck's question about "how cultural forms considered anachronistic could coexist in often vital relationships with those recognized as central to modernization."5 In the film's economy of objects, mechanical technologies exist alongside older tools and practices, all within landscapes that both resist and absorb their effects. A prosaic example, but one that keeps with the film's larger themes, comes from the stage direction in Malick's original screenplay, which describes one character reaping wheat "with a mowing machine called a binder" alongside another who gathers sheaves by hand.6 It's clear throughout the narrative that arrivals of the modern occur unevenly, in shifts, without a vacuum to fill. How does a film of 1978 imagine 1916? As an interlocking, asymmetrical compound of what-will-be and what-was that critiques existing powers at the same time as it reveals the deadly consequences of resistance borne on the individual body. The old and the new...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Benjamin S. Child (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: