Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Can Islamophobia be historiographical? This article sets out to answer this question by looking at how the way we tell the story of history engineers Islamophobia in the present. In particular, this article identifies “classicism” as an Islamophobic discourse that produces ethnonationalism by establishing the cultural and racial production of identity as something that is fixed in the “classical” world, defined as crucially before the coming of Islam. Having established the way that this classicism plays a role in the genocides of Muslims in Palestine, East Turkestan and India, the article then turns to the way historiographical Islamophobia is practiced in Muslim-majority places. It argues that classicism can be a tool of Kemalism, and looks at the example of Saudi Arabia’s recent “rediscovery” of its ancient past as a case study of this historiographical Islamophobia. A series of epistemological alliances become apparent: between classicism and ethnonationalism, ethnonationalism and Kemalism, Kemalism and Islamophobia—these help us to understand both the historiographic operation of Islamophobia and its foreclosure of Muslim political subjectivity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marchella Ward (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: