Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Unlike many other natural disasters, an impact by an asteroid on Earth may be preventable. One method available to stop an impact is the use of a nuclear explosive device (NED), through either deflection via surface ablation or intentional robust disruption such that no fragment poses a risk to the planet. To simulate NED mitigation missions, we implemented an X-ray energy deposition model in the smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) code Spheral. To assess our SPH results, we first compared with previous 1D (planar) and 2D (cylindrical) mesh-based asteroid deflection results. 1D Spheral simulations agree with these prior models to within 0.8% across a range of X-ray fluences, illumination times, blackbody temperatures, asteroid compositions, and porosities. Full 3D models in Spheral agree to within ∼18.1% with the prior cylindrical simulations but are limited to coarser resolution owing to the computational requirements of modeling in full 3D versus the finer resolutions practical in reduced 2D models. We present intentional disruption simulations in 3D for a homogeneous, 160 m asteroid composed of forsterite, exploring how disruption varies both with the NED height of burst (distance from the asteroid surface) and with damage model parameter choices. These simulations explore the near-threshold parameter space below the mission-design heuristic boundary for definitive robust disruption. Definitive verification against common robust disruption metrics, including fragment size criteria, would require running simulations to significantly longer run times. However, the observed damage extent and bidirectional material motion at the final simulated times strongly suggest that these cases lie near the robust disruption regime.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Santistevan et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: