Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Educating patients about diseases and treatments is an integral part of healthcare. It is a right included in the original patients’ rights charter at Alma-ATA in 1978 [1] and more recently updated in a few countries including the UK [2–4]. This is of particular importance for patients with chronic diseases where doctors should see their role as helping the patient manage their rheumatic disease. In order to do this the patient has to be capable, educated and literate in the relevant language to a level allowing them to participate in ‘shared decision making’ [5]. More recently as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, digital interactions have had to replace many face to face meetings. Confronted by the necessity and benefits of these digital interactions, increasing numbers of people across the globe (including resource poor settings), have been embracing digital technology. However, a challenge is that ‘digital exclusion’ (not having access to digital technology) is a health inequality and is associated with other social disadvantages including lower income, lower education and poor housing [6]. Novel and inexpensive approaches to digital technology need to be developed to ensure access to this resource for the whole population. Patients need to understand the disease and the advantages and disadvantages of different interventions as well as how to interact with the local service. The problem is that the patients are all different in terms of how much they want to know, their communication preferences, their literacy (language, health and computer), and their ability to understand concepts. People are thought to create a narrative in their minds that explains how they got where they are, and any new information needs to be added to this [7]. All narratives will therefore vary and develop in different directions. This is where the first great advantage of a digital format becomes apparent. The education can be customized to the patient, preferably by the patients themselves. Patient information could be preceded by questions designed to tease out the learning and detail preferences of the patient and the most appropriate format, style and content selected. A huge range of different educations would be possible, from detail to big picture, from word based to visual. It could also include a direct copy of a printed leaflet for those who prefer that format. The challenge here is the patient who is not e-literate and struggles to engage with a computer. It is possible that engaging using a ‘smart speaker’ and the spoken word may suit such users. That the digital format can be interactive is the next great advantage. Communication can be defined as ‘the exchange of messages to achieve a common meaning’. This requires a contribution from both sides, i.e. an interaction. Digital educational packages can involve feedback from the patient that can modify the content or be made necessary to proceed. This potentially solves the challenge of keeping the patient concentrating. The next great advantage is the ability to layer the information. If there is a minimum amount of information that is essential, say for the safe use of a drug, then that can form the base layer. Items of practical interest may form the next layer, with theoretical interests forming the one after that. Being digital, it is possible to end the layering with a ‘link’ to a reputable source such as a textbook or website. This raises the challenge, in the era of Donald Trump and fake news, of making sure that the link is to information that is reputable and evidence based. An example from the UK is ‘Versus Arthritis’ who have attempted this for their ‘Patient Information Portal’ [8] by checking the provenance of all linked sites. Keeping the information updated is another facet facilitated by a digital format. Provided that a website is used for access, then it is only necessary to update that site for all access to be updated. This also highlights the ease of distribution, provided that the patient has a suitable interface with the internet. Similarly sites that are ‘linked’ or recommended will need to be kept up to date, but that will be the responsibility of the site holder. For example, a link to British Society for Rheumatology (BSR) guidance will be updated by the BSR. The challenge will be making sure that other linked material is also kept updated. Our recent ‘Covid’ experience of using on-line group technology opens up the possibility of doing group education for purposes such as educating patients prior to starting drugs. The information would be sent in advance, and the session facilitated by a nurse. There would be a brief presentation of the salient facts, which could be pre-recorded, followed by Q & A with the advantage that patients would learn from each other’s questions. Expert patients could be involved. The challenge would be getting the technology working and the offer of a one to one session would be essential for confidential matters. Another great advantage of a digital format is the ability to provide the information in multiple languages, selected on entry to the site. Not only can the text be in different languages, but at the click of a mouse, the text can be read to you. The challenge here is getting a translation that works in the culture of the recipient. This is more complicated than expected as we found when translating osteomalacia information into Urdu [9]. Problems arose with words not existing in Urdu and being fabricated phonetically and there were also issues about the script used. Also, with English being the language of science, there was debate about how much to translate. Technical words left in English would encourage them to be learned. We concluded that minimizing the amount of translation, and then having an audio file spoken in the appropriate language or even dialect (e.g. Syletti) was the practical way forward. It raises the intriguing possibility of opening it up to people in a wiki way, to do their own voice overs for their cultural peers. Some quality control will be necessary and challenging. Feedback on the usefulness of the education is also facilitated by a digital format. Usage statistics and time spent on different parts of the site will be a guide, and feedback questionnaires are easy to send even if there is general ‘feedback fatigue’. The ‘reach’ of digital technology is also huge. It can provide information in remote areas and cross national boundaries with ease. It can provide information anywhere the internet has reached and at a time to suit the learner. The challenge will be in keeping it personal enough. The final advantage is that a ‘forum’ could be run alongside the information, either by typed or verbal conversations. The challenge would be that it would require some investment in terms of a moderator. In summary, a digital format, through websites, for patient information and education offers huge advantages that can be accessed with some development and a bit of imagination. The challenges while being difficult are not insurmountable. Funding: No specific funding was received from any funding bodies in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors to carry out the work described in this manuscript. Disclosure statement: the authors have declared no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Walker et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: