Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Review proposes an acquisitive–conservative fruit economics spectrum in seed plants, indicating that fruit traits bridge functional ecology and dispersal strategies.
The path toward a unified plant trait space, as compellingly outlined by Carmona & Beccari (2025), is fraught with hurdles: trait complexity, data paucity, and methodological shortfalls. We concur with their assessment that reproductive traits are a critical missing piece preventing global quantitative syntheses of plant phenotypes. To overcome long-standing biases and move beyond fragmentary approaches, Carmona & Beccari (2025) propose a unified trait framework to enhance predictions of plant responses to environmental change. Despite notable progress in the past decade, functional ecology has remained overwhelmingly focused on vegetative traits, leaving reproductive traits underrepresented in both trait databases and theoretical frameworks. Recent studies have begun to fill this gap by developing trait spectra for seeds (Saatkamp et al., 2019; Carta et al., 2024) and flowers (Chartier et al., 2014; Roddy et al., 2021). These frameworks, when tested across specific ecosystems (Fernández-Pascual et al., 2021; E-Vojtkó et al., 2022), reveal reproductive traits as part of independent dimensions within the plant economic spectrum. To date, on a global scale, it is unclear whether reproductive traits represent multidimensional aspects of plant life, whether they are aligned with size and economic spectra of vegetative organs, or whether they constitute independent axes of variation (Leslie & Mander, 2023; Carmona & Beccari, 2025; Carta et al., 2025). However, a comparable framework for fruit traits remains lacking (but see Carta et al., 2024). We focus specifically on fruits because they remain markedly less represented and less integrated into functional ecology frameworks, even more compared to flowers and seeds. Here we build on Carmona & Beccari (2025) to examine the causes and consequences of overlooking fruit traits, hypothesize primary trait axes shaped by trade-offs and trait covariation, and propose a conceptual framework and research agenda to advance the integration of fruit functional ecology into the whole spectrum of plant life strategies. Fruit traits are arguably the most neglected of all traits – the true ‘ugly duckling’ of plant functional ecology. Fruits encompass a wide diversity of traits that have important implications for development, ripening, opening, seed packaging, and interactions with dispersers and antagonists (Valenta & Nevo, 2020). By modulating frugivory, seed dispersal, and seed predation, fruit traits can have pervasive consequences for plant reproduction, population dynamics, genetic diversity, ecosystem regeneration and resilience, colonization of new areas under changing climates, and ecosystem restoration (Beckman & Sullivan, 2023), ultimately generating and maintaining biodiversity. Fruit traits can be broadly classified as morphological, anatomical, chemical, display, or physiological (Table 1). Morphological traits (e.g. fruit mass, fleshiness, size and width) are by far the most studied and used in large-scale studies (e.g. Morán-López et al., 2025). Combinations of these traits are often described as dispersal syndromes, partly as an attempt to assign function to certain fruit traits (Van Der Pijl, 1982; Valenta & Nevo, 2020). Because fruit traits are correlated with other plant traits (Herrera, 1992, 2002) and climatic variables (Chen et al., 2017; Sinnott-Armstrong et al., 2021), attempts to build whole-plant spectra will be incomplete without integration of functional ecology of seed dispersal, one of the most vital steps of plants life cycle (Schupp et al., 2010). While some seed traits are well established in functional ecology and form one of the major axes in the global spectrum of plant form and function (Díaz et al., 2016), fruit traits – despite their tight ecological linkage to seed traits – remain far less integrated into these frameworks, largely because they involve additional dimensions of interaction with dispersers, defenses, and nutritional investments that cannot be captured by seed traits alone. Functional ecology and dispersal ecology have historically developed in parallel, a division illustrated by how researchers assign functions to fruit traits. From a dispersal perspective, fruits are primarily viewed as mediators of plant–frugivore interactions, with traits interpreted as the mechanistic link enhancing dispersal. This unidimensional approach obscures the fact that fruit traits also evolve under selective pressures from antagonists such as pathogens and seed predators (Valenta & Nevo, 2020), abiotic drivers including temperature and water stress (Ripoll et al., 2014; Valenta et al., 2018, 2022; Gómez-Devia & Nevo, 2024), and phylogenetic constraints (Messeder et al., 2024). Fruit traits may also be involved in multiple physiological functions such as photosynthesis maintaining a positive carbon balance (Cipollini & Levey, 1991) and transpiration contributing to overall plant water loss (Rossi et al., 2022). Fruit traits such as carbon and nitrogen content can affect decomposition processes after fruits fall from the mother plant, influencing nutrient cycling, soil fertility, and overall ecosystem productivity (de Paz et al., 2018). Therefore, assigning ecological function to a given fruit trait from a single perspective risks oversimplification. Fruit traits should be best understood as outcomes of multiple selective pressures. Frugivores and antagonists exert opposing pressures on pulp chemistry and seed packaging (Tewksbury & Nabhan, 2001; Ordano et al., 2017) while abiotic conditions may constrain fruit size, color, and nutritional composition. Secondary metabolites provide a clear example of this multifunctionality across seed dispersal stages: the same compounds can attract dispersers, deter pathogens, inhibit seed germination, alter protein assimilation, extend gut passage time, or act as toxins depending on context (Cipollini, 2000; Nelson & Whitehead, 2021). A first step toward advancing fruit ecological spectrum is to identify consistent patterns of trait correlations and trade-offs to conceptualize major trait dimensions. Still, evidence supporting fruit trait correlations remains taxonomically and geographically limited and is often inconsistent across studies (Clausing et al., 2000; Cazetta et al., 2008; Rojas et al., 2022; Valenta et al., 2022; Messeder et al., 2024). Consequently, the large-scale synthesis integrating the global spectrum of plant phenotypes envisioned by Carmona & Beccari (2025) is unfeasible at this stage. Nevertheless, some broad patterns have emerged. For instance, fruit fleshiness tends to be prevalent in tropical rainforests – reflecting the abundance and diversity of frugivores (Howe & Smallwood, 1982; Jordano, 2014) – and linked to growth-form, with trees more likely to produce fleshy fruits and herbaceous species predominantly having dry capsules (Jordano, 2014; Anselmo et al., 2025). However, temperate floras show different patterns with many dominant trees (e.g. Quercus, Fagus, Castanea, and Betula) producing dry fruits, whereas shrubs (e.g. Vaccinium, Rubus) and herbs produce fleshy fruits (Howe & Smallwood, 1982). This contrast highlights that the eco-evolutionary drivers underlying fruit traits may vary across biogeographic zones (Anselmo et al., 2025). Seed plants produce a wide diversity of seed-enclosing structures, from gymnosperm arils to dry fruits and accessory tissues, to fleshy fruits (Kourmpetli & Drea, 2014). Such diversity of structures represents functional investments in protection, attraction, and/or dispersal and pose significant challenges for trait integration. Here, we focus on fleshy fruit traits for which evidence is more developed and ecological complexity is greatest, but we also attempt to integrate dry fruits and fruits with accessory structures into the fruit economic spectrum allowing nonhomologous structures to be placed within a unified trait space. Building on this rationale, dry fruits fall toward the low-sugar, low-water end of the spectrum and are generally associated with cryptic displays, reflecting reduced investment in visual attraction and nutritional rewards compared to fleshy fruits. Such integration is challenging because fleshy fruit trait evolution and function are tightly linked to interactions with animals, involving multifaceted aspects of nutritional rewards, defensive chemistry, and dispersal behaviors. Dry fruits such as acorns and nuts share some of these functions, but others such as capsules often rely more on abiotic or autochoric dispersal, resulting in fundamentally different eco-evolutionary dynamics (Howe & Smallwood, 1982). Predicting the major dimensions of fruit trait variation is not straightforward. Fruits share developmental pathways with leaves, since carpels are modified leaves, suggesting that fruit traits might be constrained along spectra analogous to the leaf economics spectrum, shaped by axes of size and resource economy. Fruit development incurs substantial construction and maintenance costs (Bonte et al., 2012) and, in some cases, may even contribute to carbon balance through photosynthetic activity (Cipollini & Levey, 1991). To complicate matters further, fruits are closely integrated with seeds, such that strong correlations between fruit and seed traits are therefore expected (Paź-Dyderska & Jagodziński, 2024). Together, these developmental and physiological linkages impose constraints on fruit trait correlations that remain poorly understood, making it especially difficult to anticipate the primary axes of a fruit trait spectrum without empirical data. Building on McKey's (1975) seminal ideas of alternative plant strategies for frugivore-mediated seed dispersal through quantity vs quality trade-offs, we propose that the foundational dimension of fruit trait variation lies within the resource economics spectrum (Snow, 1971). This primary axis represents a continuum from acquisitive to conservative reproductive strategies (McKey, 1975). At the acquisitive end, species produce numerous small seeds enclosed in energetically inexpensive, carbohydrate- and water-rich pulp, promoting dispersal by a wide array of opportunistic frugivores. At the conservative end, species invest in fewer, larger seeds and in more costly rewards rich in lipids and proteins, representing a high-investment strategy that relies on a narrower, but consistent assemblage of frugivores that delivers higher-quality dispersal (Howe & Smallwood, 1982). This axis not only encapsulates the classical seed size–number trade-off (Smith & Fretwell, 1974) but also positions it within a broader framework of whole-plant resource allocation and reproductive investment. Despite criticisms (Howe, 1993), this trade-off in dispersal strategies can serve as the foundation of a broader fruit ecological spectrum, analogous to those proposed for other organs. The carbohydrate–lipid continuum in fruit nutrient composition encompasses additional dimensions of variation in fruit and seed size and in pulp-to-seed ratio, reflecting coordinated outcomes of resource allocation constrained by plant metabolism and life history (Fig. 1). These traits jointly define the morphological and nutritional axes of fruit form and function. High-quality fruits are often the target of antagonist invertebrates and microbes, requiring protection from defensive compounds (Herrera, 1982; Cipollini & Levey, 1997), but their relationships with nutrients also vary across ecological and biochemical contexts (Cipollini & Levey, 1997; Nelson & Whitehead, 2021). Because secondary metabolites vary in solubility, localization, and metabolic cost, their association with nutritional traits may differ across systems. For instance, lipid-soluble compounds may covary with lipid-rich rewards, whereas water-soluble defenses may show closer links with carbohydrate-rich fruits, resulting in context-dependent correlations or trade-offs (Tewksbury & Nabhan, 2001; Tewksbury, 2002). Consequently, nutrient–defense relationships are expected to be nonlinear and system-specific, reflecting an evolutionary balance between dispersal and defense (Schaefer et al., 2003). Together, these interacting axes define a multidimensional space of fruit functional strategies in which trade-offs between reward and protection shape both ecological outcomes and evolutionary diversification. The carbohydrate–lipid axis could be integrated into the broader plant ecological spectrum. However, its primary alignment may not be with the leaf economics spectrum, but rather with the plant size axis of the Unified Plant Functional Spectrum (UPFS). The strong integration between fruit and seed traits, coupled with known growth-form associations (e.g. woodiness), makes it plausible that the core acquisitive-conservative fruit continuum – correlated with size and grounded in the seed size–number trade-off – loads heavily onto this established size dimension. In this view, our proposed fruit spectrum is not an independent economic axis, but rather the dispersal-ecological expression of the plant size axis, enriched with functional details (nutrient composition, defense, display) critical for mediating seed dispersal. As such, species producing lipid-rich fruits may also exhibit slower, resource-conservative strategies, whereas carbohydrate-fruited species may align with faster growth and leaf turnover, thus integrating fruit traits in the global spectrum of plant form and function (Paź-Dyderska & Jagodziński, 2024). Species of Miconia, for instance, are classic fast-growing pioneers that invest in ‘acquisitive’ fruits: small, carbohydrate-rich, and water-filled, containing numerous tiny seeds (Messeder et al., 2021). Other classical examples include Ficus and Cecropia. This aligns with broader patterns of trait coordination; Paź-Dyderska & Jagodziński (2024) demonstrated that larger leaves and seeds are correlated with larger, heavier fruits. We therefore predict a general alignment where acquisitive, fast-growing species dominate the carbohydrate-rich, small-fruited end of the fruit spectrum (e.g. Melastomataceae, Moraceae and Urticaceae), whereas conservative, slow-growing species converge on the lipid-rich, large-fruited end (examples include Lauraceae and Myristicaceae, such as Virola spp.). However, although such trait coordination is expected, fruit strategies may decouple from vegetative strategies in some lineages or ecological contexts, and evaluating these patterns at a global-scale test remains a future priority. Even so, this model provides a relevant framework for generating and evaluating hypotheses on the evolutionary coordination of fruit traits within the whole-plant phenotype. Carmona & Beccari (2025) highlighted the need to address biases in trait databases, standardize methodologies, and integrate complex or categorical traits. Fruit traits exemplify this gap: they are rarely represented in major databases. For instance, in TRY (https://www.try-db.org/de/TabDetails.php) most of the 29 fruit traits listed remain under construction. Accordingly, only four datapapers currently provide fruit trait data (Bello et al., 2017; Kissling et al., 2019; Vaessen et al., 2023; Fuzessy & Pizo, 2025) (a Web of Science search for ‘fruit AND traits’ on 1 October 2025 yielded just 22 datapapers), underscoring the paucity and bias of available data. Data scarcity and fragmentation in the literature significantly limits our ability to detect general trends in fruit functional ecology, reinforcing the need for coordinated efforts to expand fruit trait coverage globally. Inspired by recent efforts to advance seed functional ecology (Saatkamp et al., 2019), we outline steps to accelerate progress in fruit functional ecology. Building on these needs, we propose a roadmap to integrate fruit traits into the UPFS: (1) data foundation: targeted mobilization of existing data and collection of new, standardized fruit trait data – particularly chemical and display traits – across biogeographic and phylogenetic gaps; (2) trait space definition: using harmonized data to empirically test the hypothesized acquisitive-conservative fruit spectrum and quantify its major axes of variation; and (3) modular integration: applying the modular framework by Carmona & Beccari (2025) to test whether the fruit spectrum operates as an independent module, aligns with the leaf or seed economics spectra, or exhibits context-dependent correlations with whole-plant strategies. Addressing biases in trait databases will require expanding data collection in understudied regions (e.g. Africa, Southeast Asia), for understudied traits (e.g. chemical and display traits), and across underrepresented plant lineages, particularly tropical endemics. Standardization is another key challenge. While a recently proposed handbook on plant reproductive traits now includes protocols for fruit size, fruit crop size, dry pulp-dry seed mass ratio, fruit color, fruit scent and fruit chemical compounds (Poschlod et al., 2026), this coverage is limited compared to the more extensive protocols available for flowers (Michelot-Antalik et al., 2025) and seeds (Poschlod et al., 2026). Expanding protocols for fruit trait measurement will be essential for achieving comparable datasets and advancing large-scale syntheses. Integrating fruit traits into the broader framework of plant functional ecology will also open avenues of research that bridges functional and dispersal ecology, including the development of deeper biogeographic and macroecological perspectives on biological invasions (Kueffer et al., 2009), community assembly (Albrecht et al., 2018), trait–environment associations (Almeida-Neto et al., 2008; Chen et al., 2017), co-evolutionary dynamics in fruit–frugivore interactions (Cosmo et al., 2023), and meta-analyses (Palacio & Ordano, 2018). In the meantime, while comprehensive and standardized fruit trait datasets remain to be assembled, projecting the limited data currently available onto the core vegetative trait space could allow for a short-term – albeit preliminary – solution for hypothesis testing (Carmona & Beccari, 2025). The question of whether fruit traits align with existing spectra or constitute independent dimensions is a central one, although still open, for the unified trait space (Paź-Dyderska & Jagodziński, 2024). We agree with the suggestion from Carmona & Beccari (2025) that this can be tested using their proposed modular extensions or trait network analyses. Ultimately, integrating this ‘ugly duckling’ will not only complete our picture of the plant phenotype but will also be essential for predicting plant responses to global change and for designing effective conservation and restoration strategies in an increasingly disrupted world. FAOS acknowledges support from FAPEMIG. We thank Owen Atkin (associate editor), Carlos P. Carmona, Eleonora Beccari, and three additional anonymous reviewers for their comments which helped improve our manuscript. We use LLM to polish the language. None declared. The New Phytologist Foundation remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in maps and in any institutional affiliations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Silveira et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: