Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The cost of propofol anesthesia varies significantly based on the anesthesiologist's technique and dosage, and can be economically comparable to desflurane.
To the Editor: Hospital administrators are demanding cost consciousness among their providers and threatening to discontinue certain medications from their formularies based on cost. To ensure that our patients receive the drugs that equate quality care, we as anesthesiologists must be able to justify our expenses. The study performed by Rosenberg et al. [1] comparing the cost of desflurane versus propofol is long overdue. Their reported cost of propofol per hour, however, appeared surprisingly high. To test this impression, I collected data from demographically similar patients Table 1 using the Arkive Data Management system (Diatek, San Diego, CA). One of the advantages of an automated record keeper is the ease at which cost comparisons of particular anesthetics are accomplished. Assuming a 20% wastage and the cost of propofol at $0.05/mL, the total cost of propofol was calculated as $11.78/h based on the formula used by Rosenberg et al. Table 2. This cost difference ($11.78 vs $44.08) was clearly a function of total dose. Whereas both of us titrated the propofol dose to clinical effect, the calculated average dose in my study was 46 +/- 3.4 (SEM) micro gram centered dot kg-1 centered dot min-1, whereas Rosenberg et al. used a range of 100-200 micro gram centered dot kg-1 centered dot min-1.Table 1: Patient demographicsTable 2: Cost of PropofolI am not sure how to explain this difference. Although the average weight of the patients I studied was less than that of Rosenberg et al.'s patients, the costs of propofol per hour for patients weighing <90 kg ($29.36) and >90 kg ($44.59) in Rosenberg et al.'s study were still 1-3 magnitudes above those reported in my study ($9.52 vs $31.35, respectively). The anesthetic management was also similar, with the exception that the patients in my study were allowed to breathe with assisted ventilation by mask without paralysis and were given an average of 28 +/- 3.5 (SEM) micro gram of sufentanil rather than the 50-150 micro gram of fentanyl used by Rosenberg et al. It would appear that the opioids used were of equal potency and dose, but maybe there is some hidden (although doubtful) advantage of sufentanil over fentanyl. The cost per hour of propofol in my study favorably compares with that reported by Rosenberg et al. for desflurane ($11.78 and $11.24, respectively). In my hands, I see no economic reason to change from propofol to desflurane. Since anesthetic techniques vary from anesthesiologist to anesthesiologist, their respective costs differ as well. It is important that anesthesiologists use Rosenberg et al.'s formulae to critically evaluate their personal anesthetic with the goal of providing the best care at the lowest cost. Thomas G. Johans, MD St. John's Mercy Medical Center, St.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomas G. Johans (1995) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: