Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While Biochar demonstrates agronomic potential for soil improvement, crop productivity, and carbon sequestration, limited research has examined adoption patterns and implementation barriers among small-scale farmers through a sustainability lens. Employing a qualitative self-study design, this community case study reflects upon biochar extension programming delivered by Civil Society Organization (CSO) extension practitioners across Southeast Asia. Authors found that despite biochar's consistently high interest among learners and established scientific merit, sustained, multiseason adoption among smallholder farmers remains limited. Observed patterns that constrain adoption across several Southeast Asian countries include the labor necessary to produce recommended volumes at the artisanal kiln scale, and significant opportunity costs within small-scale farming systems. Successful, sustained adoption generally emerged from two contexts: 1) strategic and intensive horticultural applications, such as within greenhouse, nursery, and small plot production settings, and 2) enterprise operations with a pre-existing biomass waste management problem, uniformly sized feedstock, and sufficient scale to access carbon credit markets. Practitioner reflections suggest that effective biochar extension programming should clearly communicate biochar's realistic agronomic benefits and timelines, and better target their programming toward high-return applications or as an enterprise development opportunity rather than in promoting biochar production and soil incorporation as a universally applicable, farm-level practice among small-scale farmers.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hung et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: