Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Historiographical analysis examines the conceptual entanglement of religion and race in Middle East studies, highlighting the role of historical distinction in evaluating modern categories of...
This introduction to the special section on “Concepts of Difference: Historicizing Religion and Race in the Modern Middle East” argues for history as a practice of distinction. Ongoing critical historical work within Middle East studies and without has argued not merely that the category of religion is particular to a modern European genealogy but, further, that it is historically coextensive with race. Here, there is tension that needs resolving: Should religion and race be conceived as two sides of the same coin, as this critical work sometimes suggests—two iterations of the same invidious Western mode of dividing and categorizing the world that has tended to position Europe/Christianity/whiteness at the apex of a civilizational hierarchy of difference? Or is the concept of religion problematic insofar as it racializes? At stake here is not just the question of a minimal difference between religion and race as concepts and practices that divide human reality, but also the place of distinction, judgment, and history in scholarship.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Henry Clements (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: