Evaluating Neural Radiance Fields for ADA-Compliant Sidewalk Assessments: A Comparative Study with LiDAR and Manual Methods

An accurate assessment of sidewalk conditions is critical for ensuring compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), particularly to safeguard mobility for wheelchair users. This paper presents a novel 3D reconstruction framework based on neural radiance field (NeRF), which utilize a monocular video input from consumer-grade cameras to generate high-fidelity 3D models of sidewalk environments. The framework enables automatic extraction of ADA-relevant geometric features, including the running slope, the cross slope, and vertical displacements, facilitating an efficient and scalable compliance assessment process. A comparative study is conducted across three surveying methods—manual measurements, LiDAR scanning, and the proposed NeRF-based approach—evaluated on four sidewalks and one curb ramp. Each method was assessed based on accuracy, cost, time, level of automation, and scalability. The NeRF-based approach achieved high agreement with LiDAR-derived ground truth, delivering an F1 score of 96.52%, a precision of 96.74%, and a recall of 96.34% for ADA compliance classification. These results underscore the potential of NeRF to serve as a cost-effective, automated alternative to traditional and LiDAR-based methods, with sufficient precision for widespread deployment in municipal sidewalk audits.