This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Sir, Growing interest in the assessment of quality of care and of ‘customer satisfaction’ has led to the application in the clinical setting of evaluation methods derived from other fields, such as marketing and political analysis. Focus groups belong to this approach; their flexibility is of interest in assessing strategies directed at new or niche products; the subjectivity and the link to emotional responses is both a resource and a limit of this approach as well as of most qualitative research [1,2]. The application of the focus group on dialysis is still limited [3]. Daily haemodialysis (DHD) and home haemodialysis can both be considered niche products: there is high theoretical interest in them, but they also have a ‘patchy’ and relatively low diffusion, reflecting the need for context-sensitive solutions [4–6]. Therefore, we tried to define a list of minimal requirements for a successful DHD programme (at home and in a dialysis centre) on the basis of a focus group including patients and caregivers with different experiences of dialysis and transplantation. The focus group involved 11 participants plus the facilitator-conductor, a caregiver in a satellite centre offering DHD to home and in-centre patients. There were six patients (out of 12 on DHD at the time of study), two family members, the two head nurses and one junior physician; the median age was 45 years (range 28–70), the educational level of patients and family members was in line with the urban northern Italian situation (three of eight, primary school; two university; three high school level). The common element was participation in a DHD programme for at least 6 months. The discussion lasted for about 2 h, was tape-recorded, transcribed and summarized; the results were separately discussed and approved in the final version by all participants. The questions chosen were broad-ranging and simple: imagine planning a ‘marketing strategy’ for DHD: what makes you happy with a daily dialysis programme? What are the main requisites for success? How would you organize a programme? The group was aware that the discussion would be at the basis of the planning strategy for a new DHD programme. The discussants identified seven points of practical interest (reported in Table 1). The ‘recipe’ for a successful daily dialysis programme Note: For comments on each individual point, see our website. The patients identified themselves as ‘elite’ of dialysis treatment, characterized by greater psychological acceptance and interest in all fields of treatment, thus suggesting that an educational approach may be an important tool for promoting DHD. The need for ‘stable flexibility’ has two components: continuity of care and personalized schedules as the consequence of non-standardized approach. DHD is intrusive in daily life, and the patients admit it. The importance of the vacation period is in line with the need to ‘reinvest’ the renewed well-being in those aspects of daily life, such as vacations, that are often neglected in the care of haemodialysis patients. Our pilot analysis has some limitations, first of all involving only a selection of ‘elite’ patients; however, the focus was on the definition of a ‘marketing DHD strategy’, and it was felt that only individuals with specific experience could contribute. A further step could be inquiring also on reasons for not choosing DHD widening the discussion with dialysis patients who chose different dialysis modalities in settings where DHD is available (cons of treatment), as well as involving patients and caregivers from settings where this option is not available (analysis of the expectations). As a closing remark, we would like to stress the importance of the commitment of patients and caregivers in this new adventure. This may also offer an interpretation for the strong ‘centre effect’, with a patchy distribution of DHD. As patients stated, without mutual trust there is no room for daily dialysis. Conflict of interest statement. None declared.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Piccoli et al. (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: