Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Prodigious Births:Black Infancy, Antebellum Medicine, and the Racialization of Heredity Laura Soderberg (bio) "I have heard," murmured Starbuck, gazing down the scuttle, "that in violent fevers, men, all ignorance, have talked in ancient tongues; and that when the mystery is probed, it turns out always that in their wholly forgotten childhood those ancient tongues had been really spoken in their hearing by some lofty scholars. So, to my fond faith, poor Pip, in this strange sweetness of his lunacy, brings heavenly vouchers of all our heavenly homes. Where learned he that, but there? Herman Melville, Moby-Dick "Prodigy" has historically been a double-edged term that joins the marvelous and the monstrous together to name a category of the unpredictable and unprecedented.1 This coupling of mental and physical difference with a separation from earthly constraints and temporalities drives the basic terms of Starbuck's analogy. Pip's so-called lunacy after he has been stranded on the ocean grants him divine revelation, much like a fever could reportedly spark the chanting of an ancient language. However, the analogy also draws on another, specifically racialized legacy of the prodigious as a disruption of genealogy that is concentrated in figures of black infancy but is by no means confined to them.2 Prodigy, as I discuss it here, is the tendency to treat blackness as unpredictable and, more pointedly, as existing outside of genealogy. Prior to genetic understandings of inheritance, antebellum medical discourse turned to black infants to construct their theories of heritability, treating them as markers of failed inheritance who were estranged from the normal course of time. This practice [End Page 217] in turn contributed to a persistent association of black infancy in the antebellum United States with medical abnormality and genealogical unpredictability. However, the logic of prodigy expanded outward, coming to treat black subjects more generally as always unexpected arrivals, stripped of chronology.3 As a character whose age is impossible to determine and whose stated origin ranges from Alabama to Connecticut, Pip is one particularly canonical example of a much broader cultural figuration that mystified the age of black people and worked to erase their genealogical continuity.4 Prodigy, in short, racializes by refusing heredity. The representation of black births and black people as prodigious in the Atlantic world pathologized and excluded black childhood from genealogy and asserted the instability of black populations. In my analysis, inheritance, or rather the exclusion from inheritance, therefore takes two primary meanings. First, in the days of early race science and shortly before the rise of genetic theory, the burgeoning science of inheritance sought to define how traits were passed from parent to child and to create racial boundaries based on these heritable traits.5 As it moved into literature, though, inheritance assumed a less clinical role in determining who can claim what history and what future. As Habiba Ibrahim's work on the aged black body has shown, black women were made into spectacles of "impossible age" in the nineteenth century as a way for white audiences to imagine national history on a scale beyond human lifespans.6 Conversely, the effect of prodigy discourse on the black infant operated on the dimension of family rather than nation, imposing a perpetual newness that erased the temporal depth of black kinship and gave white kinship its defining borders. Scholars of African American literature and U.S. cultural studies have increasingly traced how children of color were denied the conventional protections of childhood in the antebellum United States and have continued to be denied them since then.7 However, we know less about narratives that concern injured children of color in ways specifically premised on their age. When analyzing antebellum black childhood, scholars most often frame their analysis through the figure referred to as the "picaninny," a pejorative term that was common in white-authored descriptions of children with African or indigenous ancestry. The prodigy and the picaninny certainly overlap, but studying their cultural presence brings different set of questions into view. In my reading, the prodigy represents an inverse of the picaninny, which frames black childhood as a site of utter fungibility. As Jayna Brown shows, the word itself encodes the...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laura Soderberg (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: