Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While the 19th century witnessed an upsurge of women in ophthalmology in different parts of the world, Indian ophthalmology saw the evolution of women much later, but was more powerful and with a steep progress curve. To begin with, the evolution started with Dr. Charloette Louisa Ellaby, a Britisher who established the first women ophthalmic department at Bombay’s Khetwadi dispensary followed by the Department of Ophthalmology at the Cama Hospital.[1,2] Considering the social taboos, lack of education, gender bias, and family restrictions, the Indian women stayed deprived of the privileges of becoming doctors/ophthalmologists, for a very long time. However, there were few driven and dedicated women who made sure that their tiny steps leave deep marks for the future women ophthalmologists to follow. The credit for the success of these women goes not only to the great legends, but also to their determined parents/families which believed in their daughters and brought them up in an environment, encouraging them everyday to take up the task of evolution through the tough times. Legends like Dr. Sudha Sutaria, Dr. Vasundhara Kalevar, Dr. Sudha Awasthi, and Dr. Hameeda Saiduljafar broke the glass ceiling and laid down the building blocks for women in ophthalmology in India.[3] The way women see ophthalmology and the way the nation sees the women in ophthalmology have changed and evolved over the years, in India and worldwide. A delicate work–life balance is essential for the progress and success of women both at work and at home, to be able to enjoy life in its purest form. As per Dr Carol Shields, the epitome of a perfect work-life balance, the ‘5As’ include availability, affability, ability, affordability, and accountability.[4] The interesting fact is that the multitasking ability of women enables them to absorb these qualities in the right proportions, along with perfect execution of all the tasks assigned. An amalgam of knowledge, empathy, and curiosity makes great doctors, mothers, and researchers. The formation of Women Ophthalmologists Society (WOS) brought a sea change in the professional lives of women in ophthalmology in India. This society, founded in 2015, with approximately 3000 women ophthalmologists as members and 18 state chapters, has been instrumental in bringing about a revolution. Formed with the aim of improving the professional working environment, knowledge and skills for women ophthalmologists, WOS became a forum where women could come forward and discuss their unique challenges and solutions, which they were previously facing in isolation. The concept of this society is based on mentorship, wherein the seniors and more accomplished women contribute by mentoring several mentees, thus encouraging them to excel in their professional lives along with keeping a perfect work-life balance. This society works on the basis of overall participation, encouragement and to uplift, inspire and motivate eachother before self. When asked about the names of the founders, the answer humbly received was – “Each and every member of WOS is a founder. No specific name should be ideally mentioned as we have all grown together to build this society”. Scientific meetings are held throughout the year by WOS, which provides a platform to several newcomers to speak, upgrade and indulge in networking. The members are encouraged to take the lead and participate in all the academic events as chairs and as an integral part of the governing council. Even though the overall participation of women in the national and international ophthalmic societies has been relatively lower than men, we have witnessed a positive change over the years. Back in the time, Dr. Miss A. B. Laker was the first female president of the premier national level organization - All India Ophthalmological Society (AIOS), followed by Dr. Sudha Sutaria in 1991. After a long gap of 30 years, Prof Namrata Sharma made great strides by being the first ever female honorary general secretary of AIOS, which has led to evolution of the participation of women in governing councils. Considering the fact that women ophthalmologists often require to take breaks in their career, the concept of short-term fellowships, observerships and trainings, have resulted in significant skill enhancement. WOS has designed projects to teach the art of handling crisis as well as workplace harassment, and these are all led by women. Women-in-Research (WINR) is an arm of WOS which has led to an evolution by encouraging and surfacing research and emphasizing on the importance of this neglected entity. This arm aims at changing the scientific temper of the country by making research studies more accessible and feasible to women solo practitioners as well as at the institutions. Several new research projects were founded with and without governmental collaboration, along with the strong pool of research mentors leading this program. In 2020, the Rare Eye Diseases (RED) project was started by WOS with the aim of highlighting the rare eye diseases which require close attention. National registries are being created for 10 rare eye diseases under this wing, with active involvement of nearly 250 women ophthalmologists cross the country. The next phase will be provision of genetic analysis, genetic counseling, formation of support groups, and provision of low vision aids. The Women Ophthalmologists Worldwide (WOW) network, the idea of which was conceived in India, is now a strong international network of women ophthalmologists involving 29 countries and connecting several women ophthalmologists across the globe. It has been an important focus of the big evolution that is currently taking place amongst the women ophthalmologists in India. Recently, we conducted an online questionnaire-based IJO-WOS survey, wherein 529 women ophthalmologists from India participated over 48 h. The mean age of participants was 39.6 ± 9.3 years (range 25–86 years). The participants belonged to 37 Indian states/union territories. Majority of the participants were from Karnataka (n = 70, 13.2%), Telangana (n = 66, 12.5%), Uttar Pradesh (n = 64, 12.1%), and Maharashtra (n = 49, 9.3%). Out of the participants, majority were consultants (n = 437, 82.9%), followed by fellows (n = 46, 8.7%) and postgraduates (n = 38, 7.2%). We observed that 7.4% (n = 39) proudly held the position as heads of their respective department and 1.5% (n = 8) women stopped working. The mean duration of practicing ophthalmology was over 11.6 years (range 1–55 years). Majority of the participants were married (n = 454, 85.8%) and few were separated/divorced as well (n = 15, 2.8%). We observed that mostly, the women got married (n = 463) during postgraduation (n = 200, 43.1%) or before pursuing ophthalmology (n = 127, 27.4%). The interesting observation is that 198 (43.2%) women agreed that marriage did not affect their career at all. This shows the progressive, optimistic, and unstoppable attitude of the women. At the same time, 100 (21.8%) women stated that due to marriage, they were unable to pursue fellowship/specialty. Few women 17.5% (n = 80) had to reduce the number of hours dedicated to ophthalmology, while 15.9% (n = 73) women faced travel restrictions from their families (which could be a problem faced specifically in the Indian scenario). Even though it is a small number, it is unfortunate that 1.5% (n = 7) women had to stop working due to family restrictions. A total of 72.8% (n = 385) Indian women gracefully welcomed motherhood, with 49.8% having two children (n = 192) and 42.8% having one child (n = 165). Majority of women had their first born while practicing ophthalmology as consultants (n = 226, 59.6%). It is interesting to note that nearly 79.5% mothers (n = 303) agreed that motherhood put a temporary pause to their practice and career, with the mean loss being 10.5 months of work. Nearly half, that is, 49% of women (n = 259), thought that the breaks in their career hampered their clinical/surgical skills compared to their male colleagues [Fig. 1]. When it comes to the number of hours successfully being dedicated to ophthalmology by these women, it was observed that majority of them worked for 7–9 h a day (n = 290, 54.8%), with 26.1% (n = 138) working for 4–6 h per day.Figure 1: Pie-chart describing the question – “Do you think breaks in your career affected your clinical/surgical skill upgradation compared to your male colleagues?”Proudly 62.9% (n=333) women pursued fellowship after post-graduation, mostly being long-term national fellowships (n=231, 63.0%) [Fig. 2]. Commonly, Indian women took up the retina (n = 77, 22.2%), cataract (n = 64, 18.4%), or the cornea (n = 59, 17.0%) fellowship. However, despite specialization, women are mostly practicing comprehensive ophthalmology (n = 171, 32.3%) or cataract (n = 124, 23.4%). Assessing the indulgence into research, we noticed that majority of the women participated in 1–10 projects each (n = 204, 38.6%). The eagerness to explore something new was evident in this survey as 35.3% (n = 187) had interest in research. The median number of papers written was 2, with the range being 1–150.Figure 2: Graphic description of the distribution of women ophthalmologists pursuing fellowship after post-graduationAs per the study by Park et al.,[5] in North America, the proportion of women editors was 23%, whereas in India, this number still remains to be extremely low, that is, 9.5% (n = 50). A total of 71.6% of women (n = 379) were not a part of any governing council in state/nationally/internationally. Even though gender-based pay gap is often highlighted and spoken of in other professions, it was great to observe that 66.9% (n = 344) of women observed no pay gap at their workspace. Over time, hopefully, this number changes, but 29.1% (n = 154) women indulged in business management and have evolved as entrepreneurs. At the same time, community work is done by all the women which includes daily contribution by 18.5% women (n = 98). The women also participated enthusiastically in the mentor–mentee programs as a mentor (n = 137, 25.9%) or as a mentee, while the others have shown deep interest in the program and were looking forward to such interactions. As per the survey, majority of the women believed that their most desirous end-result in ophthalmology is patient satisfaction (n = 274, 52.2%), followed by surgical joy (n = 208, 39.6%), with lesser preference to clinical research (n = 18, 3.4%), fame and progress (n = 16, 3.0%), conferences and presentations (n = 6, 1.1%), and monetary benefit (n = 3, 0.6%) [Fig. 3]. Gill et al.[6] and Xierali et al.[7] stated that women remain under-represented in leadership positions academically, professionally, and in subspecialization, with less access to mentorship, and we agree with their observations based on our survey. However, we would like to disagree with the bias, discrimination, gender-based pay gap components as we believe that overshadowing a positive initiative with a negative thought process demotivates any gender with an unwarranted constant need for support, help, and self-pity.Figure 3: A pie-chart displaying the most desirous end-points in Ophthalmology by the woman ophthalmologists in IndiaThe inception of women in ophthalmology in India might have started a little later than the rest of the world, but it shall run a steeper course with an exponential rise over the coming years. The concept of women in ophthalmology as separate societies nationally and internationally is not to create an isolated subset or to provide a gender-based difference, but to encourage women to get out of their comfort zone and stand up in today’s world with widespread equality, for what they believe in the most - Passion for Ophthalmology, for a brighter tomorrow. “Equality is not in regarding different things similarly; equality is in regrading different things differently.” – Tom Robbins
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sharma et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: