Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
There have been few signif icant advances in our knowledge of hydrology and the re- lated environmental sciences during the last thirty five years.Furthermore, none of them has been used successfully in prac- tice.This means that we can provide only trivial or dubious answers to important en- vironmental questions.A quarter cenlury of research on evaooration has indicated that much of the superficiality of the environmental sciences can be attributed to the application of linear cause-and-effect ways of thinking to the cybernetic feed- back mechanisms that prevail in environmental systems.The resultant problems are particularily evident in the application of small scale processes to large environmentally significant areas and in the application of mechanistic con- cepts to the interactions between plants and their environments.A discussion of examples from studies in evaooration leads to the suggestion that we need a completely new approach which would recognize that a biological system can dif- fer from a physical system, lhat a large scale system can differ from the sum of its individual components and that a forest is not just a collection of trees.Such a concept is exemplif ied in the Gaia hypothesis, in the accomplishments of the Bergen School of Meteorology during the l92O's and in the development of the complementary relationship between areal and potential evapotranspiration.The Problem A perusal of the literature on hydrology gives the impression of a vital, vigorous science making great advances in the kind of knowledge needed to solve environ- mental problems.Thus, there are models to simulate missing data, models to provide real-time flood forecasts, models to predict the effects of deforestation and even models to predict the hydrological elfecls of increased carbon dioxide con- centralions.However, a more rigorous study reveals that the scientific basis for these models is derived from the untested working hypotheses that were published in the textbooks of the 1940's and 1950's.Klemes (1986) has presented examples to demonstrate how quickly the published qualifications can be forgotten and the hypotheses established as self-evident truths.The result is that we know so liille about hydrology that we think we know a lot.We have not only failed to develop a f und ol authenticated knowledge about hy- drology but we have failed to develop a discipline that would permit us to do so in the future.The superficiality that dominates hy- drology is symptomatic of what makes the environmental sciences as a whole so ineffective.lt is ridiculous to try to predicl the effects of comolex environ- mental changes, such as those associated with ozone depletion, acid rain, enhanced carbon dioxide concen- trations or desertification.without the 1.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
F. I. Morton (1990) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: