Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
• Eddy-covariance was used at two forest sites disturbed by windthrow with contrasting management. • Unmanaged site showed greater gross primary production but also higher ecosystem respiration. • Both sites showed similar levels of evapotranspiration. • The managed site had lower gross but higher net water-use efficiency compared to unmanaged site. • The unmanaged site turned into net carbon sink 17 years after windthrow. Windthrow is a major forest disturbance source in Europe. The impact of management (salvage logging) and no-management (deadwood left in ecosystem) treatments on carbon and water fluxes of Norway spruce stand affected by windthrow were analysed. The net ecosystem production (NEP), gross primary production (GPP), ecosystem respiration (R eco ) and evapotranspiration (ET) were measured with eddy-covariance tower during 2019–2022 period. Additional chamber gas-exchange measurements, and vegetation inventory were performed. The unmanaged site had greater vegetation diversity and plant abundance, with higher leaf area index (LAI). The managed site showed overall higher NEP, lower GPP, lower R eco , lower GPP based water-use efficiency (WUE GPP ), but higher NEP based WUE NEP , compared with unmanaged site. The ET showed no clear trend between the two treatments. The higher GPP of unmanaged site can be linked to greater abundance of herbaceous species, which showed significantly higher photosynthetic capacity than the tree species. Moreover, the higher WUE GPP of unmanaged site can be affected also by the higher LAI of the unmanaged site. Nevertheless, if the R eco is accounted for in WUE NEP , the differences between sites are reversed and the unmanaged site had lower WUE NEP compared to the managed site. The option to leave the disturbed site without management leads to more productive ecosystem (GPP), with greater species diversity and abundance, but also with greater R eco and lower WUE NEP . The discrepancy between WUE GPP and WUE NEP suggests that studies analysing natural ecosystems affected by disturbances should use WUE NEP to account for R eco carbon losses and avoid mis-interpreting the ecosystem carbon-water balance with WUE GPP .
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Petrík et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: