Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background It is well-known that heat treatment of food, such as grilling and frying may give rise to unwanted, harmful substances in food, so-called process contaminants. VKM summarized this in the previous risk assessment of grilled food from 2007. In 2022, the Norwegian Food Safety Authority asked VKM to update and summarize the knowledge on formation of processed contaminants in various food by different grilling methods, and to assess the risk this may pose. More specifically the tasks were: Identify process contaminants which are formed to a greater extent by grilling than by frying and create an overview of reported amounts of these process contaminants in various types of grilled food. Elucidate factors (for example grill type, grill method and food) that are important for the formation of the identified process contaminants in grilled food. If possible, based on available information, assess the health risks associated with the consumption of grilled food compared to fried food. Methods VKM prepared a protocol, published in February 2023, describing the scope and methods for this risk assessment. New knowledge since 2006 about the relationship between the consumption of grilled food and health outcomes in humans was collected through an umbrella review of systematic summaries on this topic. Information on which contaminants are formed in grilled food, the amount formed, and factors important for their formation were collected using non-systematic literature searches. Characterization of health hazards linked to the contaminants was obtained from assessments carried out by international risk assessment bodies. VKM considered that the identified data were considered sufficient for a quantitative risk assessment of exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), but not for other contaminants. The PAH exposure was estimated by a probabilistic approach, with two scenarios for the consumption of grilled food. This involved modelling e the content of PAHs in different grilled food items and exposure to PAHs. The total risk from dietary PAH exposure from was described by the margin of exposure (MOE) approach. Results Identification of process contaminants VKM identified several process contaminants formed during grilling. These were PAHs, PAH analogues such as chlorinated-PAHs and nitrated PAHs, polyphenols, heterocyclic aromatic amines (HAAs), 3- monochloropropane-1,2-diol (3-MCPD) and glycidyl esters, acrylamide, nitrosamines, nitrite, harmful Maillard reaction products, biogenic amines, 7-ketocholesterol, acridine derivatives, anthraquinone (ATQ), pyrazines, advanced glycation end products (AGE). For two groups of compounds, PAHs and HAAs, there was substantial or plausible evidence for higher concentration in grilled meat and fish than in fried food. There was few data available on process contaminants in other grilled food than meat and fish, such as e.g. vegetables and bread. Concentration data for PAHs in grilled food (mostly meat and meat products) was collected from a total of 81 studies. The highest concentrations of PAHs (BaP and PAH4) were found in campfire grilled sausages. Concentration data for BaP, regardless of grilling method, indicated variability ranging from levels below quantification limits to more than 100 ng/g in fatty pork meat and sausages. Most of the grilled food items had median BaP concentrations below approximately 1 ng/g but varied from 0.1 to 4.1 ng/g across all food items. The occurrence of the different HAAs in grilled food varied greatly, from below detection limits to about 50 ng/g. The concentrations could, however, be up to 240 ng/g for PhIP in very well-done grilled chicken, and with higher levels in meat than in fish. Factors (for example grill type, grill method and food) that are important for the formation of the identified process contaminants in grilled food. Main types of heat sources for grilling are electricity, gas, charcoal (lump charcoal, briquettes) and firewood. The type of heat source may influence the content of PAHs and HAAs differently. Other factors that may influence the formation of PAHs and HAAs include type of fuel, direct or indirect grilling, type of meat, distance from the heat source, grilling temperature, and grilling time. Contamination of food with PAHs may primarily occur through: (1) deposition on the food of fuel-related PAHs in smoke. Electric heating and gas emit no or little PAHs, while charcoal and in particular firewood may contribute significantly to PAH contamination. When using charcoal, the PAH emission is higher in the initial period after lighting the grill. (2) deposition of smoke from incomplete combustion (pyrolysis) of dripping fat onto the heating source or hot surfaces. Dripping fat on the heat source is a significant source of PAHs in grilled food and is related to the fat content of the food. Avoiding fat dripping directly on the heat source and diverting the smoke from the food may reduce PAH deposition on the food. Studies on the impact of marination are conflicting, as marination may both reduce and increase the content of PAHs. (3) over-heating the food resulting in burned surface during cooking. Temperature, proximity to the heat source, frequent flipping of the food, and cooking time are important for avoiding burning the food during grilling. HAAs are mainly formed in the crust or gravy by heating. Variables that affect the formation are (1) temperature and cooking time. Concentrations of HAAs increase with rising temperature, while regular turning of the meat during cooking reduce the surface temperature and mitigate HAA formation. (2) presence of precursors, such as creatine, reducing sugars and free amino acids in the food. More HAA is formed in lean meat than in fatty meat, fish or mixed products. (3) method of cooking, such as marination, may affect the formation of HAAs. Microwaving beef and chicken prior to charcoal grilling can reduce the content of HAAs. Health risk associated with consumption of grilled food The umbrella review of systematic reviews of epidemiological studies published since 2006 did not reveal additional knowledge on the association between consumption of grilled food and health outcomes in humans. Hence, the conclusion drawn in the previous VKM 2007 assessment remains pertinent, suggesting a possible association between intake of well-done fried or grilled meat and cancer in the colon, rectum, prostate, breast, and pancreas. It was beyond the scope of the present assessment to review original studies on the health effects of consumption of grilled food compared to other cooking methods. VKM therefore assessed the risk from exposure to process contaminants formed by grilling. VKM estimated PAH exposure in grilled food quantitatively based on scenarios of consumption of grilled food also including a background exposure of PAH from the rest of the diet. Due to lack of data, the risk from HAA exposure and other heat-induced contaminants could not be characterised. The PAH concentration distributions in various grilled food items based on the extracted information from the 81 identified publications were generated from all types of grilling methods, of which more than 60% of the data were from charcoal grilled food. Due to limitations in the database the data did not allow for differentiation among grilling methods. The cumulative concentration distribution in most of the foods showed a sharp increase in the PAH concentrations above the 75 percentiles. The simulated concentration at the 90- and 95-percentile may represent grilling methods known to increase formation of PAHs in the food. The highest concentrations of BaP were found in sausages grilled on campfire, and in hamburgers and fatty pork. The two grilled food consumption scenarios include only meat and salmon because of lack of occurrence data in other grilled food items, such as vegetables, bread and meat imitate. The scenarios illustrate possible consequences of different food preferences on the intake of PAHs from grilled foods. The scenario plate of 200 g grilled fat-rich meat contained fat rich pork meat, hamburger, sausages, and chicken with skin. The other plate with 200 g lean meat and fish contained beef, lean pork meat, chicken without skin and salmon. Based on concentration distribution of BaP and PAH4 in each food item on the plate the distribution of the contents of BaP and PAH4 on each plate was simulated. The exposure scenarios based on the two plates included background PAH exposure from the rest of the diet and 1 to 100 servings of each plate per year. Average daily intakes of BaP or PAH4 for one year were calculated. Risk was characterized by the MOE approach using BMDL10s for BaP and PAH4 from the EFSA risk assessment of PAHs in food from 2008 as reference points. VKM considers that exposure to PAH resulting in MOE below 10,000 is of public health concern. For the plate with lean meat and salmon the use of mean, median and 75 percentile exposure to BaP and PAH4 up to 100 servings per year, resulted in MOEs above 10,000. At the 90 percentile and 100 servings the MOEs were approximately 10,000 for BaP and slightly below for PAH4. For the plate with fat rich meat the MOEs for the scenario related exposures remained above 10,000 when consuming grilled fat rich meat with a mean BaP and PAH4 content up to 100 times a year. At concentrations equivalent to the 95 percentile of BaP and PAH4 the MOEs were below 10,000 when consuming grilled fat rich meat approximately 15 and 25 times a year, respectively. Using PAH4 as an indicator of total PAH exposure, instead of BaP, gave approximately the same result as that of BaP, with slightly higher MOEs for the fat rich meat plate and slightly lower for the lean meat and salmon plate. The impact of campfire grilling on exposure estimates and the associated MOEs was examined in a sensitivity analysis. Data on campfire grilled food was only available for food items on the fat rich meat plate. Excluding campfire grilled food from the fat rich plate substantially reduced impact on the mean, median and higher percentiles values for the contents of both PAH4 and BaP on the plate. The resulting MOEs were above 10,000 when consuming more than 100 servings per year of plates with a mean, median and 75 percentile content of BaP and PAH4. At a 95-percentile content of BaP and PAH4 the MOEs were above 10,000 for up to 30 servings per year. Due to limitations the database did not allow creation of exposure scenarios reflecting various grilling methods. The MOEs calculated from the mean, median and 75 percentile exposure to PAHs likely represent the use of varied grill methods and food not causing substantial PAH formation. This will probably apply to most grilling situations. The MOEs calculated for the 90- and 95-percentile exposures to PAH may represent frequent use of grilling methods known to increase formation of PAHs in the food, such as high temperature grilling with charcoal or even campfire for a longer grill time leading to well done food. Due to lack of data, the risk from HAA exposure and other heat-induced contaminants could not be characterised. The concentrations of HAAs seem to be higher in grilled meat than in fried meat, particularly when well done. Grilling of food is associated with higher and less controllable surface temperature than frying. As most of the HAAs are genotoxic and carcinogenic in rodents and some have been classified as possible human carcinogens, their formation during grilling may be of concern. Although not precisely known, it is plausible that several other heat-induced contaminants, such as of PAH-analogues, can occur in higher concentrations in grilled food than in fried food, as the mechanism of formation is presumed to be similar to that of the PAHs or due to a presumably higher and less controllable temperature in grilling. Uncertainty The uncertainties in this assessment are large. Exposure to PAH was estimated from simulated occurrence data and consumption scenarios. The health risk from exposure to PAHs in consumed grilled food characterised by the MOE approach may both be over- and underestimated. Due to lack of data, the health risk associated with exposure to heat-induced contaminants in grilled food other than PAH could not be assessed. Due to high and less controllable temperature during grilling, it is likely that HAAs and some other heat-induced contaminants may be present in higher concentrations in grilled food than in fried food. Therefore, the total risk associated with the presence of process contaminants in grilled food is likely to be higher than for PAH alone. Data gaps The main data gaps related to the health risk assessment of grilled food identified by VKM are the following: 1) systematic reviews on health outcomes related to consumption of grilled food in comparison with other cooking methods are lacking, 2) data on consumption of grilled food, food items, frequency of grilling and grilling method applied are missing, 3) data on occurrence of PAH and other heat-induced contaminants in food prepared by different grilling methods and by other comparable cooking methods are missing, 4) toxicological data on individual HAAs for better hazard characterization considering toxicokinetic differences between rodents and humans are missing, and 5) occurrence data on HAAs in grilled food analysed with controlled and validated analytical methods are missing.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mariussen et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: