Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I would like to commend the authors on their timely study of “Evaluation of Selfies and Filtered Selfies and Effects on First Impressions.” 1 Aesthetic surgery today faces a new era. Technological advancements have removed time and geographic constraints, allowing for instantaneous connections to be made across the globe. With so many potential connections available at the click of a button, image-driven first impressions have never seemed so important. Selfie or Snapchat dysmorphias have emerged as by-products of image-sharing on social media and are novel forms of body dissatisfaction whereby patients seek treatments to improve their selfie photographs or to look like their filtered images. As reviewed in the study, selfies have been demonstrated to portray an unnaturally wide nasal bridge, oftentimes creating false concern. Filtered selfies promote unrealistic changes such as altering skin complexion and eye brightness, slimming the jawline, widening the eyes, and increasing the intercanthal distance, which either cannot be achieved with any treatments, or require such intrusive procedures that the risk and morbidity to benefit ratio cannot be justified. Patient education and adjustment of “unrealistic and unnatural expectations” are, as the authors point out, of utmost importance during the surgical consultation. The study lays the groundwork for these discussions by focusing on the source of these concerns: the type of photograph shared on social media. They demonstrate that photographs taken with a digital camera (DC), free from the optical illusions of selfies or unnatural alterations due to filters, were rated significantly higher across all categories of the First Impressions Questionnaire than selfies, filtered selfies, and rear-facing smartphone camera photographs. Although the study produced results that are clinically applicable and useful, it also has some limitations that are worth discussing. The study is significantly weakened by photographic bias. Umbrella lighting, which creates a soft, flattering light that reduces contrast between highlights and shadows of the face, was only used with the DC photographs, whereas all other photographs were limited to room lighting. The ultimate effect of umbrella lighting is a more smooth and uniform skin tone and texture as evidenced in the sample images, which are characteristics inherently associated with attractiveness and markers of health.2 Additionally, although the evaluators were not able to compare different images of the same individual, it is reasonable to assume that the umbrella-lit DC photographs can be recognized based on these features. Because this style of photography is utilized for work-related headshots and resumes, it could have biased the evaluators’ perceptions of occupational and financial success. There are also limitations with the generalizability of the results of this study, due to demographics of both the study sample and the evaluators. Although the authors point out that millennials lead the way in social media usage and are influenced by their selfies in seeking aesthetic treatments, it is interesting to consider whether viewing photographs of people from different age groups and of different socioeconomic status would produce different results. The other cautionary limitation of this study requires a cognitive and behavioral approach. Should we do as the study suggests and use external perceptions as a discussion point for a problem and vulnerability created by the desire to appease external validators? Would the proposed “cure” be better than the “disease?” Arguably not, if that is all that we rely on. The desire to undergo potentially invasive and risk-inherent procedures to seek validation of one’s photograph is perhaps the most potent manifestation of undue external pressure for plastic surgery. Other studies have demonstrated that social media usage is associated with increased body dissatisfaction, risk of eating disorders, and pursuit of cosmetic surgery.3-5 We know from experience that patients with body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) do not experience improvements in their quality of life following aesthetic surgery, and may continue seeking surgeries, or shift their dysmorphic focus to a new area of concern.6 For patients with BDD or eating disorders, discussions solely centered on societal perceptions of health and beauty is often futile, as the disorders commonly arise as overexaggerations of such perceived external standards. Adjustments in cognitive and behavioral patterns are often required for successful treatment. Selfie or Snapchat dysmorphias are commonly not as severe as BDD or eating disorder along what is likely a continuum of body dysmorphia. Nevertheless, the need for patient education and cognitive realignment remains paramount during surgical consultation and prior to any treatments. We must educate patients presenting with selfie or Snapchat dysmorphias against internalization of external perceptions of beauty, especially when these constructs are fabricated or incompletely conveyed. Beauty is a complex construct and a product of evolutionary biology that continues to change. Patients seeking “ideal proportions” or the “golden ratio” are commonly inadequately informed about the many dimensions of the paradigm of beauty.7 Although such standards can be useful guides, beauty is also a celebration of individual differences and uniqueness, including culturally identifying features.8 Patients driven by social media pressures must be made aware of optical illusions and distortions created by cameras. It is equally important to remind patients that despite the importance of digital media, humans cannot be reduced to 2-dimensional images; rather, our bodies move and interact, and it is not only features but micro- and macro-expressions, body language, and behavior, among other features, that inform true attractiveness. A proportionally ideal face that moves unnaturally is not considered beautiful. Unrealistic expectations must be realigned with discussions of risks and morbidities of procedures and what is surgically and ethically achievable.9 This study provides a good first step in guiding our surgical consultations in the face of social media-driven dysmorphias, but a more comprehensive approach to patient education and, in some circumstances, cognitive realignment is necessary. The author declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and publication of this article. The author received no financial support for the research, authorship, and publication of this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maryam Saheb-Al-Zamani (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: