Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Editor’s note: The opinions expressed in this editorial do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the AAMC or its members. More than 200,000 full-time faculty members serve in U.S. medical schools.1 Most of these are academic physicians appointed in clinical departments as clinician educators.2 Clinician educator faculty are at the front lines of clinical care and medical education, establishing the learning environment for medical students, residents, and fellows.3,4 As the number of clinician educator faculty has surpassed that of the tenured and tenure-track faculty over the past 4 decades,2 medical schools and their academic health systems have increasingly relied on the efforts and contribution of clinician educators across the 5 missions5 of academic medicine.6,7 Clinician educators hold expanded, critically important roles as primary care and specialty clinicians, teachers, advisors, training program directors, continuing education lecturers, clinical researchers, science communicators, public health advisors, and institutional and health system leaders. Clinician educators, moreover, work across varied settings on interprofessional teams in inpatient, surgical, and ambulatory sites in academic and community contexts. In some institutions, clinician educators may also maintain private practices or work as independent contractors, providing services in activities outside of their academic ones. Medical schools and academic health systems dedicate resources to train, attract, and retain clinician educators.8,9 About half of MD-granting medical schools in the United States have curricular structures to prepare students for future careers as clinician educators, according to one recent study.8 The collaborative milieu and professional opportunities in the academic workplace are seen as strengths by clinician educators.10–12 That said, loss of clinician educators from academic medicine has been a persistent concern,13,14 heightened since the pandemic.15 Studies related to faculty well-being have documented that clinician educators carry heavy workloads, receive lower compensation than in other practice settings, and are at risk for professional exhaustion and burnout.16 In addition, over time, the academic expectations of clinician educators have matured and become more rigorous as their roles have grown. Medical schools require evidence of clinical and educational excellence when hiring clinician educator faculty members. At the time of reappointment or promotion, some medical schools require substantial documentation of clinical expertise, teaching skills, local, regional, and national reputations, and overall contribution to the clinical and education missions of the institution. Many medical schools have adopted the practice of including medical educator portfolios with promotion materials.17 Such portfolios provide evidence of the impact and range of a faculty member’s educational activities, e.g., in teaching, mentorship, curriculum development, assessment, and/or educational innovation and scholarship. Such documentation enables clinician educators to characterize their contributions at and beyond the local institutional context. In this issue of Academic Medicine, the specific role of clinician educators in delivering competency-based medical education is highlighted in a report by Mahan et al,18 who characterize the activities of a workgroup convened in 2020 by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education, the Association of American Medical Colleges, and the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine. The workgroup was charged with developing and refining a set of competencies, subcompetencies, and milestones for clinician educators. After a multistep iterative process, including gathering insights from the published literature, receiving input from a diverse sample of clinician educators, and soliciting public comment, the workgroup finalized an assessment framework named Clinician Educator Milestones, which was released in 2022.18,19 The Clinician Educator Milestones have 5 levels, from novice to expert, across 5 competency domains: lifelong learning; educational theory and practice; well-being; diversity, equity, and inclusion; and administration. The approach is proposed for use by faculty members for self-assessment or assessment in collaboration with a “trusted peer” in support of “lifelong growth and development as educators.” The workgroup further suggests that the Clinician Educator Milestones model may be used for “systematic evaluation of faculty in programs, departments, institutions, and disciplines.” The model is recommended as a tool to help identify faculty who may benefit from “focused” faculty development interventions to strengthen teaching skills or address teaching deficits.18 The Clinician Educator Milestones may become an invaluable resource for academic medical institutions, following on milestones work introduced and refined over many years in postgraduate medical education. The Clinician Educator Milestones’ levels and domains can inform the design and evaluation of faculty development programs, for example. A recent scoping review by Alexandraki et al9 identified faculty development programs for clinician educators as limited and concluded that program evaluation efforts to determine institutional impact, in particular, receive insufficient attention. Ideally, the Clinician Educator Milestones can also address challenges related to assessment of clinician educator faculty in their academic roles, which may better anchor promotion criteria and procedures within and across medical schools. It is long acknowledged that promotion criteria and procedures for clinician educators vary widely.6,7,20 Clinician educators may spend long careers at junior rank, though they may have had transformational impact, locally, regionally, or nationally. This lack of progression may occur because the institutional criteria for promotion are poorly matched to the roles of clinician educators in academic environments, which may be better attuned still to the traditional model of the tenure line.6,20 The Clinician Educator Milestones, although perhaps narrow in scope given the array of different roles fulfilled by clinician educators, could nevertheless be helpful in bringing more alignment and consistency to promotion criteria and evaluative practices in medical schools. That said, and as acknowledged by Mahan et al,18 the validity of the Clinician Educator Milestones has yet to be established. Other limitations for the proposed milestones relate to whether the approach will be feasible, adequate, beneficial, or even accepted, in light of the varied activities and heavy workload of clinician educators. It is unclear whether the current methodology will be sufficient to discern meaningful differences in skills and real-world performance of faculty. In addition, the Clinician Educator Milestones are intended for use in both formative and summative assessment activities, and their proposed uses are remarkably broad, e.g., engagement by an individual for self-assessment or by an institutional supervisor for faculty member evaluation. Another potential critique relates to the rationale for the Clinician Educator Milestones. The need to adopt the approach may not yet be clear for faculty members as they navigate their careers. Similarly, leaders of departments and institutions may not see the “case for change” if they have already developed and implemented other measures for evaluating the academic abilities and contributions of their clinician educator faculty. The manifold contributions of clinician educator faculty clearly deserve greater recognition. The Clinician Educator Milestones, for these reasons, represent a welcome development and an opportunity in academic medicine. The 5-level, 5-competency domain model and its proposed applications require ongoing consideration and systematic study to establish validity, utility, and benefit to the field. Efforts to create a national conversation to characterize what constitutes excellence in the work of a clinician educator, across a full range of activities and with clear markers of progression, may help bring greater clarity and rigor in academic promotion for clinician educators. Additional experience and data gathering will help determine whether and how the Clinician Educator Milestones can bring value to clinician educators, individually and as a group, to their institutions, and more broadly to the field of academic medicine. • This issue features the 66 Trainee-Authored Letters to the Editor accepted in response to our 2023 call asking for letters about why mentorship matters. For an overview of the trainee-engaged selection process, see the introduction by Dilpreet K. Kaeley, assistant editor for trainee engagement, and journal staff editor Laura Blyton.21 The trainee letters immediately follow the introduction.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laura Weiss Roberts (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: