Why the study?
Does aerobic dance with arms overhead elicit a disproportionately greater increase in heart rate compared to treadmill running in healthy females?
Does aerobic dance with arms overhead elicit a disproportionately greater increase in heart rate compared to treadmill running in healthy females?
Low-intensity aerobic dance, regardless of arm position, elicits similar cardiovascular and sympathetic responses as treadmill running.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Overhead arm positions during low-intensity dance do not disproportionately raise heart rate versus running; leaves open effects in other populations or intensities.
Aerobic dance has been reported to result in a disproportionately higher heart rate than running at a similar percent of VO2max. It has been suggested that the extensive use of the arms overhead during aerobic dance results in an increase in sympathetic outflow thereby disproportionately increasing the heart rate. To compare the hemodynamic and sympathetic nervous system activity responses during aerobic dance and treadmill running, nine healthy females exercised at approximately 50% of their VO2max during each of the following three exercise trials: aerobic dance where the arms were used extensively overhead (ABOVE), aerobic dance where the arms were kept below the shoulders (BELOW), and treadmill running (TR). Mean heart rate values during the ABOVE, BELOW, and TR trials were 136 beats.min-1 for all three trials. Mean VO2 values during the ABOVE, BELOW, and TR trials were 1.48, 1.51, and 1.47 l.min-1, respectively, and were not significantly different. Mean cardiac output for the ABOVE, BELOW, and TR trials were 13.5, 14.0, and 13.0 1. min-1, respectively, and were not significantly different. Postexercise blood lactate and norepinephrine values were not significantly different among the three trials. These results suggest a similar relationship between heart rate and VO2 during low intensity aerobic dance and running and do not support the contention that the use of the arms overhead during aerobic dance exercise elicits a disproportionately greater increase in heart rate as compared with running. Additionally these results demonstrate similar cardiovascular and sympathetic nervous system responses between aerobic dance exercise and running.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Berry et al. (1992) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: