Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Professional mental health organizations widely embrace gender-affirmative therapy as an approach to supporting transgender (trans) clients in their identities, shifting away from historically pathologizing views. However, an increasingly influential gender exploratory therapy movement now urges therapists to probe trans clients’ identities for pathological causes, presenting their model as a neutral alternative to both affirmation and “conversion” or change therapy rooted in conservative religious beliefs. Using a qualitative, comparative content analysis, I examine the discursive strategies that advocates of gender exploratory, change, and affirmative therapies use to legitimate their models. I find that although gender exploratory therapy advocates assert a boundary between their practices and religious change therapy, these models involve similar interventions based on a construction of trans identities as unhealthy deviations from “biological” reality. Moreover, both exploratory and change therapy advocates strategically mobilize doubt to challenge professional and state regulations and promote their favored practices. These results integrate literatures on boundary work and the politics of doubt to illustrate how professional movements legitimate interventions that contradict prevailing health-scientific knowledge. Additionally, this analysis contributes to trans studies by elucidating framing processes that potentially disseminate re-pathologizing views of trans identity to diverse audiences.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maddie Kerr (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: