Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Outdoor daylight exposure is an important component of daily light exposure and may provide useful context for built environment field studies, but it is difficult to capture in a practical and time-sensitive way. Wearable light sensors can provide detailed exposure data, but they require equipment, calibration, data processing and participant compliance. Questionnaires are easier to use, but a simple question about total time outdoors treats all outdoor minutes as equal. This is a limitation because daylight exposure depends not only on how long a person is outdoors, but also on when and where that exposure occurs. The same 30-min outdoor period may therefore represent a different daylight exposure if it occurs in the early morning rather than around midday, or in a different city, season or weather context. This study developed a questionnaire-based method for estimating outdoor daylight exposure in field studies of the built environment and compared two estimates derived from the same self-report grid. The method was applied to a university library field dataset collected at the UCL Bartlett Library in London, with 193 cleaned participant records. Participants reported when they were outdoors, defined as being outside without a roof above the head, using 15-min intervals between 07:00 and 16:00. They completed the grid separately for regular workdays and free days, referring to typical days during the previous 4 weeks. The first estimate calculated the total reported outdoor exposure duration in minutes/day. The second estimate combined the reported outdoor intervals with interval-specific daylight availability weights derived from a representative late-autumn weather profile for the London St James’s Park location, producing a time- and irradiance-weighted estimate in lux⋅hour/day. Among the 179 participants included in the main method-comparison sample, the duration-only and time- and irradiance-weighted estimates were strongly associated (Pearson r = 0.913; Spearman ρ = 0.870; R 2 = 0.833). This indicates that the weighted estimate remained closely related to the simpler duration-based measure. However, 16.7% of the variance in the weighted estimate was not explained by duration alone, and 45 participants (25.1%) were assigned to a different low-, medium-, or high-exposure group when timing and site-specific daylight availability were included. These findings show that exposure classification can be sensitive to whether temporal daylight availability is incorporated, but they do not establish that the weighted estimate is more accurate or more predictive than duration-only reporting. The weighted estimate should therefore be treated as an optional, fit-for-purpose, macro-scale contextual proxy for studies in which exposure timing or broad site- or season-specific daylight context is analytically important. Duration-only reporting may remain adequate when overall time outdoors is the primary construct of interest. Validation against participant-worn light measurements is required before claims regarding accuracy or superiority can be made.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tunahan et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: