Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
NE Asia seems like a non-region: it is less integrated than ASEAN, there is merely a socialisation process of China, Japan and Korea trilateral summitry but its institutionalisation is weak. At present they all try to minimise political constraints from economic inter-dependence and keep as much policy space as possible. NE Asia cultivates a sacred idea of sovereignty and nationalist exclusion of the ‘Other’. A national conception of development has led to the consolidation of the nation state in Asia, able to exercise sovereignty as a pre-condition for co-existence and cooperation, but also for fierce competition. This prompts the question whether NE Asia actually needs regional integration at all: states may not be integrating regionally but internationalise because so much of their economic and security interactions are with outside partners. Thus concepts of regionalism which explain ASEAN integration processes do not apply to NE Asia. I argue that this lack of integration is due mainly to the moralization gap and victim-perpetrator roles and related defensive use of international law. The shadow of the 20th century is hanging over dynamic 21st century NE Asia. Hence, I believe that NE Asia’s regional society will remain characterised by a two level dynamic: economic and social interaction will increase with limited spillover to the political level, which will seek control and proceed incrementally through functional intergovernmental multilateralism (trilateral FTA, education cooperation). A supranational institutionalisation is unlikely and subject to political decisions to overcome historical animosities, sacral interpretations of sovereignty and instrumental use of international law.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Uwe Wissenbach (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: