Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We read with interest the article by Barakat et al. [1], which investigated two pharmacokinetic models for propofol to determine which model better correlates with the clinically observed effect as assessed by the Observer Assessment of Alertness/Sedation (OAAS) score and the Bispectral index. The authors administered propofol by target controlled infusion (TCI) using the Alaris Asena PK® pump. Although the implementation of the ‘Schnider Model’ in the Alaris pump uses our pharmacokinetic model [2], the authors seem to have been unaware that the Alaris pump does not use our ‘carefully developed’ke0 [3]. When our ke0 (0.456 min−1) is combined with our covariate adjusted pharmacokinetic model, the result is a longer time to peak effect-site concentration following a bolus (tpeak) in the elderly than in the young. In contrast, the Alaris pump uses our median tpeak value (1.6 min) which we obtained from visual inspection of our EEG data. Our tpeak algorithm [4] is then used to calculate a unique ke0 value for each individual, so that all individuals, whether young or old, will have an age-invariant tpeak of 1.6 min. This change in ke0 not only affects the time course of the predicted effect-site concentrations, it also affects the loading dose calculations. This is because ke0 is one of the parameters that determines Vdpe (the volume of distribution at the time of the peak effect-site concentration). The authors used the Tivatrainer® to simulate the predicted effect-site concentrations achieved by the Alaris pump. However, the default ‘Schnider Model’ in the Tivatrainer uses a ‘constant ke0’ (whereas the Alaris pump uses a ‘constant tpeak’). Thus, the predicted effect-site concentrations for the ‘Schnider Model’ used in the analysis by Barakat et al. are incorrect. Unfortunately, the concentrations simulated with the ‘Marsh Model’ pharmacokinetics based on the ‘Schnider Model’ infusion rates are also incorrect (because the dose calculated by the Tivatrainer is different to that actually given by the Alaris pump). We believe that the authors would be wise to re-evaluate their simulations using the correct model, because the ‘constant ke0’ and the ‘constant tpeak’ implementations of the ‘Schnider Model’ are definitely not the same.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Schnider et al. (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: