Key result
Heidelberg Mortality Risk Score predicts 90-day post-hepatectomy mortality more accurately than labMELD with C-index ~0.84.
Why the study?
Preoperative mortality risk assessment by scoring systems remains debatable as liver surgery indications expand and procedure complexity increases.
Does the Heidelberg Mortality Risk Score more accurately predict 90-day mortality than the labMELD and P-POSSUM scores in adults undergoing liver resection?
Cohort (n=529)
No
Does the Heidelberg Mortality Risk Score more accurately predict 90-day mortality than the labMELD and P-POSSUM scores in adults undergoing liver resection?
The Heidelberg Mortality Risk Score provides superior preoperative prediction of 90-day mortality after liver resection compared to labMELD and P-POSSUM scores, aiding preoperative patient selection.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May improve preoperative selection for liver resection; leaves open prospective validation before routine use.
BACKGROUND: Indications for liver surgery are expanding fast and complexity of procedures increases. Preoperative mortality risk assessment by scoring systems is debatable. A previously published externally validated Mortality Risk Score allowed easy applicable and precise prediction of postoperative mortality. Aim of the study was to compare the performance of the Mortality Risk Score with the standard scores MELD and P-POSSUM. METHODS: Data of 529 patients undergoing liver resection were analysed. Mortality Risk Score, the labMELD Score and the P-POSSUM Scores (PS, OS, P-POSSUM mortality %) were calculated. The ROC curves of the three scoring systems were computed and the areas under the curve (C-index) were calculated using logistic regression models. Comparisons between the ROC curves were performed using the corresponding Wald tests. RESULTS: Internal validation confirmed that the risk model was predictive for a 90-day mortality rate with a C-index of 0.8421. The labMELD Score had a C-index of 0.7352 and the P-POSSUM system 0.6795 (PS 0.6953, OS 0.5413). The 90-day mortality rate increased with increasing labMELD values (p < 0.0001). Categorized according to the Mortality Risk Score Groups the labMELD Score showed a linear increase while the POSSUM Scores showed variable results. CONCLUSIONS: By accurately predicting the risk of postoperative mortality after liver surgery the Mortality Risk Score should be useful at the selection stage. Prediction can be adjusted by use of the well-established labMELD Score. In contrast, the performance of standard P-POSSUM Scores is limited.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Knoblich et al. (2020) conducted a cohort in Liver resection (hepatectomy) (n=529). Heidelberg Mortality Risk Score vs. labMELD Score and P-POSSUM Scores (PS, OS, P-POSSUM mortality %) was evaluated on Prediction of 90-day postoperative mortality (area under the ROC curve / C-index) (C-index 0.8421 vs 0.7352 (labMELD) and 0.6795 (P-POSSUM), 95% CI 0.7675-0.9167, p=0.0163). The Heidelberg Mortality Risk Score predicted 90-day mortality after liver resection more accurately than the labMELD Score and P-POSSUM mortality.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: