Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I applaud the recent statement by the American Academy of Pediatrics1 which states that, as community pediatricians, we promote the health and well-being ofall children in the community. It is important because it addresses the idealistic principles that motivated many of us to become health professionals (before mortgages and overheads became realities), and provides a framework from which to teach students, residents, and peers an essential style of medicine for the 21st century, with its plethora of new, more difficult to treat morbidities.The tenants of community pediatric care so elegantly expressed in the original statement ring true to the idealist in many of us. The practicality, however, is more sobering. Haggerty2addressed this issue to some degree in his commentary.Teaching community pediatrics according to the principles of the Committee's definition is possible. However, the effectiveness of this teaching does not occur so much in academic discussion of community medicine, but, as Haggerty mentioned, through the real-life mentoring by those community practitioners who live the difficulties of volunteering time and energy while engaging in holistic community pediatrics and supporting an office.The practice of community pediatrics is a much more interesting point to me. Haggerty states that it can be practiced, but with difficulty. It will remain unpracticed if we depend solely on convincing more idealists to engage in such work. The resources that allow pediatricians to immerse themselves in practical community-based 21st century medicine cannot be short-term. Tackling the new morbidities requires long-term commitment. Communities do not need to have their hopes raised by a brief burst of potential from a funded provider, only to be crushed by a retreat to the survival mode when funding programs fizzle.We must think and begin a dialogue beyond the box if community pediatrics is to become a practicality. A model does exist to support pediatricians so that they need not sacrifice their personal lives and family for the community good and endure the tides of project funding. The model is deceptively simple. The community at some level supports, by paying for, this particular form of community pediatrics. This is not a hypothesis, but is a model in use in my health care community. What it has allowed me to do is remarkable enough that it warrants further study.My experience of this model of community pediatrics functions in the following manner. A tribally administered Indian Health Service clinic serving all Native Americans in an urban county decided to hire a pediatrician, their first, in an otherwise family practice-dominated clinic that had been in existence for almost 20 years. They agreed that this pediatrician would work 60% of his/her time in clinical duties and 40% in “health promotion and disease prevention.” Therein lies part of the success of this model. It was the community that decided the worth of community pediatrics and committed themselves to support this long-term provision of care.Based on my 3 years of experience in community pediatrics, the challenges I see are relatively few. They include:The benefits, on the other hand, are numerous:My contention is that this model of community pediatrics is not difficult to practice. This model is difficult to stoppracticing because it is so rewarding. It embodies the ideal that so many of us dreamt of—the ideal scenario the Committee recently defined in their statement. This model deserves development in other communities.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cliff O’Callahan (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: