The spontaneous memory symptoms of 100 brain-damaged patients suffering from a variety of conditions were elicited. The most frequent types of symptom related to memory for people's names, memory for recent events occurring a few days or weeks ago, memory for a spoken message and remembering to do something. The spontaneous symptoms from 50 non-brain-damaged patients were also elicited. There was a considerable degree of overlap between the type and incidence of symptoms in brain-damaged and control patients. Some symptoms (e.g. remembering people's names) were reported by a similar proportion of control as brain-damaged patients. A few symptoms (e.g. spatial disorientation, temporal disorientation) were reported by brain-damaged patients but not by any control patients. One symptom (remembering to do something) occurred more frequently in the control group of patients than in the brain-damaged group. The relationship between memory symptoms and memory performance was examined in a group of head-injured patients. A short questionnaire on memory symptoms was completed by each patient and by a close observer, and the head-injured subjects also performed tests of immediate and delayed recall. Although there was a highly significant correlation between degree of memory impairment as perceived by the patient and as perceived by an observer, there was generally a low correlation between subjective or observed memory impairment and scores on commonly used clinical memory tests.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kapur et al. (1983) studied this question.