Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
At the 2011 annual meeting of the Pediatric Academic Societies participants debated whether the duration of pediatric residency should be extended. Those favoring a longer residency argued that there is more to learn now than 30 years ago and, because of regulations curtailing resident work hours, less time in which to learn it. Their opponents argued that the purpose of residency is basic competence, not mastery, and there is still sufficient time and flexibility for residents to achieve basic competence. Moreover, adding time to the residency would be prohibitively expensive.A proposal to extend residency is a simple (and simplistic) solution to complex issues. In addition to the increase in medical knowledge in recent decades, the scope of pediatrics has widened, and subspecialization has progressed; learners' exposure to various aspects of pediatrics is now occurring, if at all, in distinct and separate silos. Although setting basic competence, rather than mastery, as the outcome measure may seem reassuring, defining “basic competence” is challenging: does the term refer to a basic level of competence in the vast breadth of pediatrics or to competence in a narrow basic “core” of pediatrics? This is a fundamental distinction for educators, future pediatricians, and the public, and there are implications for length of medical school and residency training and breadth of experiences required or necessary during training. The Association of American Medical Colleges is undertaking a pediatrics redesign project for students interested in pediatrics that begins in the second year of medical school and progresses to the end of residency.1 Transition from medical school to residency and residency to practice will be based on competence rather than time. This effort is an exciting opportunity to create a true continuum of learning, but the results of the project will not be known for quite a while and, in the short-term, will only involve a small number of students. In the meantime, the vast majority of future pediatricians, and their teachers, face the daunting task of ensuring adequate preparation for residency after completion of medical school and readiness for unsupervised practice after completion of residency in the current system. One approach to enhancing the likelihood that future pediatricians are broadly competent is to better use opportunities available in the fourth year of medical school.The minimum amount of time required for each learner to achieve basic competence in the broad discipline of pediatrics is not known. Educators who design curricula to ensure broad competence face at least 2 obstacles. The first obstacle is lack of exposure. Because learning opportunities in the various subspecialties have developed as separate months (or “educational units”), medical students and residents are likely to have little or no exposure to children with conditions in 1 or more of the subspecialties. For example, unless medical students and residents commit 1 month to an endocrinology elective, their only exposure to pediatric endocrinology is likely to be a child admitted to the hospital with diabetic ketoacidosis. Some specialty opportunities, administered by departments other than pediatrics, are particularly “out of sight and out of mind,” including areas identified repeatedly as weaknesses by graduates of pediatric residency training, such as office orthopedics.2The second major issue is the lack of oversight in the fourth year. Despite the general consensus that medical education needs to be reformed,3 little attention has been directed toward the fourth year.4 In most medical schools, the time between completion of the required clerkships and graduation is loosely organized and has few requirements other than completion of a subinternship.4–6 There is no national set of objectives or competencies that describe the fourth year, which results in flexibility (a good thing) but at the expense of direction and guidance. Some schools require research or capstone courses7; it is telling that 1 capstone course characterizes itself as “our last chance to ensure competent resident physicians.”8 Educators in a few specialties, including surgery and obstetrics/gynecology, have published recommended fourth-year educational courses for students interested in those fields.9,10 Family medicine has identified core skills, competencies, and goals for the fourth year.11 The national pediatric core curriculum developed by the Council on Medical Student Education in Pediatrics (COMSEP) lists the knowledge and skills expected of advanced students.12 However, the format is not easily used by educators designing fourth-year programs, and the end result is that students entering pediatric residency do so with variable experiences and levels of competence.13The fourth year of medical school should be a time for students to refine career choices and develop both general and specific skills that they will hone during residency and thereafter. An approach to enhancing the preparation of future pediatricians is to require students interested in a pediatrics career to complete both a subinternship and a minimum number of months (eg, 3) of pediatric electives that have specific objectives with defined competencies. The experiences could be in subspecialty clinics, community practices, research opportunities in pediatrics, or advocacy programs. The exposure may help refine career choices. Currently, more than two-thirds of students who enter pediatrics residency have already decided whether to pursue a career in primary or specialty care, and approximately three-quarters of them maintain their commitment to that career choice in their third year of residency.14 Those who are planning a career in primary care would benefit from exposure to areas of pediatrics (and related disciplines) that would supplement and complement residency experiences; those planning a career in a subspecialty may use the time to help identify which subspecialty is of particular interest.To address the growing need for more specific objectives and clearly defined competencies for medical students interested in the field of pediatrics, the Council on Medical Student Education in Pediatrics (COMSEP) and the Association of Pediatric Program Directors (APPD) worked together to create a subinternship curriculum in 2009.15 This curriculum has specific learning objectives and learning modules as well as assessment tools. The sub-I curriculum is a good start, but more is needed.Students and educators may complain that additional prerequisites place an undue burden on medical students. However, committing 3 months in addition to a subinternship to enhance the training in one's chosen field would be beneficial and still allow for flexibility during the majority of the senior year. The “burden” would be to construct a rationale for the choice of experiences; residency program directors might choose to inquire about this rationale as an assessment of the candidate's abilities as a self-directed learner.Before 1988, residency recruitment and selection was conducted largely in the fall of the fourth year of medical school, and match lists were due in mid-November. In 1988, Robert Petersdorf, president of the Association of American Medical Colleges, requested deans to withhold their letters until November 1. The result was, in effect, an extension of the period of medical school that “counted” by an additional 2 to 3 months. Beginning in 2012, however, dean's letters (officially identified as the Medical Student Performance Evaluation) will be released 1 month earlier, on October 1,16 thereby reducing the number of months in the fourth year that “count” (ie, appear in the official report to residency programs). As an unintended consequence, the potential for greater underuse of the valuable senior year will increase.Developing competency-based electives will be challenging. Although the core clerkship in pediatrics has quite specific competencies,12 no specific national competencies exist for fourth-year pediatric electives other than the general inpatient subinternship. Competencies for fourth-year experiences will need to be developed, and students will need to be assessed on the basis of those competencies.It should be noted that implementing the recommendation that students interested in pediatrics commit 3 months of their fourth year to supplementing and complementing residency training does not involve overcoming 2 challenges common to most educational innovations: securing major funding and surmounting major administrative obstacles.The goal of pediatric medical education should be to develop longitudinal educational programs that entice talented young men and women to enter the field and to ensure that they are well prepared to care for children at the completion of their training and thereafter. Defining and better using opportunities available in the fourth year of medical school is a worthwhile step in that direction and can be implemented now.We gratefully acknowledge Carol Carraccio for thoughtful critique of an early draft of this manuscript.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Roberts et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: