Why the study?
What is the rate of false-positive vasovagal syncope during prolonged passive head up tilt testing in normal adults?
What is the rate of false-positive vasovagal syncope during prolonged passive head up tilt testing in normal adults?
Prolonged passive head up tilt testing produces a 13% false-positive rate for vasovagal syncope in healthy adults, which largely invalidates previously suggested criteria for abnormal non-syncopal outcomes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant caution interpreting prolonged tilt-test results; challenges prior diagnostic criteria and leaves open prospective validation.
OBJECTIVE: To define the responses to head up tilt in a large group of normal adult subjects using the most widely employed protocol for tilt testing. METHODS: 127 normal subjects aged 19-88 years (mean (SD), 49 (20) years) without a previous history of syncope underwent tilt testing at 60 degrees for 45 minutes or until syncope intervened. Blood pressure monitoring was performed with digital photoplethysmography, providing continuous, non-invasive, beat to beat heart rate and pressure measurements. RESULTS: 13% of subjects developed vasovagal syncope after a mean (SD) tilt time of 31.7 (12. 4) minutes (range 8.5-44.9 minutes). Severe cardioinhibition during syncope was observed less often than is reported in patients investigated for syncope. There were no differences in the age or sex distributions of subjects with positive or negative outcomes, or in the proportions with cardioinhibitory and vasodepressor vasovagal syncope compared with previously reported patient populations. Subjects with negative outcomes showed age related differences in heart rate and blood pressure behaviour throughout tilt. CONCLUSIONS: False positive results with tilting appear to be common. This has important implications for the use of diagnostic tilt testing. The magnitude of the heart rate and blood pressure changes observed during negative tilts largely invalidates previously suggested criteria for abnormal non-syncopal outcomes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
MARK E.V. PETERSEN (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: