Why the study?
Does physical activity improve anxiety, depression, and positive mood?
Does physical activity improve anxiety, depression, and positive mood?
While exercise is associated with improvements in anxiety, depression, and positive mood, current evidence does not definitively establish a causal link according to Hill's criteria.
This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Introduction: In regard to the psychological benefits that may be derived from exercise, the scientific community has been tentative in supporting the relationship. In 1996, the U.S. Surgeon General's Report on Physical Activity and Health reflected this hesitancy by stating that “physical activity appears to relieve symptoms of depression and anxiety and improve mood” (p. 4). The words “may” and “appears to” were used to describe this link. Since 1996, scientists have become more optimistic by stating that exercise is linked to decreases in anxiety and depression, and, in a recent review, Mutrie (2000) stated that support exists for a causal link between exercise and decreased clinical depression. The purpose of this review is to examine where the current research on anxiety, depression and improved positive mood stands in regard to Hill's (1965) criteria for establishing causation. Specifically, the current review focuses on seven of Hill's eight original criteria (see 1st column in Results Table). The eighth criterion, specificity, was not included as its use may be outdated. In its place, attempts to control behavioral artifacts (e.g., non-reactive measures or animal studies) were considered. Method: Computer searches were initially used to identify narrative reviews and meta-analytic reviews (which were primarily used to assess strength of association and consistency) as well as experimental and epidemiological studies (which were used to assess the remaining criteria) on the effects of exercise on mental health. These documents were then cross-referenced to locate additional studies on the topic. Results:Table: No Caption AvailableDiscussion: The research literature demonstrates that exercise is related to, but does not cause, desirable changes in anxiety, depression, and positive mood. Conclusions can be made that are stronger than those in the Surgeons General Report, but the causal link between exercise and mental health is not yet clearly established. Although the positive trends indicate a potential causal link, conclusions are often tempered by limited available experimental evidence and tests of potential mechanisms to determine coherence or methodological problems inherent in many studies that attempt to explore the dose-response issue. As compared to depression and anxiety, the effects of exercise on positive mood have the greatest likelihood of being spurious. This is due to the fact that the influence of behavioral artifacts cannot be ruled out in positive mood, like it can be in depression and anxiety, because positive mood has only been measured using questionnaires. Overall, it is important for future research to examine dose-response questions to clarify intensity, duration and frequency components of the exercise and mental health relationship. In addition, future research should evaluate the numerous proposed mechanisms for the reported relationships, as mechanistic evidence will clarify behavioral artifact and moderator variable information.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Associations with mood benefits should not yet change practice; leaves open definitive causality per Hill's criteria.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arent et al. (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: