Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The te rm medul lob las toma was introduced to distinguish this neoplasm as a specific tumor ent i ty by Bailey and Cushing in 19~5. 8 Cushing had opera ted upon tumors of this type as early as 1903. TM Bailey and Cushing believed tha t a fa ta l outcome was inevitable, but t ha t radiat ion t h e r a p y was conclusively beneficial in prolonging the average postoperat ive survival. 9 This me thod of t reat m e n t had been used since 1919.19 Not ing an incidence of 6 cases of spinal meningeal metas tases among their to ta l of 61, they extended the field of irradiat ion to include routinely the spinal axis in 19~72 Thei r goal of operat ion was to unblock the aqueduct , ra ther than to a t t e m p t gross total removal of the t umor? 9 Subsequent repor t s have been in substantial agreement wi th the ear ly views of Bailey and Cushing regarding t r e a t m e n t and prognosis 1 0 -12 ,16 ,18 ,25 ,29-31 ,38 ,43 ,46 ,51 ,54-56 The futi l i ty of a t t e m p t i n g cure by radical operat ion has become well establ ished? 2 On the other hand, i r radiat ion wi thout operat ion has been condemned. I r reparab le damage m a y occur during the delay necessitated by trial irradiation of a radioresis tant , benign tumor incorrectly diagnosed2 7 Fur thermore , irradiation wi thout pr ior decompression risks a fatal edema. 17 The possible advan tage of avoiding operat ive dissemination of t u m o r cells through the subarachnoid space has assumed less importance since it has been shown tha t seeding may occur even wi thout operation?,~3 Survivals longer than 5 years have been repor ted sporadical]y?4,17,20-24,2~-2s,32,34-~6,40, 41,4~-49,6z,sa In some of these cases the diagnosis has been disputed or actual ly changed. 7, 12,17,57 The m a t t e r is fur ther complicated by the failure of m a n y authors to confine their reports to tumors occurring in children, 14,17, 20,21,24,26,27,32,;~4,36,47-49,53 since similar tumors in the adul t have been thought to have a more favorable prognosisN ,5~ Bailey believes t h a t the medul loblas toma occurs only in children under 15 and tha t the leptomeningeal sarcoma has often been confused with it in the adult . 5 While this m a y be a m a t t e r of opinion, we feel t h a t analyses clearly distinguishing between cases in children and in adul ts are more meaningful. The most optimist ic repor t o ther t han our own is tha t of Pa te rson and F a r r ? 5 In 1953 they repor ted 6 children with 5-year survivals among ~1 opera ted upon and irradiated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Smith et al. (1961) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: