Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
During our discussion today we have heard presentations describing the roles of physicians ((1)Rippe J.M. Crossley S. Ringer R. Obesity as a chronic disease modern medical and lifestyle manageme.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S9-S15Google Scholar, (2)Aronne L.J. Modern medical management of obesity the role of pharmaceutical intervention.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S23-S26Google Scholar, (3)Frank A. A multidisciplinary approach to obesity management the physician's role and team care alternatives.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S44-S48Google Scholar), dietitians ((4)Coulston A.M. Obesity as an epidemic facing the challenge.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S6-S8Google Scholar, (5)Nonas C.A. A model for chronic care of obesity through dietary treatment.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S16-S22Google Scholar, (6)Franz M.J. Managing obesity in patients with comorbidities.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S39-S43Google Scholar, (7)Dalton S. The dietitian's philosophy and practice in multi-disciplinary weight management.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S49-S54Google Scholar), behaviorists ((8)Foreyt J.P. Poston WSC I.I. The role of the behavioral counselor in obesity treatment.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S27-S30Google Scholar), and other health care professionals who work both individually and as a team to combat the epidemic of obesity in our country. Currently, more than 1 in 3 adults in the United States are obese ((9)Update prevalence of overweight among children, adolescents, and adults—United States, 1998-1994.MMWR. 1997; 46: 99-202Google Scholar). Furthermore, the prevalence of obesity in this country grew an astounding 40% between 1980 and 1990 ((10)Kuczmarski R.J. Flegal K.M. Campbell S.M. Johnson C.L. Increasing prevalence of overweight among US adults the national health and nutrition examination surveys, 1960-1991.JAMA. 1994; 272: 205-211Google Scholar). There is agreement in the health care community that obesity is a major health problem ((11)Pi-Sunyer F.X. Medical hazards of obesity.Ann Intern Med. 1993; 119: 655-660Google Scholar, (12)Stunkard AJ. Current views on obesity. Am J Med. 1996;230–236.Google Scholar, (13)Rippe J.M. Overweight and health communications challenges and opportunities.Am J Clin Nutr. 1996; 63: 470-473Google Scholar, (14)Institute of MedicineWeighing the Options. Criteria for Evaluating Weight-Management Programs. National Academy Press, Washington, DC1995Google Scholar). Most health professionals would agree that obesity is a chronic disease. Obesity is a long-standing or lifelong problem for most people, it is multifactorial in origin, and it markedly increases morbidity and mortality. Obesity is also associated with many other chronic conditions, including coronary heart disease ((15)Rimm E.B. Stampler M.J. Giovannucci B. Ascherio A. Spiegelman D. Colditz G.A. Willett W.C. Body size and fat distribution as predictors of coronary heart disease among middle-aged and older US men.Am J Epidemiol. 1995; 141: 1117-1127Google Scholar), type 2 diabetes ((16)Colditz G.A. Willett W.C. Rotnitzky A. Manson J.E. Weight gain as a risk factor for clinical diabetes mellitus in women.Ann Intern Med. 1995; 122: 481-486Google Scholar), hypertension ((17)Stamler J. Epidemiologic findings on body mass and blood pressure in adults.Ann Epidemiol. 1991; 4: 347-362Google Scholar), and dyslipidemias ((18)Denke M.A. Sempos C.T. Grundy S.M. Excess body weight an unrecognized contributor to high blood cholesterol levels in white American men.Arch Intern Med. 1993; 153: 1093-1103Google Scholar, (19)Denke M.A. Sempos C.T. Grundy S.M. Excess body weight an unrecognized contributor to high blood cholesterol levels in white American women.Arch Intern Med. 1994; 154: 401-410Google Scholar). According to data from the third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES III), by the time people reach a body mass index of 27, they have a >70% likelihood of having developed a comorbid condition ((20)1997 Heat and Stroke Statistical Update. Dallas, Tex: American Heart Association; 1996.Google Scholar). The negative economic and social ramifications of obesity are also considerable. Obese adolescents enter the job market at lower salaries, and most never recover from this disadvantage ((21)Sarget J. Blanchflower D. Obese teen girls, short teen boys earn less as young adults.Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1994; 148: 681-687Google Scholar). Obese people are less likely to marry. In addition, many adverse psychological conditions such as depression and low self-esteem are more prevalent in obese persons than in nonobese persons ((22)Stunkard A.J. Wadden T.A. Psychological aspects of severe obesity.Am J Cin Nutr. 1992; 55: 524S-532SGoogle Scholar, (23)Wadden T.A. Stunkard A.J. Social and psychological consequences of obesity.Ann Intern Med. 1985; 103: 1062-1067Google Scholar). Although our panel has focused largely on adult obesity, obesity is also a huge and rapidly growing problem in children and adolescents. The prevalence of obesity has more than doubled in these age groups during the last 20 years ((24)Troiano R.P. Flegal K.M. Kuczmarski R.J. Campbell S.M. Johnson C.L. Overweight prevalence and trends for children and adolescents the national health and nutrition examination surveys, 1963 to 1991.Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1995; 140: 1085-1091Google Scholar, (25)National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases. Statistics Related to Overweight and Obesity. Rockville, Md: National Institutes of Health; July 1,1996. NIH Publication 96-4158.Google Scholar). Moreover, recent evidence confirms that childhood obesity continues into adulthood ((26)Whitaker R.C. Wright J.A. Pepe M.S. Seidel K.D. Dietz W.H. Predicting obesity in young adulthood from childhood and parental obesity.N Engl J Med. 1997; 337: 869-873Google Scholar). Having 1 or more obese parents and the age of an obese child or adolescent are characteristics that correlate with an increased likelihood that obesity will continue into young adulthood; that is, the later into adolescence the obesity persists, the greater the likelihood an obese adolescent will become an obese adult. Because obesity is a chronic disease, treatment approaches analogous to those used successfully to treat other chronic diseases, such as hypertension, coronary artery disease, and type 2 diabetes, should also be appropriate for treatment of obesity. Central to the chronic disease treatment model, as many panelists have discussed, is the importance of assembling a team of health care experts to deliver appropriate therapy. In the case of obesity, members of this treatment team may include physicians, registered dietitians, and behaviorists. In their individual presentations, our panelists described many opportunities for physicians and registered dietitians to collaborate in the multidisciplinary approach to treatment of obesity ((1)Rippe J.M. Crossley S. Ringer R. Obesity as a chronic disease modern medical and lifestyle manageme.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S9-S15Google Scholar, (2)Aronne L.J. Modern medical management of obesity the role of pharmaceutical intervention.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S23-S26Google Scholar, (3)Frank A. A multidisciplinary approach to obesity management the physician's role and team care alternatives.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S44-S48Google Scholar, (4)Coulston A.M. Obesity as an epidemic facing the challenge.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S6-S8Google Scholar, (5)Nonas C.A. A model for chronic care of obesity through dietary treatment.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S16-S22Google Scholar, (6)Franz M.J. Managing obesity in patients with comorbidities.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S39-S43Google Scholar, (7)Dalton S. The dietitian's philosophy and practice in multi-disciplinary weight management.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S49-S54Google Scholar, (8)Foreyt J.P. Poston WSC I.I. The role of the behavioral counselor in obesity treatment.J Am Diet Assoc. 1998; 98: S27-S30Google Scholar). During this panel discussion portion of our session, I will ask the panelists to clarify and expand on some of the issues raised in their individual presentations. Rippe:Cathy Nonas, in your presentation you discussed various logistical and technical problems confronting both physicians and dietitians who treat obese patients. For example, you mentioned that many physicians lack basic equipment, such as appropriately sized blood pressure cuffs for obese people. If I understand your comments correctly, you are skeptical that the typical and understand to treat obesity. a the be If the work with physicians who may lack basic of and to obesity There is to your the country are with obesity may be obesity experts many dietitians they have appropriate and to treat obesity. is a the a In the of diabetes, the diabetes a of The American many dietitians they the appropriate to treat that dietitians a to that they appropriate dietary care to people with will likely the basic it to dietitians obesity. Because a of dietitians treat obesity, many will that in a or should be to treat this the other will be a dietitians who will be as we to many more physicians and dietitians to have a and of obesity as a disease and the various also to health care professionals it is appropriate to a to an obesity or a more obesity treatment to to in the of obesity for both dietitians and If we both groups more obesity, dietitians and physicians will of will in more of obesity among dietitians and physicians and should to this type of For example, as a I to be obese blood Although I to treat blood I blood pressure and a to or for of would be in comments from other dietitians on the is the for dietitians to work with physicians in the of obesity I agree with dietitians should a major role in obesity treatment and many a I that obesity treatment is of the most treatment for have at patients weight For this dietitians may with people who have weight problems and will on other of health and A problem to we in weight both health care professionals and patients on weight as a of to other such as in of and self-esteem that from in also to the importance of increased For example, we should patients to understand that their is If a a than the 3 that is an for a weight during the to have a of to to our patients. raised an that is for dietitians to has and I would that many dietitians that or of a and is of health professionals understand obesity. There is obese people have a of the other we people to a of that and you that some people will a such as of for and a of is a that a of of and a In some low or to a is for more and is that we to dietitians the importance of approaches obese patients and nutrition to from The approach has in diabetes management the dietitian's role has from the who to a role that problem are in diabetes are on an of the and blood are to as as other that may have blood Nutrition on on problem to for blood to the to and the to the role of to more dietitians to this counselor I the should a nutrition and a the should also on a and a of other behavioral to that we are with nutrition with The of is and would to to In your you the importance of in obesity you should dietitians be in for the There are for a who is in a weight management will have to many and is a dietitians have of their and from the of dietitians an in obesity management and to have major In addition, the who may be a health care will have time to the of dietary or with nutrition and a of is an of issues also more time than a has as as the that dietitians to is for I to that I the you on Furthermore, your comments our on the for than weight as of are Medical and nutrition problems in obese persons with are should the approach an obese with a such as type 2 diabetes, hypertension, or coronary artery these patients be from patients who have obesity The approach to an obese with a is from that used with obese patients who have such Most persons who have both obesity and a have the importance of weight In some obese patients are to with a they that they will the weight they have in this and are of to other to obese patients with in For example, patients with diabetes, it is I have a of their blood levels and I this to patients lifestyle their blood and or they patients understand that in these blood health the weight as the clinical you are describing is on the that are many to and health many the negative of of many for patients to The more that you are is both with the clinical and more to patients. to be in of chronic patients who have 1 or more chronic to expand our to include a including children, of people who have chronic are at increased risk for the chronic the who is with a chronic disease is an for dietitians to to the be to their health on to lower risk for chronic disease be to the importance of and weight is to of your on the panel have that as an has an on the role of the in the treatment of obesity. you this is a If is it that may be of developed a on weight management of The American weight J Am Diet Assoc. Scholar), it raised a of among the people our and we should at of it appropriate for to a on weight this is people are to they that has a on the of weight management and obesity. is for in your presentation you discussed both opportunities and of the medical model for obesity. you discussed a team approach to obesity you focused on of and we in obesity is it to of In this model, of the 3 an I would your on this I a team of I to the size of the The team of 2 a to are in short or is a of and with a team of to the that you other professionals would be a team of health care would work in the would and of and the to in a more at the it is to that a team of 2 be is to that 1 of the team is the is to the from a role as the of to the more role of team and in the of a treatment A major role that the in your is to be the case we should the role of case to the also be the or many will be in the is the care the appropriate is to and in the community and to these and are for team The team approach If we are to a team approach that community and health care professionals to that at the many physicians are to treat the obese hypertension, type 2 diabetes, or coronary artery disease than the of these the obesity If we physicians obesity as a chronic disease and a chronic disease treatment model, the will be more treatment of obesity also of of the chronic associated with obesity are with analogous chronic disease treatment of coronary artery disease, type 2 diabetes, and hypertension lifestyle as as pharmaceutical therapy. Nutrition and are appropriate in these conditions, as as in treatment of obesity. of between physicians and dietitians in the of obesity will be to the medical community the it to obesity as a chronic disease. A major for in the treatment of obesity is that many physicians many health that is they to treat obesity from their to treat obesity. to the or to in the If physicians and patients their this will more obesity A approach the of the as as the of health care professionals in the care of obese patients. I would to a of a physicians to dietitians as of team management of obesity would a major is that many physicians lack of the as as the treatment of obesity. For example, in our at we heart in obese patients also of diabetes and hypertension that are conditions, such as are major in obesity we team the at our we and work as a patients to dietitians who as the case and and If dietitians are to the role of case it is that they to obese patients. obesity as a chronic disease and a chronic disease will both physicians and dietitians to more for obesity. this is the in American I would this in the we have treatment for obesity, it be a disease. Because it is a disease, it be a disease, and it will is I medical we that it obesity will is astounding that we the of in the United States and treat it this is the chronic disease model as a for obesity is we the medical community to obesity as a chronic disease, is to a chronic disease treatment model including a multidisciplinary team to treat If you have a disease, is to a for is an of it is an of or you obesity a disease will an will in become in a treatment they that they be Obesity has an physicians they be will the more to physicians treat obesity may the In this is physicians that to treat obesity they will have to some of such as nutrition or that may be problem is that physicians to that weight is the weight gain in obese patients are of also most physicians to treat obesity. Most physicians are to for management of hypertension, diabetes, or these physicians may to the obese that you have weight you to these is the of most physicians, it is also the of many of patients. that they have they to obesity of is and it a for obesity the that patients who have weight should have that weight I would to the to that In the medical care many their the to treat obesity. and groups of are more likely to have appropriate For example, in the I it is for physicians to an physicians or obesity are more likely to be Furthermore, for obesity may be more to physicians than they have that in these I this is are physicians for you a obesity in a in a are your the role of dietitians in your you to both physicians and dietitians on the team approach to obesity on the and you have at your at these groups work successfully The roles of dietitians and physicians are Because patients who to our practice at Medical are by other physicians, most of the people we are overweight and have medical Because of this I may to a the to work with our dietitians for nutrition There are also people who the and dietary by the and to or In our more than the patients we treat never and their are by the team also include a is an model for obesity in an The treatment model we at be in In a we patients our to A in a dietitians, practice dietitians, or as and appropriate of the dietitians on this panel In to the have and have In addition, panelists have the to that they are diabetes it that in the we a in the of the of a obesity The is by or by the American Diabetes is and by an by the American of Diabetes an to from who are in diabetes For example, dietitians, and physicians become we such a in The major problem I with a in obesity is that is of obesity that the in the treatment of obesity. is in diabetes we have the American Diabetes also have the American of Diabetes would a on the of the of Obesity that would the many in the clinical treatment of obesity. to a practice for dietitians in the who in obesity who in at in to this practice dietitians who work for the Weight and other groups in weight the we have a of dietitians in the who are in obesity to have a practice Most of are members of and practice is the that most of in obesity the is to There are groups focused diabetes and heart disease you that groups for dietitians who have an in I this will or such a is will largely on obesity is There is a of dietitians in most dietitians would obesity as an be that obesity is an or at many dietitians would to the of as a to obesity it a I it is dietitians who are focused on to include obesity their of dietitians are obesity as a management your weight your obesity as a management problem a approach that on such as and in the that you your your your your or other of your is a and that would be appropriate to you a job of a for the role of in the management of obesity. you that our approach to will as more become to will a of obesity management or are The behavioral approach to lifestyle such as a and will to obesity in the model by an is for dietitians to their and become more and of and many dietitians also to of of and is I in the of in the of and is for dietitians to to such as the be in this I also will become as health If we are to the prevalence of obesity, we will to appropriate behavioral at the community and at the of the In to your the role of as more become for the treatment of obesity, I will become more with greater of these patients will the of obesity treatment these the of a and as of weight management also as lifestyle that health and I would your of on the various that are to on the market or that will be the we treat obesity. will obesity treatment in the to will these the role of the In to treat obesity the dietitian's job less the dietitian's become more patients with dietary more to to dietary they are of an medical to the at obesity I that dietary will be as as is a I dietary will on the nutrition for health than on The role of the will in the than and dietitians will an greater role in the health care team than they There is that nutrition is a of health and this it that the role of the in chronic disease management will continue to I agree with I is that are to an role in obesity will become and they will be more will the In a to treat obesity is analogous to a If you it in it is to will to have to with the obesity The is in the of body fat that is likely to the obesity we will to and as we to hypertension or will to these with approaches such as and increased we are to in obesity. There are many and associated with that is to be for a to 1 and be the of the behavioral to obesity The of on on and this is by many we will to a and approach to a will dietary and with in the social and psychological that our that during your to of your as of the that you to work to have dietitians as more members of the medical you on this this be a major during your as of in the health care to work as of a health care For dietitians, of the opportunities in obesity treatment is people weight as a to disease a more body and health in I to I to opportunities for dietitians in this will roles of dietitians as members of the health care with more of the work dietitians will to be in an most for nutrition is to for nutrition in is has some to we have a I dietitians have opportunities in and we are to of these In a is a approach to patients than having a from to In the of obesity, is for health care they are physicians or as of professionals are with obesity, and physicians become more in this it is that physicians and work with dietitians to treatment and that obesity you dietitians in your as of the obesity management you a of are you we for dietitians who have in the of obesity, more we for with a in obesity we for the is to who are to obese people and understand that these patients are will a would to ask some of the members on this panel the for dietitians as and for as an with to obesity I and that dietitians are to be in the of obesity I the of obesity treatment I obesity treatment more as care that an of The treatment is, at a to people weight gain to some I dietitians to and as to our in and to in and to to with dietitians to as by both the clinical evidence and the of have major roles to I of in this I some as a has never of with I dietitians they more obesity treatment than they I that as a I that will be more on obesity treatment among dietitians in the also to of the of obesity. the I is to as of is that with we will in individual dietitians and approach obesity in the I have a for a I I some young dietitians the obesity treatment and they have of the The they in the the more they they have the they become The you are in the the more it that you work with people, their problem is, your major role is that of a The we to among dietitians are and the to work with people. also more to people with obesity. I as are developed for obesity we will more dietitians become in obesity. I dietitians will to the and an role in the treatment of obesity. dietitians that they have appropriate in the have the to the appropriate to a role in obesity to this in of individual dietitians and as a I the of obesity treatment among physicians, dietitians, and other health care If physicians become more in the management of obesity and a chronic disease management model that is to that in diabetes, hypertension, and coronary artery disease, and will I obesity management as a for to our panel for a is that obesity has epidemic in the United is also that as we approach obesity management in the will be and opportunities for dietitians and physicians to work in a multidisciplinary approach to combat this health panel has appropriately both the community and the community to the opportunities that as we for a major health problem confronting the United
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rippe et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: