Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The field of antioxidants and free radicals is often perceived as focusing around the use of antioxidant supplements to prevent human disease. In fact, antioxidants/free radicals permeate the whole of life, creating the field of redox biology. Free radicals are not all bad, nor antioxidants all good. Life is a balance between the two: Antioxidants serve to keep down the levels of free radicals, permitting them to perform useful biological functions without too much damage (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). This is especially true in plants, as the rest of this issue reveals. Yet some damage is inevitable, requiring repair systems to maintain cell viability. The purpose of this article is to take a broad view of the field, and highlight some of the fascinating differences between plants and other organisms. All animals need O2 for efficient production of energy in mitochondria. This need for O2 obscures the fact that it is a toxic mutagenic gas; aerobes survive only because they have evolved antioxidant defenses (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). Oxygen appeared in significant amounts in the Earth's atmosphere over 2.2 billion years ago, largely due to the evolution of photosynthesis by cyanobacteria. They evolved to use energy from the sun to split water. Thereby, they gained reducing power (hydrogen equivalents) to drive their metabolism, but the byproduct, tonnes of O2, was discarded into the atmosphere (Lane, 2002) as an early case of air pollution. Initially, most of this O2 was consumed by the formation of the metallic oxide deposits that exist in rocks and ores today. Only when this was largely complete did O2 build up in the atmosphere. The rise in atmospheric O2 was advantageous in at least two ways; it led to formation of the ozone (O3) layer in the stratosphere that protects living organisms from UV-C radiation (that may have helped organisms to leave the sea and colonize land), and it removed ferrous iron (Fe2+) from aqueous environments by forming insoluble ferric complexes. Most Fe2+ was precipitated from solution, leaving sea and river waters today containing only trace amounts of soluble iron (Lane, 2002). When living organisms first appeared on Earth, they did so under an atmosphere containing much N2 and CO2 but little O2, i.e. they were anaerobes (Kasting, 1993). Anaerobes still exist today, but usually their growth is inhibited or they are killed by exposure to 21% O2, the current atmospheric level. As atmospheric O2 rose, many anaerobes must have died out. Present-day ones are presumably the descendants of organisms that adapted to rising O2 by restricting themselves to anoxic microenvironments. Other organisms instead began to evolve antioxidant defenses (producing new ones and realigning ancient molecules to new functions) to protect against O2 toxicity. One of the earliest of these may have been to develop proteins that bind and detoxify iron to protect DNA against Fenton chemistry (Wiedenheft et al., 2005). In retrospect, this development of antioxidants was a fruitful path to follow. Organisms that tolerated O2 could further evolve to use it for metabolic transformations catalyzed by oxidase, oxygenase, and hydroxylase enzymes, such as the Pro and Lys hydroxylases needed for collagen biosynthesis. Indeed, large multicellular animals need collagen for making their support tissues (bone and cartilage). Best of all, O2 could facilitate efficient energy production, employing electron-transport chains with O2 as the terminal electron acceptor. This switch to aerobic metabolism increased the yield of ATP that could be made from food molecules such as Glc by over 15-fold. Evolution of efficient energy production allowed the development of complex multicellular organisms, which then also needed systems to ensure that O2 can be distributed throughout their bodies (mechanisms varying from spiracles in insects to the human vascular system). A further advantage of evolving such systems is that delivery of O2 can be controlled: for example, most cells in the human body are never exposed to the full force of atmospheric O2 because blood pO2 is much lower than that of air. Similarly, insects control the opening of their spiracles to keep internal O2 low (Hetz and Bradley, 2005). Under an atmosphere mainly composed of N2 and CO2 with no O3 screen, UV radiation must have bombarded the face of the Earth. Even at the low O2 levels present 3.5 billion years ago (<0.1%), there could have been substantial H2O2 levels in rainwater generated by photochemical reactions with traces of O2 (Lane, 2002). Since Fe2+ was freely available, Fenton chemistry was a threat, so H2O2 must be eliminated. One suggestion is that the evolutionary precursors of PSII used H2O2 as a substrate (Olson and Blankenship, 2004) and only later evolved the increased chemical ferocity needed to split water. Atmospheric O2 levels may have been higher at periods in the Earth's history, perhaps reaching 35% by the late Carboniferous era. As plant life flourished, CO2 levels fell drastically, and huge deposits of coal and oil formed (Graham et al., 1995; Lane, 2002). This increased O2 concentration may have permitted insects (whose O2 distribution system depends largely on diffusion) to become larger. For example, the giant Carboniferous dragonfly Meganeura monyi was bigger than any dragonfly that exists today (Lane, 2002). The plants and animals existing in Carboniferous times may have had enhanced antioxidant defenses, which would be fascinating to study if they could be resurrected. Even today, some of the plants that evolved at that time can resist damage by elevated O2 better than plants that evolved more recently (Beerling et al., 1998). All aerobes including plants, aerobic bacteria, and humans, suffer damage when exposed to O2 concentrations higher than normal (Gilbert, 1981; Balentine, 1982; Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006), signifying that they have no excess of antioxidant defenses. Indeed, as we learned how to measure oxidative damage (for review, see Halliwell and Whiteman, 2004), it was found to occur in aerobes even at normal O2 levels. What causes this damage? Many scientists believe that O2 toxicity is due to excess formation of the superoxide radical O2 ⋅− (Fridovich, 1995), this is the superoxide theory of O2 toxicity. But let us step back for a moment and examine some basics. A free radical is any species capable of independent existence (hence the term free) that contains one or more unpaired electrons (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). An unpaired electron is one that occupies an atomic or molecular orbital by itself. The simplest free radical is atomic hydrogen. Since a hydrogen atom has only one electron, it must be unpaired. Many free radicals exist in living systems (some bad, some good, and some both), although most molecules in vivo are nonradicals. Radicals can be formed by several mechanisms, such as adding a single electron to a nonradical. They can form when a covalent bond is broken if one electron from the bonding pair remains on each atom (homolytic fission). Some bonds are hard to break, e.g. temperatures of 450°C to 600°C are often required to rupture C–C, C–H, or C–O bonds. Indeed, combustion of organic compounds proceeds by free radical mechanisms. Other covalent bonds fragment more easily: Just trimming your fingernails can cleave disulphide bonds in keratin to generate sulfur radicals (Symons, 1996). A simplified version of bonding in the diatomic oxygen molecule and its derivatives. The oxygen atom has eight electrons, O2 has 16 electrons. Adapted from Halliwell and Gutteridge (2006) by courtesy of Oxford University Press. More reactive forms of O2, the singlet oxygens, can be generated by an input of energy that rearranges the electrons (Foote et al., 1985). In both forms of singlet O2 the spin restriction is removed (Fig. 1) and the oxidizing ability greatly increased; singlet O2 can directly oxidize proteins, DNA, and lipids (Foote et al., 1985). The 1Σg+ state rapidly decays to the 1Δg state, so only the latter is usually encountered in biological systems. Note that 1ΔgO2 is not a free radical, it has no unpaired electrons (Fig. 1). Singlet O2 1Δg (written just as singlet O2 or 1O2 from now on) is the curse of the illuminated chloroplast; insufficient energy dissipation during photosynthesis can lead to formation of a chlorophyll triplet state that can transfer its excitation energy onto ground-state O2 to make 1O2 (Holt et al., 2005). This can oxidize chloroplast molecules and can trigger cell death (Wagner et al., 2004). The plant counters this by regulating energy distribution between the light harvesting complexes and by judicious use of certain carotenoids, which can quench both the triplet chlorophyll state and the 1O2 itself (Holt et al., 2005). Singlet O2 is also sometimes used as a signaling molecule. Animals are not exempt from singlet O2 formation; it occurs in the skin and eye (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). Photosensitizers of singlet O2 can be consumed in dietary plants (e.g. hypericin in St. John's Wort [Hypericum perforatum] and psoralens in celery [Apium graveolens]) or taken as drugs (e.g. the fluoroquinolone antibiotics), and subsequent sunbathing can cause skin damage (Morison, 2004; Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). If a single electron is supplied to O2, it enters one of the π* antibonding orbitals (Fig. 1). The product is superoxide radical, O2 ⋅−, full name superoxide radical anion. With only one unpaired electron, superoxide is less radical than O2, despite its super name (Fridovich, 1995). Mitochondria take up O2 and reduce 95% or more of it to water, a process achieved by cytochrome oxidase. It removes one electron from each of four reduced (Fe2+-haem) cytochrome c molecules, oxidizing them to ferric cytochrome c, and adds the four electrons on to O2 as shown above. However, it is impossible to add four (not even two!) electrons to O2 at once. Cytochrome oxidase is a large and complex multiprotein assembly, both because it catalyzes several reduction steps and also because it must hold onto toxic partially reduced oxygen species until they can be fully reduced to water (Babcock, 1999). Many different terms are used in the literature to describe oxygen radicals and related (nonradical) species such as 1O2 and H2O2. I prefer the term reactive oxygen species (ROS), a collective descriptor that includes not only the oxygen radicals but also some nonradical derivatives of O2 (Table I Some reactive species ROS is a collective term that includes both oxygen radicals and certain nonradicals that are oxidizing agents and/or are easily converted into radicals (HOCl, HOBr, O3, ONOO−, 1O2, and H2O2). All oxygen radicals are ROS, but not all ROS are oxygen radicals. Reactive nitrogen species is a similar collective term that includes NO⋅ and NO2⋅, as well as nonradicals such as HNO2 and N2O4. Reactive is not always an appropriate term: H2O2, NO⋅, and O2 ⋅− react fast with few molecules, whereas OH⋅ reacts fast with almost everything. Species such as RO2 ⋅, NO3 ⋅, RO⋅, HOCl, HOBr, CO3 ⋅−, CO2 ⋅−, NO2 ⋅, ONOO−, NO2 +, and O3 have intermediate reactivities. HOBr and BrCl could also be regarded as reactive bromine species. HOCl and HOBr are often included as ROS. Oxidizing species formed in polluted air that are toxic to plants and animals. ONOO−, ONOOH, and O2NOO− are often included as ROS. NO2Cl can also be regarded as a reactive nitrogen species. This species may cause formation of allergenic nitrated proteins in pollens. Some reactive species ROS is a collective term that includes both oxygen radicals and certain nonradicals that are oxidizing agents and/or are easily converted into radicals (HOCl, HOBr, O3, ONOO−, 1O2, and H2O2). All oxygen radicals are ROS, but not all ROS are oxygen radicals. Reactive nitrogen species is a similar collective term that includes NO⋅ and NO2⋅, as well as nonradicals such as HNO2 and N2O4. Reactive is not always an appropriate term: H2O2, NO⋅, and O2 ⋅− react fast with few molecules, whereas OH⋅ reacts fast with almost everything. Species such as RO2 ⋅, NO3 ⋅, RO⋅, HOCl, HOBr, CO3 ⋅−, CO2 ⋅−, NO2 ⋅, ONOO−, NO2 +, and O3 have intermediate reactivities. HOBr and BrCl could also be regarded as reactive bromine species. HOCl and HOBr are often included as ROS. Oxidizing species formed in polluted air that are toxic to plants and animals. ONOO−, ONOOH, and O2NOO− are often included as ROS. NO2Cl can also be regarded as a reactive nitrogen species. This species may cause formation of allergenic nitrated proteins in pollens. However, most biological molecules are nonradicals. When a free radical reacts with a nonradical, a new radical results, and chain reactions may occur. There are several types of reactions (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). (1) A radical may add to another molecule; the adduct still has an unpaired electron. For example, OH⋅ adds to position 8 in the ring structure of guanine in DNA; the initial product is an 8-hydroxy-2′-deoxyguanosine radical. Among other fates, this can undergo oxidation to the mutagenic lesion 8-hydroxy-2′-deoxyguanosine, 8OHdG (Evans et al., 2004). Hydroxyl radical also attacks other bases and the deoxy-Rib in DNA, damage (Evans et al., 2004). A new radical is formed to the and a If the chain is the radicals can around and from the and A single has the to generate molecules by a chain The initial from a can occur at different on the complex of Singlet O2 can react directly with to e.g. it to and (Foote et al., 1985). The of singlet O2 in the of is than in aqueous of lipids in the of of 1O2 formation reactions are in the eye and in oxidation of chains and their to and lead to of e.g. rupture of or In some of have the formed from with at least including and sometimes formation of is in many human and exposure of animals to a of and Some as and can damage are in plants but their have not been as much as the 2004). of by iron and or by (e.g. the use of a complex of toxic including and such as and et al., toxic from of or and formed from and bind to proteins, and can DNA, forming mutagenic et al., organisms with O2 One is to the levels of O2, or its to ROS (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). Some organisms O2 toxicity by from O2 and can to the O2 to the they et al., 2004). The most of O2 ⋅− in vivo in many aerobic cells is the electron-transport chain plants, make a of O2 ⋅− as of cytochrome oxidase no ROS evolved some of the electron-transport chain can electrons directly to O2, although the of them onto the in the chain This O2 cytochrome oxidase is at low O2 the of electron O2 ⋅− by in increased by O2 levels it is not so is also by levels of reduced which can when O2 is may have evolved to the redox of the and other electron-transport chains in a that of electrons to O2 to form O2 ⋅− less may use oxidase systems to O2 ⋅− formation and both plants and animals have proteins in their may as e.g. by more and a back up of electrons in the chain to to of or O2 ⋅− to proteins, which then the and O2 ⋅− formation et al., 2004). that bind as and and so both Fenton chemistry and the of by iron and are other ROS formation (Halliwell and Gutteridge, and must with that H2O2. are not the most in this there is little or no in and much O2 ⋅− is generated (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). Most or all in plants and animals is in to with H2O2 by oxidase on such as and and 2004). are in that H2O2 by it to oxidize a Many plant are is perhaps the in plant chloroplast and can H2O2 by as a oxidizing it to a free radical et al., least four types of One is the often now body low levels of a different is found in the cells the and may to in food The of the is or with the ability to reduce not only H2O2 but also that are still in lipids of or In all four types of the is for 1999). In little in The chloroplast to are in and over some or all of the of H2O2 et al., has been in and in some plant and similar to in animals have been in several plant have than at the which their as with Indeed, at least some of the plant may prefer to as a substrate et al., et al., It has now been that may be the most systems in bacteria, and plants et al., 2005). They are and no The redox reactions are on at the There are at least the most the and the In all H2O2 an on the to a In the enzymes, this reacts with another on the to a disulphide that is then reduced by In another (not the are at H2O2 than although the large amounts present to of soluble in some and their low for H2O2 can for as can their in all and in the are by H2O2, the ones more to this than ones and have for et al., 2005). In is for the of the that in the reduced state for for the many other metabolic of of in animals the system as well as et al., 2005). there are agents that are by reactive species to more For example, can most ROS, including O2 ⋅−, RO2 ⋅, and ONOOH, as can are of radicals and to protect against by the chain is with the of the structure (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). Other of antioxidants carotenoids, and that are in animals. Even and are (for review, see Halliwell and Gutteridge, and plants have as well (e.g. et al., In one study et al., most died with in and metabolic and damage in to a in other that to survive than to a of including and et al., 1998). Even which at first increased oxidative damage as they as well as increased oxidative DNA damage and elevated et al., have also been When they normal they are more to but as they and can develop at an They have and vascular et al., 2005). It that O2 ⋅− can cause But in aqueous not react with many However, few that it are its with NO⋅ to is A from with several in energy production and have is by oxidation of the to of by Fenton The can be in vivo by the iron Indeed, even the low levels of O2 ⋅− production in damage these enzymes, and is by them If O2 ⋅− levels rise (e.g. at elevated repair keep and metabolic are damage to occurs in and animals. can iron from and of proteins by H2O2 can also also iron from proteins (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). What of or in animals not cause many but of both and to and of the and of is et al., 2004; Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). of in also cause later in life et al., defenses are not oxidative damage to DNA, proteins, and lipids is in all aerobes under Indeed, this damage may to the development of in animals 2002) and perhaps even to itself. even 21% O2 is are all the ROS not because ROS perform so the was to evolve antioxidant defenses that such to with oxidative damage are e.g. to repair DNA, in enzymes, repair on proteins some of which are requiring in but not in and and lipids and In could ROS be of ROS production in animals by and by other cells in the and is a against 2004; et al., 2005). is with of by and of and but we have in the that by oxidation and reduction is only the two systems i.e. the redox state of the cell and For example, of to growth on cells that then and subsequent proteins in the at the ROS levels and facilitate the some can be directly by ROS (e.g. some of in ROS not to they by et al., 2005). are in but can be and by ROS. the and the ROS by the ROS the O2 ⋅− production, e.g. by O2 oxidase were in 2004), but are now to be in see the rest of this In when cells are exposed to H2O2 (e.g. at a of or or when oxidase are the are partially to the are more to The cell then rapidly more and the so that the H2O2 can be removed it has its and et al., 2005). ROS production is often of as a an of electron under O2, a view with the of However, another view is that in H2O2 production are a that the and the are to in redox and of antioxidants are useful in to study the of ROS et al., 2006). ROS may perform similar What if the balance between ROS and antioxidants is too many ROS in to the antioxidants is to be a state of oxidative this term as a in the balance in of the to damage is often oxidative which has been as the damage by of reactive species the of living organisms (Halliwell and Whiteman, 2004). oxidative damage can not only from more oxidative but also from to repair or can from in antioxidant e.g. the levels of of dietary antioxidants and other dietary (e.g. and can also cause For example, with the suffer oxidative low levels of in the and iron to make 2005). can also be due to increased ROS production, e.g. by exposure to elevated O2, the of that ROS (e.g. or of systems ROS, e.g. of (Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). cells to oxidative Adapted from Halliwell and Gutteridge (2006) by courtesy of Oxford University Press. of by low levels of reactive species is with increased of The cell is a reducing especially the and but less so in the a is required for and disulphide reactive species. ROS are all over the in plants, and aerobic without them or we from they often us in the over the human the damage by ROS, if not repair to in the can to the development of and many other Halliwell and Gutteridge, 2006). This may be a by product of ROS are for against and until your has and have if they in the later Evolution antioxidant supplements not make us for because the human body the balance so that antioxidants not it and oxidative damage not
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Barry Halliwell (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: