Key result
Microwave ablation using multiple simultaneously powered antennas created significantly larger cross-sectional ablation areas (26.6 cm2 at 2.5-cm spacing) than single antennas (6.76 cm2, P<.001).
Why the study?
Does microwave ablation with multiple simultaneously powered antennas increase the size of ablation zones in an in vivo swine liver model?
Does microwave ablation with multiple simultaneously powered antennas increase the size of ablation zones in an in vivo swine liver model?
Absolute Event Rate: 26.6% vs 6.76%
p-value: p=<.001
A single generator can effectively power multiple microwave antennas to create significantly larger ablation zones in liver tissue compared to single antennas.
May enable larger ablation zones in liver models; leaves open human translation pending prospective trials.
PURPOSE: To prospectively investigate the ability of a single generator to power multiple small-diameter antennas and create large zones of ablation in an in vivo swine liver model. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Thirteen female domestic swine (mean weight, 70 kg) were used for the study as approved by the animal care and use committee. A single generator was used to simultaneously power three triaxial antennas at 55 W per antenna for 10 minutes in three groups: a control group where antennas were spaced to eliminate ablation zone overlap (n=6; 18 individual zones of ablation) and experimental groups where antennas were spaced 2.5 cm (n=7) or 3.0 cm (n=5) apart. Animals were euthanized after ablation, and ablation zones were sectioned and measured. A mixed linear model was used to test for differences in size and circularity among groups. RESULTS: Mean (+/-standard deviation) cross-sectional areas of multiple-antenna zones of ablation at 2.5- and 3.0-cm spacing (26.6 cm(2) +/- 9.7 and 32.2 cm(2) +/- 8.1, respectively) were significantly larger than individual ablation zones created with single antennas (6.76 cm(2) +/- 2.8, P<.001) and were 31% (2.5-cm spacing group: multiple antenna mean area, 26.6 cm(2); 3 x single antenna mean area, 20.28 cm(2)) to 59% (3.0-cm spacing group: multiple antenna mean area, 32.2 cm(2); 3 x single antenna mean area, 20.28 cm(2)) larger than 3 times the mean area of the single-antenna zones. Zones of ablation were found to be very circular, and vessels as large as 1.1 cm were completely coagulated with multiple antennas. CONCLUSION: A single generator may effectively deliver microwave power to multiple antennas. Large volumes of tissue may be ablated and large vessels coagulated with multiple-antenna ablation in the same time as single-antenna ablation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brace et al. (2007) studied Liver ablation (in vivo swine model) (n=13). Microwave ablation with multiple simultaneously powered triaxial antennas vs. Single antennas (spaced to eliminate overlap) was evaluated on Cross-sectional area of ablation zones (p=<.001). Microwave ablation using multiple simultaneously powered antennas created significantly larger cross-sectional ablation areas (26.6 cm2 at 2.5-cm spacing) than single antennas (6.76 cm2, P<.001).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: