Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ethnographic hunter-gatherers exhibit fission-fusion cycles explained, for instance, as modular organisation of group sizes. However well models explain ethnographic pattern, archaeological tests pose challenges when we approach remote hunter-gatherers using what the !Kung teach us. We believe that eastern North American Paleoindians practiced fission-fusion, based partly on sites considered aggregations because they are unusually large and possibly organised as collections of smaller modules. Owing precisely to the flexibility that encompasses fission-fusion, however, large sites can be one-time aggregations or accumulations from repeated occupations. Seeking ethnographic pattern in material data presumes valid archaeological measures of contemporaneous group size and occupation span. Assemblage size and composition reflect group size and behaviour, but also span (itself parsed as aggregate or per capita) in ways not always appreciated. Surovell’s models of hunter-gatherer assemblage accumulation and methods to estimate span distinguish synchronic aggregation from diachronic accumulation in eastern North American Paleoindian data. This exploratory study applies Surovell’s models to Ontario’s Fisher Paleoindian site, where it both confounds and corroborates expectations based on simple correspondence between ethnographic and archaeological contexts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Michael Shott (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: