Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The tongue-in-groove (TIG) technique is a versatile surgical approach for modification of the lower third of the nose, long recognized as one of the most challenging aspects of rhinoplasty. This technique can be performed through a hemistransfixion, full transfixion, or external rhinoplasty approach and is useful for altering the tip position, correcting tip ptosis due to pull of the depressor septi nasi muscle, narrowing the widened columella, reducing excess columellar show, and straightening the deviated caudal septum. Following any required septoplasty, retrograde dissection performed between the medial crura creates a potential space that can be advanced against the caudal septum in a TIG fashion. If there is excessive width to the columella or tip ptosis from depressor septi nasi pull preoperatively, soft tissue resection from the pocket may help narrow the columella and prevent tip ptosis with smiling. Because of the space created between the medial crura, further caudal septal excision is usually unnecessary. A bilateral membranous septum excision is necessary to remove excess membrane, as the medial crura are advanced towards the caudal septum. When redundant mucoperichondrium posterior to the transfixion is excised and sewn closed, the resultant pull positions the medial crura snugly over the caudal septum like a hammock to sustain the TIG result. A transfixion incision accomplishes this easily, but when using a hemitransfixion incision, a fusiform ellipse of mucosa can be excised from the contralateral membranous septum. The medial crura are then sutured to the caudal septum to establish the desired tip projection and rotation. The can be achieved using 3 to 4 transmucosal chromic sutures spanning the medial crura and septum. Alternatively, permanent polypropylene (Prolene) or semi-permanent polydioxanone (PDS) sutures can be placed in buried fashion, typically via an external rhinoplasty exposure, to secure the caudal medial crura to the caudal septum.1 Even when planning to perform an open rhinoplasty, we prefer first to apply the TIG technique through a transfixion incision, as the TIG modifications are easier to perform when the hammock-like configuration of the medial crural pocket is preserved. In their paper, the authors evaluated the change in tip rotation, as measured by nostril axis, in 17 patients in whom the TIG technique was used as the primary tip rotation maneuver during open rhinoplasty.2 The inclusion criteria included an under-rotated tip, a relatively long caudal septum and at least 3 mm of columellar show. Patients submitted to other maneuvers that might have impacted tip rotation were excluded from the study. All 17 patients also had cephalic trims, which the authors believed had a minimal impact on the final tip rotation. Using standardized photometric measurements, they observed an average preoperative tip rotation of 93.95°, immediate postoperative rotation of 114.47°, and 1-year postoperative rotation of 106.55°. They found a statistically significant 7.9° decrease in tip rotation from immediately after surgery to 1 year after surgery (P < 0.0001). Based on their data, the authors proposed that for every degree of rotation gained during surgery using the TIG technique, one can expect to lose 0.35° over the first year after surgery. They concluded that the TIG is more dependable than other methods of tip rotation that rely solely on healing and contraction, and when employing the TIG technique for tip rotation, surgeons should overcorrect the amount of tip rotation to account for the expected counter-rotation over time. The TIG technique can be a reliable method of setting nasal tip projection and rotation when used in the right patient. However, the TIG technique is intended to be used in conjunction with other surgical maneuvers, rather than as a stand-alone maneuver, in most cases.1 Rhinoplasty surgeons often utilize multiple techniques to execute tip modifications that can be performed incrementally and reversibly without sacrificing the integrity of the cartilaginous framework.3,4 Cephalic trim, scroll excision, and domal suturing are common techniques used for modest tip rotation. Techniques such as the lateral crural steal and lateral crural overlay can further reshape and reposition the tip cartilages to rotate the tip.5 Also to be mentioned is the potential impact that tip projection modifications, such as a columellar strut graft, can have on tip rotation. We agree that the TIG technique is a more reliable means of tip rotation compared to methods that rely solely on contraction, and a certain degree of tip counter-rotation is expected after surgery as swelling subsides. However, when someone utilizes a technique, he/she may be doing it slightly differently than others, resulting in different outcomes. The authors reported an average loss of 7.9° in tip rotation over the first year using plain sutures to fixate the medial crura to the septum. In contrast, Pensler noted a minimal change in tip rotation in 76 patients with a longer average follow-up of 2.4 years, in whom he used PDS sutures to fixate the medial crura to the caudal septum using the TIG technique.6 Whatever technique is used, critical long-term follow up is essential to see if the results stand the test of time. The consistent loss of tip rotation described by the authors could be due to the healing process but might also be due to surgical technique. The choice of suture material for medial crura fixation to the septum may affect the longevity of TIG tip repositioning. Wound tensile strength is minimal during the initial inflammatory healing phase, which typically lasts 5 to 7 days. Collagen synthesis begins in earnest only after the inflammatory processes of wound healing have subsided and usually reaches peak production at ~3 weeks after surgery.7 Plain sutures retain tensile strength for only up to 10 days and Chromic sutures maintain their load-bearing capabilities for approximately 21 days. By comparison, the tensile strength of PDS persists for up to six weeks, and polypropylene (Prolene) is permanent.8 When the TIG technique is employed exclusively for tip repositioning, permanent or semi-permanent sutures used to fixate the medial crura to the caudal septum and secure the domal cartilages and medial crura to themselves may provide better long-term support as the nose heals, particularly in patients exhibiting thick soft tissue envelopes and poor tip support. In general, noses with strong medial crura that extend to the nasal spine tend not to lose projection after surgery. Conversely, patients who have weak medial crura and those that do not reach the nasal spine or posterior septal angle, and heavy soft tissue envelopes are apt to lose projection over time due to the normal aging process.9,10 Disruption of the ligamentous attachments between the domal cartilages and between the medial crura to the caudal septum and separation of the scroll at the time of surgery can result in loss of tip support, especially in open rhinoplasty. Insufficient tip support may result in unintended postoperative tip ptosis.6 In addition to suturing the medial crura to the septum, the medial crura should be bound to one another or, in select cases, to a columellar strut to bolster tip support and minimize postoperative tip counter-rotation. One should always consider the resiliency and length of the medial crura, the amount of tip support present, and the thickness of the soft tissue envelope during rhinoplasty. In this paper, we do not know whether tip-supporting maneuvers were performed and the medial crura were sutured together, which may shed light on another potential reason for the authors’ observed tip counter-rotation. We routinely remove excess membranous septum when performing the TIG technique to pull the medial crura over the caudal septum like a hammock to sustain TIG modifications.1 Additionally, if not removed, the redundant mucosa may bunch up and become visible on base view. Preoperatively, we evaluate our patients for tip ptosis when smiling to assess depressor septi nasi muscle activity, a common concern for those presenting for rhinoplasty. Using the TIG technique for access, partial resection of the depressor septi nasi muscle addresses this problem and may prevent postoperative tip ptosis from the muscle’s repetitive downward pull on the tip (Figure 1). A 27-year-old female desired dorsal hump reduction and tip rotation. (A, C) Preoperative photographs, at rest and smiling, demonstrate the downward pull of the depressor septi nasi muscle on the nasal tip with smiling. To rotate the tip, cephalic trim, single and double domal sutures, and the TIG technique were employed. The TIG technique was performed through a full transfixion incision, which also provided access for resection of the depressor septi nasi muscle. The medial crura were sutured together to preserve tip support. Additionally, the patient had a dorsal reduction, medial and lateral osteotomies, bilateral spreader grafts, and a supratip crushed cartilage onlay graft. (B) Postoperative photographs taken 1 month and 4 days after surgery demonstrate dorsal hump reduction and tip rotation and (D) a tip that no longer pulls down when smiling after resection of the depressor septi nasi muscle. Proper taping and splinting of the nose at the conclusion of the rhinoplasty are essential for minimizing edema and maintaining the tip position as the nose heals. In addition to taping the dorsum and supratip region, use the tape to create an infratip lobule sling with the ends of the tape secured to the dorsum to minimize tip swelling and maintain tip rotation. It is also crucial that the splint is appropriately sized and ends at the supratip, as an overly long splint may push the tip downward. The TIG technique is a versatile surgical approach that allows the surgeon to perform myriad nasal tip, columellar, and caudal septal modifications. This paper discusses its use to accomplish tip rotation. Tip support is an important consideration when establishing the tip rotation using the TIG technique, as a poor tip support may result in unwanted counter-rotation postoperatively. In the appropriate patient with adequate tip support, the TIG technique may be an effective primary method for tip rotation using permanent or semi-permanent sutures for fixation. This study is important because it points to a loss of tip rotation with the TIG maneuver over time in patients in whom plain sutures alone were used to secure the medial crura to the septum. The findings might encourage more surgeons to use permanent or semi-permanent sutures to fixate the medial crura to the septum and to one another for lasting tip rotation and stronger tip support. Certain patients with very ptotic tips may need the addition of a combination of tip rotation maneuvers, such as the lateral crural overlay or lateral crural steal, in addition to the TIG technique. The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and publication of this article. The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and publication of this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kridel et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: