Key result
Obstetric general anaesthesia claims were more likely to lead to a financial cost and had a higher median cost (£41,594 vs £5,678) compared to regional anaesthesia claims.
Litigation claims related to obstetric general anaesthesia are rare but tend to be more severe and associated with greater costs per claim compared to regional anaesthesia.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Highlights greater litigation costs with obstetric general anaesthesia; leaves open whether this reflects true risk differences in non-randomized claims data.
We have recently published several papers describing anaesthesia related claims against the National Health Service Litigation Authority (NHSLA) [1–4]. This letter serves to report, in brief, aspects of claims relating to obstetric general anaesthesia not reported in those papers and provides some comparison with obstetric regional anaesthesia claims [4]. We studied NHSLA claims from 1995 to 2007; the methodology is reported elsewhere [1]. Financial settlements were adjusted using the Retail Price Index to 2006 values. Of 841 relevant interpretable claims 246 (29%) described obstetric anaesthesia and 82% were closed at a total cost of £8.6m. These included 29 (12%) obstetric general anaesthesia claims, 186 (76%) obstetric regional anaesthesia claims and 31 in which the type of anaesthesia was unclear (most at caesarean section). The 29 obstetric general anaesthesia claims represent 3.4% of all claims. Half of obstetric general anaesthesia claims and one third of obstetric regional anaesthesia claims described moderate or severe outcomes [5]. Obstetric general anaesthesia claims included two deaths and obstetric regional anaesthesia claims none. Four fifths of obstetric general anaesthesia claims (Table 1) described awareness during caesarean section; in contrast 21% of non-obstetric general anaesthesia claims described awareness [2] and 31% of obstetric regional anaesthesia claims described inadequate anaesthesia. The incidence of awareness in obstetric general anaesthesia has been reported as 0.26–0.4% [6–8], which extrapolates to approximately 40–60 UK cases over 10 years [9]. Both deaths involved intubation difficulty, hypoxia and subsequent death on the intensive care unit. These two deaths contrast with nine attributable to airway and breathing problems in the last four Confidential Enquires into Maternal and Child Health/Confidential Enquiries into Maternal Deaths reports [10]; explanations include the limited scope of the NHSLA dataset (NHS and England only) and the fact that not all injuries lead to litigation. Obstetric general anaesthesia claims accounted for 12% of all obstetric claims. The National Obstetric Anaesthetic Database estimates that 10.5–15% of all obstetric anaesthetics are general anaesthetics [9]; however, obstetric general anaesthesia claims were more likely to lead to a cost (96% vs 69% regional anaesthesia) and had a higher cost per claim. The total and median (IQR [range]) cost of closed claims for obstetric general anaesthesia (25 claims) was £2.2m and £41 594 (£17 408–£66 223 [0–£626 823]) respectively, while for obstetric regional anaesthesia (149 claims) it was £5.4m and £5678 (£0–27 690 [0–£1 597 565]). Over the 12 years examined, obstetric regional anaesthesia claims following caesarean section increased while their associated annual cost declined; conversely obstetric general anaesthesia claims remained roughly constant but their associated cost rose. The median cost of claims relating to death was nearly 20-fold more than for a ‘severe’ claim. This contrasts with other NHSLA datasets where severe injuries led to higher cost than death [1]. Maternal death is likely to be disproportionately expensive because of the cost of caring for a surviving child, perhaps also damaged by the same event. The NHSLA obstetric anaesthesia database, despite its deficiencies, presents a relevant record of litigation practices over the last decade. Reviews of litigation can point towards areas of risk that might not be raised from critical incident reporting or obstetric surveillance systems. In summary, obstetric general anaesthesia claims in the NHSLA dataset are rather few. They are primarily associated with awareness and as a group such claims tend to be more severe and associated with a greater cost per claim than obstetric regional anaesthesia claims.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ashpole et al. (2010) conducted a letter in Obstetric anaesthesia claims (n=841). Obstetric general anaesthesia vs. Obstetric regional anaesthesia was evaluated on Claim leading to a financial cost. Obstetric general anaesthesia claims were more likely to lead to a financial cost and had a higher median cost (£41,594 vs £5,678) compared to regional anaesthesia claims.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: