Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The team that won the departmental birding contest at my university this past year counted 32 species during a 6-h intensive, car-aided search—a good score even for an experienced eye on a cold winter day at 64 ° N. Compared with that, the tropics harbor an incredible number of species. So, when I teach undergraduate evolutionary biology, there will always be a student asking what “actually” causes that difference in species richness—often casually, or even ashamed of asking about such a well-known pattern, presuming that (s)he ought to have known the answer. Because I research models of speciation, extinction, and distribution of species, I feel embarrassed to honestly answer: “I don't know.” I teach the students about various processes that could shape biodiversity patterns: speciation, extinction, range shifts, and how present and historical, biotic and abiotic factors could directly or indirectly affect the distribution of species over the earth; and yet, I cannot answer why most species are found in the tropics. Fortunately, I can rest assured that I am not the only one who does not know the answer but would like to know it. This new edited volume, Speciation and patterns of diversity, represents the proceedings of the 2007 annual symposium of the British Ecological Society (BES): “Speciation and Ecology.” The incentive for that meeting, and hence for the book being reviewed, was the 2002 BES meeting on macroecology, where the organizers argued that large-scale biodiversity patterns are shaped by 3 key processes: speciation, extinction, and range shifts. At the 2002 conference, there was relatively little discussion about speciation, and so the intention of the 2007 meeting was to focus on the role of speciation in shaping patterns of biodiversity. Hence, according to the editors: “our intention in this volume is to examine the thesis that mechanisms and rates of speciation are key determinants of biodiversity patterns” and “this volume … aims to foster communication among the various disciplines that can contribute to this exploration.” Especially in the light of the latter aim, the editors have been successful: the volume comprises 16 chapters. The first is written by the editors and serves mostly as an introduction to, and discussion of, the other chapters. Those other 15 contributions cover a range of systems, scales, and approaches: theoretical, conceptual, as well as empirical, from protists, microbes, and microcosm studies of bacteria, to continental-scale patterns in birds and mammals. Written by prominent scientists in their respective fields, these chapters together provide an interesting diversity of views on the role of speciation in shaping diversity patterns. However, it is too early to judge whether or not the first aim of the book is also accomplished. Not surprisingly, after reading the book, one is left with the impression that speciation is indeed a key process generating biodiversity, which is probably what most of us would guess as well. However, where the 2002 BES meeting focused on extinction and range dynamics, these processes receive little attention in the present volume. Perhaps we will see yet another annual symposium in the future where the complete picture of speciation, extinction, range shifts, and diversification (genetic and phenotypic) will be considered. In any case, the chapters here examine the role of speciation from various points of view but are perhaps too few and too diverse to merit any kind of conclusion or consensus. Indeed, there seems to be a parallel between the 2002 “Macroecology” and the 2007 “Speciation and Ecology” meetings: Macroecology broke with the tradition of hypothetico-deductive ecological research, attempting to generalize the findings of very many descriptive small-scale studies in search of unifying principles. Macroecology became very popular and—arguably—successful in just a decade. Similarly, Speciation and patterns of diversity could be regarded as an early attempt to find unifying principles in the seemingly idiosyncratic results of many studies of speciation in different environments, at different spatial scales, and at different time scales. (This need for models and generalization is explicitly stated by Curtis, Wallbridge, and Sloan in their chapter on diversification in microbial communities, but in my opinion, it applies more broadly.) The first contributed chapter is by Jody Hey in which he argues, with a short historical background, that as technical development progresses the designation of taxonomic status (species) to groups of individuals will inevitably be arbitrary but should be chosen so as to be applicable to as wide an array of organisms as possible. Of course, we have heard this argument many times before, but Hey's argument is novel in a sense, although perhaps paradoxical: that arbitrary quantitative definitions of taxonomic boundaries will lead to objectively identified “real” species, which (at least theoretically) paves the way for comparable species definitions across higher taxa. I know several colleagues who would prefer to blacklist the question: “Okay, but what is a species?” in any symposium; but the argument reiterated by Hey remains central to the quantification and understanding of biodiversity patterns: If we are to find patterns and unifying principles in the diversification of populations, species, and taxa of still higher rank to answer “big questions” about evolution, it would be very helpful if the data were comparable in the first place. Conceptual and broad questions are in fact the basis for most of the subsequent chapters, even though they may be addressed in a specialized fashion. Therefore, I will use these questions to review the book rather than summarizing individual chapters. Probably the most general, the “biggest,” question is posed in the introductory chapter and closely resembles Hutchinson's (1959) famous Homage to Santa Rosalia: how many species are there, how are they distributed over space and over higher taxa, and why is that so? Unsurprisingly, the question is not answered in the book, but how the subsequent chapters pertain to these questions is explained. Bridle, Polechova, and Vines address the issue by asking (and investigating theoretically) why species have finite ranges in space and time: why do not all organisms belong to a universally adapted superspecies? Barraclough, Fontaneto, Herniou, and Ricci investigate whether asexual organisms also diversify into species (attempting to avoid answering the question by choice of species concept), a question upon which Bell also touches in his account of laboratory studies of diversification in protists. His assertion that “bacterial populations … will readily undergo adaptive radiation into a variety of specialized types, as seen in the laboratory” may come as a surprise to those researchers who have attempted to study ecological speciation and adaptive radiation; especially, in the traditionally well-studied groups like birds, mammals, and flowering plants, where evidence is not quite as easily obtained, as reviewed in the chapters by Funk and by Nosil and Harmon. Similarly, Gavrilets and Vose note that adaptive radiation has received surprisingly little attention from modelers. The study of ecological speciation has taken a high flight in recent years and is most suitable for a symposium called “Speciation and Ecology.” It is therefore not surprising that much attention is paid to the central idea that ecological processes may promote speciation. Phillimore and Price, however, point out that ecological factors may inhibit as well as promote the formation of species, and they investigate the temporal pattern of speciation in this light. Their's is also 1 of 4 chapters representing another rapidly expanding field, which attempts to infer information from the temporal pattern of speciation, typically using molecular phylogenetic data. Certainly, in this field, the search for general (temporal) patterns and unifying principles in the process of diversification is already on its way, as is clear in particular from Ricklefs' contribution “Speciation, Extinction, and Diversity.” The emphasis in this volume on unifying conceptual issues is perhaps best illustrated by the fact that the only chapter truly concerned with spatial patterns of diversity is Schemske's investigation of the possible role of biotic interactions in generating high diversity in the tropics. Also, there are only 2 chapters focusing explicitly on the evidence from particular systems: Lake Victoria cichlids (by Seehausen) and Heliconius butterflies (by Mallet), representing some of the primary model systems in empirical speciation research. In conclusion, Speciation and patterns of diversity provides an interestingly diverse cross-disciplinary view of the modern study of speciation from a biogeographical perspective. As is unfortunately common with edited volumes composed of chapters contributed by many authors, the chapters themselves are only loosely coherent for which the editors' own, introductory chapter attempts to compensate. However, most of the chapters are firmly rooted in conceptual questions of broad and lasting interest, so that the volume is more than a collection of papers describing the research interests of a collection of scientists. In my opinion, this book (rather than the individual chapters on their own) is interesting and worthwhile reading for postgraduate students and researchers interested in speciation and patterns of diversity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Folmer Bokma (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: