Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Taxic homology constitutes evidence of monophyly (Patterson, 1982), whereas transformational homology involves evolutionary series from plesiomorphic to apomorphic homologues. Integration of the two approaches is best effected by considering the issues of the transformational approach as a subset of those of the taxic [origin of taxa] approach. The role of homology in phylogenetic reconstruction is limited to the production of cladograms, or classifications. These activities need have no evolutionary connotations. If phylogeny has to be about evolution, homology has nothing to contribute to it. The same organ in different animals under every variety of form and function. Homologous features are those which characterize monophyletic groups. The definition implies either that paraphyletic groups are not characterized by homologies, or that shared primitive characters are non-homologous, something which is certainly counter-intuitive. Although the equivalence of homology and Hennig's concept of synapomorphy is implicit in Hennig's work(e.g. 1966; p. 95), I did not become fully aware of the equation until early in 1976, through a manuscript by Gareth Nelson. That manuscript is just published (Nelson and Platnick, 1981), but appreciation of the equivalence of homology and synapomorphy is fairly widespread (Wiley, 1975, 1976; Bonde, 1977, p. 779; Bock, 1977, p. 888; Szalay, 1977, p. 16; Platnick and Cameron, 1977; Nelson, 1978; Cracraft, 1978; Patterson, [1978]; Platnick, [1978]; Gaffney, [1979]). With the advent of Hennig's (1965, 1966) Phylogenetic Systematics, homology started being understood in cladistic theory and practice from a new approach—i.e. as synapomorphy (shared derived characters) (e.g. Wiley, 1975…) The cladistic equation of homology with synapomorphy brought precise and simple clarity to a fundamental yet formerly nebulous idea. The insight was so appealing that several thinkers came to it independently (e.g. Wiley, 1975, 1976; Bonde, 1977; Platnick and Cameron, 1977; Cracraft, 1978; Nelson, 1978; Patterson, 1978; Gaffney, 1979; Platnick, 1979; Nelson and Platnick, 1981), prior to the widely cited paper by Patterson (1982). Some symplesiomorphies are “homologies” inasmuch as they represent synapomorphies of more inclusive taxa. In all those respects, BdP's position on homology was unquestionably superior to Patterson's. They did not, however, point that out, or even take note of NAS or non-transformationalism. Their list of citations consequently gave the impression that Patterson's views were like everyone else's. That impression, to say the least, was most unfortunate. Between rejecting transformation and pushing his bizarre NAS scheme, Patterson was well on the way to turning “cladistics” into a kind of creationist neo-typology. Cladists may find that unpleasant to contemplate, but even so, it is better to know the danger than not.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
James S. Farris (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: