This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Turmoil in the hospital environment and other dynamics in the health care system in the past decade have not been very conducive to the development of a favourable nurse work environment tuned to the delivery of high quality patient centered care. Clinical care delivery in hospitals is affected by health care reforms and reengineering operations. Nursing resources are unfortunately often one of the prime targets in these dynamics. Evidence from international studies shows that nurses are increasingly dissatisfied with working conditions in hospitals [1,2]. Moreover, the perception of nurses' and patients that there is a deterioration in the quality of care is being substantiated by recent reports showing the negative impact of not enough nursing care (both in terms of amount and qualification of nurses) on morbidity and mortality in hospital settings [3–10]. Organizational characteristics of the nurse work environment do influence this link as we learn from the magnet hospital research [7,11,12]. Magnet hospitals were hospitals in the early 1980s, which were able to attract and retain nurses despite an existing nurse shortage. The American Academy of Nursing launched an initiative to identify the organizational characteristics of these hospitals which resulted in two decades of ongoing research of which an overview was recently published [13]. Magnet hospitals are characterized by a professional nurse practice environment as substantiated by: (1) nurses being able to work with clinically competent nurses; (2) good nurse-physician relationships and communication; (3) nurse autonomy and accountability; (4) supportive nurse manager/supervisor; (5) control over nurse practice environment; (6) support of education; (7) adequate nurse staffing; (8) concern for patient is paramount [11]. Please note factors like patient centeredness, communication, adequate resources, and good leadership prevailing in these environments. Research has also focused on evaluating nurses' and patient's outcomes in magnet hospitals [2,7,12] revealing that these hospitals had not only better nurses' outcomes in view of retention, burnout, job turnover and nurse safety (e.g. needle sticks), but importantly, they also showed favourable results in view of patient outcomes as substantiated by higher patient satisfaction, lower morbidity and lower mortality [2,4,7,8,12]. Based on this evidence, it seems worthwhile to invest in creating a better nurse work environment with the goal not only to create a more favourable professional nurse work environment but also to enhance patient outcomes. The Royal College of Nursing in an attempt to transfer the magnet hospital characteristics to other hospital settings focused primarily on the leadership style prevailing in magnet hospitals. Magnet hospitals leaders used instead of a ‘top-down’“get things done‘“born in church, raised in the army’ management style so typical to hospital environments, a what is called transformational leadership style. This leadership style contrasts to the creativity stifling old-fashioned management in that these leaders instil faith and respect (charisma), treat each employee as an individual (individualised consideration), arouse innovative ways of problem solving (intellectual stimulation), transmit their values and ethical principles (idealised influence), provide challenging goals and communicate a vision of the future (inspirational role). Transformational leadership emerges as a leadership style that fits better the current volatile hospital environment where the only real constant is change and where survival is dependent of fast adaptation in this changing world. Transformational leadership is crucial to the building of cohesive, adaptive work teams that ultimately lead to success [14]. Evidence from non health care settings and findings from our own research in hospitals confirms the positive associations of transformational leadership and higher employee satisfaction and performance parameters [15–20]. Employee satisfaction further correlates positively with consumers satisfaction in environments where services are delivered in a direct employee-consumer interface as is the case in health care [21–23]. The Royal College of Nursing building on the insight that good leaders produce good care and that poor leaders produce poor care, launched the Clinical Leadership Project, with the goal to enhance transformational leadership style in head nurses [24]. Head nurses hold key positions in hospital settings. It was hypothesised that enhancing their leadership style would be a first important step to improving nurse practice environments and realising more patient centered care in hospitals [25]. The 12–18 months Clinical Leadership Program builds on an action learning approach and inputs from different data sources (e.g. 360° leadership style feedback) and other instruments (e.g. personal development plan, observation of care, patient stories, individual feedback, workshops, mentorship and action learning sets). Action learning, in contrast to the more linear top-down change strategies, refers to a circular dynamic in which groups are empowered to identify a real life problem that would be worthwhile to change, to determine a possible action plan for change, to try this out in real life and to feed back the result to the group afterwards, which then determines the next step to be taken [26,27]. The premise of this approach is that there is no learning without action and no action without learning. The facilitator who participates in the action learning group uses a non directive, supportive, democratic and enabling style. Action learning has proven to be a superior methodology to implement and sustain change. Moreover, it has shown to mobilize the creativity and commitment from groups to contribute to sustained system change [28,29]. Findings from the pilot study in the UK and from the Belgium/Swiss study show that favourable effects can be observed in head nurses' leadership style and some indications can be found that the effects also radiate to nurses' and patients' outcomes [25,30]. Overall, the major theme emerging from interpretation of the results is that head nurses made the transition from being combat troopers or victims to more proactive partners in the hospital system. The major areas where the change took place were better self management, improved management of teams and better relationships with the organization. The program will be further disseminated in the UK, Scotland, Belgium, Switzerland and recently also in Australia [31]. The Clinical Leadership Project, i.e. transformational leadership, seems to hold promise to provide a valuable instrument to nursing to improve nurse work environments and to contribute to patient centered care, two factors that are conducive to better nurses' and patients' outcomes. Its underlying methodology based on action learning should become a standard competence of nurse leaders at all levels, including advanced clinical care practitioners who want to expand and advance nursing care for specific patient populations as well as nurse managers. Action learning could be included in the curricula of Master's of Nursing Science programs to prepare students how to engage in theory-practice transfer. In the UK the Clinical Leadership Project has become a key instrument in the ‘Modernisation Agency’ of the National Health Service [32]. It is time we all get inspired!
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Claessens et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: