The Relevance of Donor T Cell-Directed Immunoglobulin G in Historic Sera in the Age of Flow Cytometry

BACKGROUND: Renal transplant recipients with a positive historic cross-match due to donor T cell-directed IgG antibodies are considered to have decreased graft survival, even if their current serum is negative prior to transplantation. With the use of flow cytometric cross-match for testing current sera, false-negative results could be eliminated and the outcome of transplantation in this group of patients could be improved, assuming that immunological memory is effectively controlled with immunosuppression. METHODS: We reviewed our records to identify those patients who underwent cadaveric renal transplant, with a historic IgG positive cytotoxic T cell cross-match and a current negative flow cytometric T cell cross-match. RESULTS: Eighteen patients underwent cadaveric renal transplant in the face of a historic IgG positive T cell cross-match and a current negative flow cytometric T cell cross-match. In 14 patients treated with cyclosporine-based immunosuppression the 1-, 2-, and 3-year cumulative graft survival rates were 57, 50, and 43%, respectively. Ten of the 14 patients (71%) ultimately lost their grafts. CONCLUSIONS: Even with negative flow cytometric cross-match in current serum, a positive historic conventional cross-match suggests a high risk of graft failure.