Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Shows that adjusting for present-at-admission diagnoses improves mortality prediction in acute myocardial infarction, indicating significant changes in evaluated hospital performance.
We thank Drs Gale, Manda, and Birkhead for their comments and questions regarding our study. The variables in our model were derived from California hospital data similar to most US hospital administrative data, except for one difference: California hospitals report which secondary diagnoses were present at admission. The California data included up to 20 ICD-9-CM diagnosis codes for each patient. We grouped the codes into 233 mutually exclusive categories of comorbid disease and included these as dichotomous variables in the model. arsimonious models can be advantageous when original data collection is required and resources are limited. However, our study used data routinely collected on discharge from US hospitals. Our aims were to use available hospital data distinguishing which diagnoses are present at admission to develop a valid model that maximally explained and accurately predicted death. We found that substantial additional predictive value is obtained by including adjustments for the large number of conditions that are present at admission, including conditions with small effects on mortality and conditions that occur infrequently. The model that we achieved improved statistical performance and demonstrated external predictive validity in an independent California hospital discharge data set. Most importantly, we found that the increase in statistical performance matters, because models with better statistical performance produce substantially different results about which hospitals have better or worse than expected death rates.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Stukenborg et al. (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: