Key result
The Biro method for measuring systemic oxygen uptake showed poor agreement with the standard Fick-derived method, with wide limits of agreement (-162 to 311 ml/min before bypass).
Why the study?
Does the novel Biro method agree with the standard Fick-derived method for measuring systemic oxygen uptake in patients undergoing elective cardiac surgery?
Observational (n=29)
Does the novel Biro method agree with the standard Fick-derived method for measuring systemic oxygen uptake in patients undergoing elective cardiac surgery?
The novel Biro method is an unreliable measure of systemic oxygen uptake compared to the Fick-derived method during elective cardiac surgery.
Biro method should not be used for oxygen uptake in cardiac surgery; leaves open validation of accurate alternatives.
We assessed agreement between measurement of systemic oxygen uptake using the Fick-derived method, and a novel method described by Biro, based on the difference in oxygen concentrations of the delivered fresh gas and the gas circulating in the circle system. Twenty-nine patients undergoing elective cardiac surgery were studied during stable haemodynamic and ventilatory conditions. Systemic oxygen uptake was measured using the two methods in each patient before and after cardiopulmonary bypass. Limits of agreement were found to be wide (-162 to 311 ml.min-1 before bypass, and -257 to 401 ml.min-1 after bypass), indicating poor agreement between the methods. No significant difference was found between the pre- and post cardiopulmonary bypass values for each method. We conclude that the Biro method, although attractive in terms of its simplicity, is an unreliable measure of systemic oxygen uptake under these conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Leonard et al. (2002) conducted an observational in Elective cardiac surgery (n=29). Biro method vs. Fick-derived method was evaluated on Agreement in systemic oxygen uptake measurement (Limits of agreement -162 to 311 ml.min-1 (before bypass) and -257 to 401 ml.min-1 (after bypass)). The Biro method for measuring systemic oxygen uptake showed poor agreement with the standard Fick-derived method, with wide limits of agreement (-162 to 311 ml/min before bypass).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: