Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Garden in Motion: Botanical Exchange and Transnational Collaboration in Leslie Marmon Silko’s Gardens in the Dunes Yeonhaun Kang (bio) In a 1998 interview with Ellen Arnold, in advance of the release of her third novel, Gardens in the Dunes (1999), Leslie Marmon Silko explains how she became interested in plants: “They come from all over the world, and they’re also another way of looking at colonialism because everywhere the colonials went, the plants came back from there.”1 Breaking from her initial plan to write a “nonpolitical” novel after her angry, intensely political previous work, Almanac of the Dead (1991), received harsh criticism, Silko confesses that “it wasn’t too long before I realized how very political gardens are. . . . I had actually stumbled into the most political thing of all—how you grow your food, whether you eat, the fact that the plant collectors followed the Conquistadors.”2 The pages of Gardens evidence Silko’s keen interest in the relationship between plants and colonialism, and she dramatizes the historical contexts of Southwestern Indians’ struggles for food sovereignty and environmental justice. Set in the 1890s, the final decades of the Indian Wars in the West, Gardens revolves around the colonization of indigenous minds and bodies through a variety of processes under the flag of manifest destiny: the loss of land and natural resources in general and the disruption of Native foodways in particular.3 Whereas Silko’s first two novels, Ceremony (1977) and Almanac of the Dead, probe the exploitation and dispossession of the poor and Native peoples in the postwar period and late twentieth century respectively, Gardens focuses on the American West in the late nineteenth century and, correspondingly, invokes traditional literary forms such as the historical epic, literary realism, Victorian children’s literature, and women’s botanical writing. Against the backdrop of indigenous peoples’ land dispossession, Silko’s Gardens offers insights into the root causes of issues [End Page 103] such as poverty and health disparities that Native Americans face today. Moreover, it problematizes the privatization of food commons and its negative impacts on local communities from the Gilded Age to the present. In this sense, Gardens creates a narrative of longue durée that correlates the American West’s past, present, and future surrounding the history of settler colonialism and its link to environmental and social injustice in the United States and beyond. This essay examines how Silko, a writer of Laguna Pueblo, Mexican, and Anglo-American ancestry, employs the trope of the garden as a means of critiquing and revising modern America’s ecological imperialism, which has attempted to naturalize the conquest of Native lands and foodways. With Gardens, Silko shows how colonizing the West and “educating” Indians as U.S. citizens were projects integral to constructing American national identity at the turn of the twentieth century. On one level, the novel presents the garden as a window into U.S. settler colonialism and the advent of modern agriculture. However, the garden also provides a communal space for unexpected encounters and knowledge and seed exchange, which leads to self-transformation and transnational environmental organizing in latter portions of the novel. Drawing on what feminist science studies scholar Anna Tsing calls “patchiness,” I argue that tracing various forms of the garden in Silko’s novel—from the desert garden in Arizona to gardens on estates in California and New York to the English and Italian gardens in Europe—invites us to appreciate the precarity of the environment and the many worlds entwined with the global networks of plants.4 Though reading global history in relation to culturally situated, site-specific indigenous knowledge is often challenging and unpredictable due to problems of scale, Silko skillfully weaves these “unruly edges” through her garden narratives and asks us to cultivate “arts of noticing.”5 From this perspective, I investigate how Silko’s project in Gardens not only allows us to read the relationship between the development of Western science and modern capitalism and the expansion of settler colonialism around the globe but also opens up new possibilities for thinking and remaking the world with others, both humans and nonhumans. Current scholarship on Gardens typically centers on either...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yeonhaun Kang (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: