Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Over the past two decades, the Internet has emerged as a powerful tool for the dissemination of medical knowledge. The routine online publication of peer-reviewed journals and the standardisation of the portable document format (.pdf) marked a coming of age for Internet technology allowing readers, authors and editors to quickly access articles old and new and share them efficiently. Although the most prestigious medical journals still view the paper versions of their journals to be the pinnacle product, it is now standard for articles to be e-published online ‘ahead of print’, weeks to months before the paper passes through the press, and arrives on the doorstep. Thus, for most web-savvy and voracious readers, by the time physical journals appear in mailboxes, important or controversial new research has often already been read, discussed and debated at length in online and ‘real life’ forums. Emails have been written and responses have been sent to the editors. Opinions have been formed. However, because of print delays, some of the most thought-out and qualified opinions (i.e. experts' Letters to the Editor) have been embargoed from general consumption, waiting instead until future issues can be published. Meanwhile, print errors remain uncorrected. As the goals of peer-reviewed medical journals are to foster medical progress and improve research as a whole, this obsolete model must be phased out. The window between the acquisition of research knowledge and clinical translation can often gape longer than a decade. This was perhaps an acceptable although suboptimal reality before the advent of Internet-based technologies, but the recent social media revolution has made this untenable. If peer-reviewed journals adapt to a new reality, not only will such delays be shortened, but also the journals will find themselves to be more relevant than ever. On the other hand, those publications that fail to adapt will cease to be potent in the most meaningful ways. In this editorial, we suggest three key ways that peer-reviewed journals can maintain and increase their relevance in today's milieu: first, by embracing real-time interactivity; second, by embracing new tools to measure clinical impact; and third, by finally eliminating print publication. Social media medical education might be the inspiration for many of these changes. However, medical social media is still in its nascent stages; it must evolve as well. It requires adoption and adaptation of systems for peer review and information verification to allow trust by clinicians. Furthermore, the time demands of product creation will not be sustainable unless there is a path for academic advancement to support these activities. The development of new tools to estimate the influence of research publications, which take online activity into account, is overdue. The goal of peer-reviewed medical research is to impact professional behaviour. For this reason, the Journal Impact Factor (JIF) metric was first proposed in 1955 in the journal Science by Eugene Garfield and Irving H. Sher.1 The idea was that the more frequently an article was cited, the more impact it had in the field. However, the overall system was and remains flawed because citations alone do not always correlate with knowledge translation. However, the notion of a central locus for the efficient assessment of influence is an attractive one, and it is interesting to note that the same year that Garfield and Shef proposed the JIF, the American commercial air carrier Delta Airlines® famously adopted a new travel model, the ‘hub-and-spoke’ system. In this system, instead of point-to-point travel between destinations that did not have enough demand to sustain a profitable business model, far-flung travellers were ferried from smaller markets to large central hubs, making connections to other smaller markets. For the past few decades, curated ‘Journal Watches’ have served a similar function with some success, but it was not until the rise of Twitter® that a truly efficient hub-and-spoke system developed for medical research consumption. Now, instead of reading several particular journals many web-savvy physicians read a smaller number of journals cover-to-cover, and instead rely on Twitter® feeds to point out interesting, relevant articles from hundreds of journals. Under the system that has emerged in the past 5–10 years, a single tweet from an influential physician containing a link to an important article published by a lower impact-factor journal has the potential to change clinical practice far more rapidly than even an article from the New England Journal of Medicine or Lancet that does not receive this social media recirculation. Therefore, it might be the case that the attention brought to an article by social media outlets might already represent clinical impact more than virtually any other metric in use, such as the JIF or other media and promotional activities. The medical community should embrace this reality when assessing influence. Instead of relying solely on the number of citations a journal or an article later receives, a new Estimate of Clinical Influence could take into account number of online page views an article receives, downloads, discussion forum comments, as well as mentions, links and viral sharing on Twitter®, Facebook® and other social media. If peer-reviewed journals wish to enjoy the magnitude of relevance currently enjoyed by a relatively small number of thought leaders who have successfully embraced and harnessed social media technology, we believe opening peer-reviewed journal websites to genuine online interactivity and creating and promoting a new system to assess clinical impact of new research will be significant strides. A prevalent online existence for traditional journals allows for an active rather than a passive audience. One of the reasons the current generation of learners has flocked to social media medical education is that it offers interactivity. Journals must allow similar multidirectional communication in order to stay relevant. Publications, such as the British Medical Journal, have already made inroads by allowing readers to comment on any article published. However, because of fears of less-than-polite conversations (which often occur in less curated corners of the Internet), the experience is still flawed by a cumbersome and time-wasting moderation policy. However, the attempt is still laudable. Even in its current form, this online interaction has allowed vigorous debate and in some cases, such as the responses to a recent article on clinical policies, a revelation of the true characteristics of a paper's audience.2 Hopefully, this new trend of interaction will eliminate or transform the currently flawed system of Letters to the Editor. In the past, a Letters to the Editor section was the only outlet for published questions and clarifications post-publication. However, the system is slow, limited and often merely a devolution to one-upmanship. Unlike genuine multidirectional conversations that occur in truly interactive settings, the narrative is more akin to lobbing bombs in series rather than sitting at a negotiating table to hash out compromises and reach consensus in some areas while identifying genuine and relevant points of variance in others. Readers should be able to question and discuss a publication before or in lieu of traditional Letters. Interaction between the commenter and the authors should occur before the publication of a letter, rather than in the form of a Letter. This has the potential to make the actual published letter far more useful.3 One crucial stipulation is that these forums, if moderated at all, must be done so by medical professionals, not medical publishers or corporate employees. We predict that traditional medical publishing not only will continue, but also holds the potential to become stronger and more useful than ever by adapting interactivity. However, if any traditional journal refuses to change and mould itself to this new era, it will be left in the dust by more adaptable and technology-savvy imprints. We further predict that, at last, journals will no longer be printed. Aside from the cost of production and dissemination, the unnecessary space limits imposed by a paper existence are superfluous and deleterious. The need to print and ship leads to inflated subscription fees and possibly inappropriate reliance on journal-industry partnerships. Current screen resolutions, tablet technology and e-paper readers leave no excuse for not moving forward to an electronic-only existence. In the near future, development of better tablet and smartphone-style apps will enhance reader experience, preserving perhaps the most delightful advantages of print publication: the fortuitous nature of finding unexpected articles by flipping through a table of contents or thumbing through the pages of a journal, without sacrificing modern amenities, such as text searches, downloads and reversible annotations. Although many journals have already started to move to a hybrid publication, e-articles still carry the veneer of inferiority when others in the same journal are published both online and in print. It is common for prolific authors to opt out when e-only publication is offered by a hybrid journal. Only when all articles are solely electronically published, will this prejudice fade. Therefore, abolishing print publication will not only lead to easier corrections and retractions, but also will eliminate an unnecessary two-tiered system. We believe that social media interactions by recognised and emerging leaders have already begun to replace JIF as the primary driver of influence on the clinical choices made by physicians. However, social media should never chip away at the role of traditional journals; specifically, we still believe that vigorous original research should be published in journals. Review articles, as they are currently commissioned and developed, might eventually disappear and be replaced. In the future, published review articles might become the culmination of ideas presented and vetted initially through social media. Indeed, social media has already begun to fill this role. The influence of a meta-analysis is no longer simply guaranteed by its publication but rather by post-hoc analyses in the community, often beginning and ending in social media outlets. A journal that embraces this process will be able to publish review articles that are more robust, relevant, realistic and durable. Modern journals that embrace interactivity as a part of publishing and that abolish print publication will fill a needed niche that is currently partially filled by content and commentary found in social media. If and when a critical mass of journals adapts our discussed changes, the role of social media will be to continue to comment on developments before and after publication, but in a way that leads to higher quality articles and swifter knowledge translation and dissemination. However, not all forms of knowledge are best vetted by traditional peer review and for this social media will continue to grow as a viable locus for discussion and dissemination. For example, some studies simply cannot be done for reasons of ethics, equipoise, appropriate control and appropriate measurable outcomes. Social media offers an outlet for the publication and discussion of tacit knowledge, which Panahi et al. state refers to: ‘Personal knowledge [that] resides in an individual's head in the forms of experience, know-how, insight, expertise, personal beliefs. This type of knowledge can be found in everyday discussions, face-to-face informal meetings, and reports. The unspoken, the non-formal, the tips, the tricks’.4 Prior to the advent of social media, this potent and important body of practical information had no mainstream outlet other than monthly trade periodicals that, like today's peer-review journals, lack appropriate opportunities for timely interactivity by their readership. Mike Cadogan and colleagues coined the term Free Open Access Medical Education (FOAM) to describe the subset of the social media world that is non-commercial, cost-free and in most cases created and distributed by individuals rather than companies. FOAM encompasses blogs, podcasts, smartphone apps and microblogs, such as Twitter® feeds. Although peer review is a far from ideal system in traditional medical publishing, the absence of any system at all might be a current weakness of FOAM. On a popular site, peer review is provided diligently and often nearly instantaneously by a cadre of expert consumer-participants. Many of these ad hoc reviewers are leaders in their fields. Their corrections can be integrated into the FOAM product as soon as they are received, as opposed to in a buried corrigendum published a few months after the original publication. However, new or less frequented sites might not benefit from this automatic oversight. Incorrect information on a site will appear on web searches and because there is no clear hierarchy or grading system for FOAM, it might be equally regarded as ‘fact’ by an inexperienced user. Initial attempts have been made to address this by asking consumer-participants to rate the quality and accuracy of individual posts on popular websites, but again this luxury requires a sufficient level of traffic from reliable experts, including those who serve as peer-reviewed journal referees for traditional publications. The unspoken but requisite and intimated aspect of FOAM is the social component, the interaction. Making said interaction explicit would yield the more descriptive but less evocative acronym: IFOAM. This would distinguish FOAM from one-way communication products, such as open-access journals or links to lectures with no ability to comment or question directly on the relevant site. Currently, this crucial interaction is limited to those practitioners savvy enough with technology to access the FOAM. This might be creating an echo chamber of like-minded clinicians. FOAM must find ways to bring this interaction to a wider swath of the medical population if it is to benefit from the full spectrum of opinion and knowledge. The shift to publications in peer-reviewed journals as the arbiter of medical expertise was one of the great successes of 20th century medical science, as it promoted research vigour over speculation, and the production of evidence over expert opinion and best-guessing. For lack of any better measuring mechanism, research contributions, specifically print publications, became the surrogate watermark of influence in the medical community. Later, as our field matured, the need for publication became a prerequisite for advancement in most academic emergency medicine departments as well. This inspired droves of clinician-scientists to focus on research as a significant part of their careers with the goal of publishing in journals with the highest impact factors. However, we believe this system became the victim of its own success. Career-driven ambition led to a higher quantity of research but often at the expense of quality and passion. Researchers must hurry out a manuscript out of fear of being scooped by a competitor. Reliance on grant funding as well as the ‘publish or perish’ mentality, which pervades many academic departments, lead to publications as a necessity, rather than clinicians writing out of a desire to share a message or idea. At the current time, FOAM is created with no hopes of feeding into traditional career advancement, although this might be changing with all of the positives and negatives that come with such change. One of us (SDW) is a medical podcaster. This activity defines his role in emergency medicine education more than any other activity. Every month the podcast is downloaded more than 250 000 times, with over 5 million downloads since the podcast's inception 4 years ago.5 This allows an enormous reach into the emergency medicine community and the ability to present objective measures of dissemination and impact to a promotions committee. It also implies that FOAM influence can far exceed the impact of traditional publication and on an accelerated time course. This has only begun to be considered relevant by promotions committees. Departments granting faculty protected time for the creation of FOAM is therefore an emerging and welcome trend (see landmark article on FOAM by Nickson and Cadogan in this issue for a comprehensive overview).6 We feel traditional journals will become untraditional by embracing onsite interactivity, developing and promoting new tools to assess and estimate the clinical impact of new research, and by ceasing print publication. These changes will allow articles to be vetted more thoroughly and corrections made more swiftly. They will permit peer-reviewed journals to continue to appropriately concentrate on the publication of research, guidelines and shortcut reviews, as well as review articles that have gone through the FOAM cycle. They will encourage investigators to create high-quality work that genuinely and speedily impacts the field and improves medical practice. Finally, they will benefit authors and editors alike by allowing the length of papers and depth of discussion to be determined by the boundaries of the ideas, rather than the cost of the paper. Enlightened journals will have a blog site run by identified clinicians rather than faceless corporate employees. Every article published will be capable of receiving comments and questions with little or no moderation delay. The authors of the articles should and will be expected to reply, clarify and correct their work in public and in a timely manner. In these ways, we predict that the full adaption and integration of Internet technologies and of social media behaviours will enhance the ability of peer-reviewed journals to disseminate medical knowledge with more speed and accuracy than ever before possible. SDW is the author of the EMCrit Blog and Podcast.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Weingart et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: