Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Organismic and morphological approaches to biology have lately come under attack from a variety of corners in both teaching and research. However, the main motivations for these attacks are not scientific but are instead reflective of economic pressures on teaching and the current fashionability of molecular approaches in research. For example, over the last few decades the number of students taking courses in invertebrate zoology in North American universities has declined significantly. This decline has largely been abetted by the abandonment of classes with small enrolments as increasingly more students are encouraged to take classes in the more fashionable disciplines of molecular and cell biology (Fautin and Watling, 1999). More recently, the fact that systematics is a time-consuming science dependent upon the mastering of specialist knowledge has been cited as a motivation for redirecting research toward DNA taxonomy (Pennisi, 2003; Tautz et al., 2003), and the utility of morphology for phylogeny reconstruction has recently been questioned on several grounds (see Hillis and Wiens, 2000; Baker and Gatesy, 2002). The most recent challenge to the value of morphology for phylogenetics was published in a recent issue of this journal (Scotland et al., 2003). After a critical look at morphological phylogenetics, Scotland et al. (2003:543) reached a strong conclusion: “We disagree that morphology offers any hope for the future to resolve phylogeny at lower or higher taxonomic levels.” Instead, they advocated a “more limited role for morphological data in phylogeny reconstruction” (2003:545), which consists chiefly of studying fewer morphological characters in the context of molecular phylogeny. Because the validity of these arguments would impinge upon morphological phylogenetic research ranging from algae to elephants, a detailed response to Scotland et al. (hereinafter SEA) is necessary. SEA adduced several arguments in support of their contention that morphology has little if anything to offer to the future of phylogeny reconstruction and contended that we should be investing our time and effort into obtaining more molecular phylogenetic data. Here, I evaluate the main arguments of SEA and expose several weaknesses in their reasoning, the correction of which leaves the importance and future promise of morphology for phylogenetics fully intact. The coordinating themes of the critique of SEA are their concerns for phylogenetic accuracy and quantitative clade support. SEA merged these two aspects of phylogenetic analysis into a universal yardstick that they used to assess the relative value of molecules and morphology. SEA (2003:539–540) claimed that in general both accuracy and support are positively correlated with the number of phylogenetic characters. First, SEA (2003:539) concluded that “the number of characters needed in simulation studies to recover accurate trees is an order of magnitude greater than that available from morphology.” Second, SEA (2003:540) claimed that “the low character/taxon ratio in many morphological studies itself precludes high support values.” Do these findings provide an irrefutable basis for discarding morphological evidence from phylogeny reconstruction? SEA judged the relative worth of molecular and morphological data with respect to the accuracy of phylogeny reconstruction. They asserted that increasing phylogenetic accuracy generally depends on increasing the number of characters, as is summarized in their figure 1a. As SEA made clear throughout their article, their main contention is that morphological data are inferior to molecular data in contributing accurate phylogenetic signal. Despite comparing the performance of morphology versus that of molecules with respect to phylogenetic accuracy, SEA failed to discuss how phylogenetic accuracy can be estimated. Phylogenetic accuracy can only be assessed when the true phylogeny is known prior to the analysis. Phylogenetic accuracy is therefore assessed either by simulation studies or by study of known phylogenies (laboratory strains) (Hillis et al., 1994a, 1994b; Hillis, 1995; Givnish and Sytsma, 1997). Consequently, given the typical limitations of available molecular or morphological evidence for a particular set of taxa for which we do not know the phylogeny, we simply cannot know whether our phylogenetic estimate is accurate, i.e., represents the true phylogeny. This realization seriously compromises the value of phylogenetic accuracy as an empirical guide in most phylogenetic studies (Siddall and Kluge, 1997; Siddall, 1998; Farris, 1999). SEA's arguments about phylogenetic accuracy are based on simulation studies, summarized in their figure 1a. SEA (2003:542) stated that “DNA sequence data at least offer the unique potential of scoring large numbers of unambiguous characters and character states.” SEA stated (2003:541) that in contrast to this bounty of sequence data, simulations show that “the number of unambiguously coded morphological characters for any study is finite … and less than the number typically required to accurately reconstruct phylogenies in simulation studies.” However, simulation studies can reliably assess phylogenetic accuracy only when the data evolve precisely according to the assumed model of evolution (Hillis et al., 1994a; Hillis, 1995). If the data do not evolve according to the specified model, then the phylogeny may not be accurately reconstructed, and the number of characters necessary to accurately reconstruct the phylogeny cannot be correctly estimated. The number of characters needed to accurately reconstruct a phylogeny varies according to the nature of the data at hand, the number of taxa, and the chosen model of evolution (Hillis et al., 1994a, 1994b, 2003; Hillis, 1996, 1998; Rosenberg and Kumar, 2003). Therefore, it is very difficult to generalize the number of characters needed to accurately reconstruct phylogeny in given instances. Models for sequence evolution have been selected as much (or more) for their computational convenience as for their approximation to reality (Farris, 1999:201, 202; but see Sullivan and Swofford, 2001). SEA wrote (2003:541) that “the exact processes underlying nucleotide substitution are more complex than the simple models used in phylogenetic reconstruction.” This admission makes SEA's appeal to accuracy largely a moot point because widely employed methods cannot guarantee phylogenetic accuracy. With respect to morphology, SEA (2003:542) emphasized “our current inability to incorporate models of morphological evolution into phylogeny reconstruction methods,” which makes it extremely difficult to determine the number of morphological characters necessary to accurately reconstruct phylogeny in specific cases. However, the development of new models for dealing with morphological data in a likelihood context (Lewis, 2001) may improve our ability to combine morphological and molecular data in single phylogenetic analyses. In repeatedly contrasting molecules and morphology, SEA assumed that these are two distinct and clearly alternative categories of data for phylogeny reconstruction. The greater potential of molecules to contribute to increased phylogenetic accuracy is then chiefly a result of the genome representing a much bigger reservoir of potentially useful unambiguous phylogenetic data. However, is this anything more than a truism? Millions or billions of genomic nucleotides offer a vastly bigger pool of potentially useful phylogenetic variation than the phenotype of even the morphologically most complex eukaryotes. By the same argument, one might as well conclude that because even entire mitochondrial genomes are typically dwarfed by the size of the nuclear genome, they are therefore inferior phylogenetic indicators. However, the quality of a data set and its size are two distinct attributes, and even limited data sets may contribute phylogenetic accuracy. In practice, molecular phylogenetic studies are typically limited to one or a few genes, the analysis of which is far more problematic than hinted at by SEA. Such limited data frequently fail to provide enough information for a robust and accurate phylogenetic estimate. For example, despite intense taxon sampling, the 18S ribosomal RNA locus has so far yielded and accurate of and 2002). This result is not because may evolve at and may be for of a phylogeny. In a recent et al. made this potential They a phylogenetic analysis of from of from the et al., that sets of single or a small number of have a of single molecular data sets are potentially with respect to accurate phylogeny reconstruction as are morphological data “the support for a given was dependent on the et al., which that are in support for of the phylogeny. In with these increasingly have approaches to phylogeny reconstruction to from data that provide at in the phylogeny et al., 1998; et al., Baker et al., et al., 2003; et al., 2003), data set be it molecular or may have only limited a large of the genome is an that has only been for a few However, even a may not when the number of is may phylogenetic on taxonomic the of for a variety of and of of genes, taxon sampling, and substitution of a a a phylogeny, to molecular and and the same may phylogenies when on the nucleotide or and 1995; 1997; and 1998; Hillis and Wiens, 2000; et al., 2000; and Sullivan and Swofford, et al., and et al., et al., et al., and 2003; et al., 2003). Consequently, not of the genome and positively contribute to phylogenetic accuracy, and their in a single phylogenetic analysis may therefore not to increased accuracy. This makes SEA's molecular sequence data on the one and morphology on the not SEA's (2003:539) a main of phylogenetic concerns the limited number of unambiguous characters available for is to many available molecular data the limitations of molecular data sets have not to the general of molecular The limitations of morphological data sets should therefore more be used as an to the value of morphology for phylogeny reconstruction. the potential of large of genomic we do not know whether we can genomes to the required of data to resolve phylogenetic on phylogenetic SEA (2003:543) as would have to that even genomes for not a fully SEA (2003:540) that morphological phylogenetic studies generally have few morphological characters to provide in any given estimate of SEA the findings of et al. and a few studies in their figure and claimed (2003:540) that these that the character/taxon ratio for morphological studies is that are to be This true for the morphological data sets of two by et al. data sets low numbers of and for and et al. cited the low number of available characters as the of the low support for the phylogenetic of these data The bigger molecular data sets support I the potential value of support of used support as by 1995; Siddall, and of the of arguments in in the (Siddall and Kluge, 1997; et al., Kluge, 2002). may provide more phylogenetic than molecular data because of lower character/taxon but this not to lower quantitative support is not only the number of characters but the of that determine how well a given data set a phylogeny. Therefore, one cannot generalize the findings of et al. that small morphological data sets are than molecular data et al. a morphological data set for the of and with and that of the with In two of molecular data sets for this lower of with despite a much number of characters. is to generalize from a few morphological data sets by SEA to the (2003:540) that high support are many morphological studies.” high support are depends on the morphological data set under In a recent morphological analysis of phylogeny, and that of the of in a morphological phylogenetic analysis of et al. that of the support of and high quantitative support for morphological are not and 2000; and et al., et al., 2003). SEA evidence that morphological phylogenetic evidence is generally because “the low character/taxon ratio in many morphological studies itself precludes high support sets of single molecules may provide to clade support as limited at that by morphological data The point is that the available character should be as as and morphology may contribute evidence in with molecular data. SEA the potential value of of both molecular and morphological data, they failed to that in the study of et al. from which they their the support of the of molecules and morphology than of either the morphological or molecular data sets of morphology to quantitative clade support in have been for a of taxa the of et al., 2000; et al., et al., and et al., and et al., 2003; 2003; and 2003). The of morphology to may from as support et al., 1998; and 2000; and et al., Gatesy, and and et al., 2003; and 2003). morphological data sets may small numbers of characters in to the of molecular data, morphology may contribute more support and to the analysis when character et al., 1998; Gatesy, and 2002). For example, Baker et al. and and Baker that morphology may be to as as molecules character in a analysis a of may contribute to data in the of clade support that only when data sets are and 2000; and et al., Gatesy, et al., 2003). morphology may be with molecular data when but when the evidence may a phylogeny. For the same of molecular data sets may to a single phylogeny et al., 2003). In morphology and molecules of data may contribute to of the phylogeny and 2002). of morphology is that characters at many in the phylogeny are in a single data the substitution of a given may its utility to particular in a phylogeny. or a few may not provide phylogenetic in a phylogeny, when the taxa a of In morphology may contribute unique phylogenetic molecules are and In morphology may support of that of et al., 2000; and and in morphology may not any support to data 2001). morphological and molecular evidence may and about morphological and molecular data into a single phylogenetic analysis not to analysis of morphological and molecular these clearly show that morphological data may improve clade support SEA the limited number of unambiguous characters as the main of morphological phylogenetic data. even SEA that any to this by increasing the number of morphological characters be to First, SEA concluded that of the useful morphological has been this may be true for taxa as the by is that it true for The of new morphological data in phylogenetic of many taxa leaves that much variation to be 1995; et al., et al., 2003). Second, SEA (2003:541) that the to and morphological characters only of and to the which the of or problematic SEA (2003:542) morphological studies a high number of characters, both character and character increasingly that may have a on a study as more characters are SEA their with and which show that of both and character with the of more characters. arguments but a SEA these any evidence to support is to support SEA's contention that increasing the number of characters in a morphological data set to increasingly and character The only SEA (2003:542) an in the number of morphological characters to the the basis for these the of In I an in the quality of morphological phylogenetic data with time as the development of new of data and the of For example, in phylogenetics as molecular and cell are contributing to an of the morphological data sets as new data are and are The main of SEA's is that they assumed that of and character can be as of a general phylogenetic in a data set and are as as single to the number of characters in an analysis. However, data sets do not a single phylogenetic signal. The phylogenetic in a data set is and characters are on phylogenetic characters are therefore for taxa but are for Consequently, is simple an in the number of morphological characters and the of character and that can be in a as and and that is throughout the phylogeny. SEA's arguments about and characters are reflective of a of the morphological that is at the of This a in the on phylogeny in the recently published new of the widely used on invertebrate zoology by and of a character is the in morphological phylogenetic However, character is the only empirical of If morphological study be the of a phylogenetic and when less than it may be the The of morphological phylogenetic in in which data are and for their with characters 1998; 1999). SEA's of greater in character and in morphological studies contribute to the quality of morphological phylogenetic analyses. With respect to character and character in molecular phylogenetics, SEA (2003:541) concluded that for sequence data, is in character and is that the of is the In the of characters and the of character in morphological phylogenetics is much more However, the issue is not only whether two nucleotides at the same are but whether they are are characters of low and the character for nucleotides is much more than that for morphology. In this a that the same nucleotide has in the same This realization has been an to models of evolution that estimate the that the same nucleotides at a are to the value of more complex molecular characters et al., and and to methods that molecular information and to improve the of 1995; et al., In morphology generally a of more complex characters that a more of potential which may in morphology may be to molecules when character et al., 1998; Gatesy, and 2002). The and of morphological characters is a difficult and for a given set of taxa alternative approaches to and character may to However, as the cited by SEA is to this and are to with this issue is to a analysis with character to see how the phylogeny with character and and 2002). This at least a of the and in the context of this is that despite the of morphological character is evidence to that morphology generally more than molecules in phylogeny (Hillis and Wiens, 2000; Baker and Gatesy, 2002). SEA (2003:543) cited an molecular evidence from is to that phylogenetic of morphology and have to phylogenetic of the this may be we cannot conclude that morphology the molecules and morphology In many molecular may with and et al., et al., and 2003; et al., 2003), and morphology may be more than molecular data and 2000; and 2001). The findings of et al. that data from one or a small number of may to a phylogeny that may be in with an alternative phylogeny based on set of genes, even for In the context of limited of data we simply cannot know whether we have accurately the true phylogeny. can only character as as and the most SEA (2003:541) claimed that these of and are from molecular data, because of sequence can be As recent research has to this of least may be and this seriously the of and with molecular from the of taxa, and in molecular phylogenetics may in the of the the of how to determine when and or the of phylogenetic analysis the of whether nucleotides or are for genes, and the of the for these may result in phylogenies and et al., et al., et al., 2003). and may to in molecular phylogenetic analyses. SEA's to simply information with may as by the For more than a 18S ribosomal DNA that most to This was in with from a large of and and molecular data, which instead with After the 18S data in they concluded that this was an of molecules of phylogeny. However, in a recent study et al. that the 18S data and the and molecular data was an to two main of and of to the of this was the of information from the most of the 18S that most difficult to This study clearly that the data set to only the least unambiguous might a phylogeny. The that and characters in (2003:541) is therefore not limited to morphological data. The recent development of methods to with or to sequence see 2001) the the value and of molecular and morphological data as by SEA. SEA stated that role for morphology in phylogeny reconstruction a and they the role of morphology in systematics in one of In the which is the one by fewer morphological are in and are then a molecular phylogeny the basis that morphological characters can be for on molecular morphological character is with respect to a in the molecular phylogeny, and characters to be not into the phylogenetic SEA claimed that this to If one to as a research the is the of was clearly about the of characters analysis on the basis of character in which the of characters is assessed this guarantee the that By comparing morphological characters an molecular phylogeny, one is not of characters, despite SEA's of If of characters with the molecular phylogeny but SEA's would as This is more to the basis of which for phylogeny reconstruction was questioned (Farris, This any from the phylogenetic which is in with the of if morphological characters not used to reconstruct a phylogeny as by a molecular phylogeny to evidence for a more limited number of (2003:545), we would have to the same of character and character that SEA as the weaknesses of morphological phylogenetic characters can be a molecular phylogeny as a limited number of they be as about character determine on in the phylogeny a character is so is the of a character in a in a phylogeny with particular about character For example, SEA (2003:541) cited the to that even for simple characters it may be difficult to an For these data, not the variation of a versus (see by et al., 1997). Consequently, if we the of as a on a particular in a molecular phylogeny, we that the variation is not as a even about character are not made in a data cannot be SEA the study of fewer than more characters because character study is time the high of in the of phylogenetics is set by molecular studies, methods much data than can be when studying morphology. this may in to the of phylogenetic studies based on and morphological data sets of low quality in However, we to as much as we can about the evolution of morphology, and for which is difficult science can be time can be a scientific for studying fewer than more characters. SEA's and for morphology into phylogenetics are the As a SEA advocated a of current morphological and molecular data both have their and they are both and in to study The is only characters that are in of and character are and with the molecular data. two approaches provide the same as the and as with respect to more in SEA that morphological study is and I not However, SEA's to only unambiguously morphological characters is and character are and can in be and By that the and of even simple characters can be problematic SEA show that prior to a phylogenetic analysis are coded morphological to problematic from more characters prior to a phylogenetic analysis show that the phylogenetic utility of characters is very difficult to a and and 2003; et al., 2003; 2003). By (2003:543) that morphology cannot offer hope for the future to resolve phylogeny at lower or higher taxonomic SEA very little to in with taxon sampling, SEA not any about their value for phylogenetics than that their to phylogenetic accuracy is in of the of and character However, the limited of molecular and morphological evidence typically available to not to determine whether the true phylogeny has been accurately in the As an of in phylogenetic SEA (2003:543) cited the of In concluded on the basis of simulation studies that “the of data in the taxa is a of their on phylogenetic is more to the of data in the and the number of characters that can be for the As Baker and morphological evidence is the phylogeny of over of is In as the of the are known only from 2002). The importance of for phylogeny can be by the importance of et al., 1998; and 2000; et al., and and 2003; et al., 2003). the most of taxa, and their value in the morphological is of importance to the of the of With the of morphological phylogenetic analysis is the only in which can be into the phylogeny of to do so phylogenies of SEA the value of in which data can unique on a However, they fail to that by morphological phylogenetic the of is Phylogenetic of data sets provide and unique on both phylogenetic and of character The of a morphological and molecular and in phylogenetic research on many taxa on many phylogenetic For example, a recent phylogenetic analysis of 18S in failed to on the basis of morphological study et al., 2003). This a more detailed look at the molecular data, several that may have and recently phylogeny with nuclear and mitochondrial They that the morphologically clade of and is by molecular Because have claimed that most molecular and morphological phylogenies is to support for either or both of the and that and morphological phylogenies are (Hillis and Wiens, 2000; et al., 2003), a potential for strong is worth to the that in this morphological phylogenetic may from the of in the characters to This may about the of evolution in a complex of into evolution are dependent upon the and of molecular and morphological data its from its of approaches can only to of see the of molecular and morphological data sets and in to the et al., et al., 2000; et al., 2000; et al., et al., et al., and and et al., and et al., 2003; 2003; and 2003). As SEA study of morphological characters is necessary because one of phylogenetic analysis is to character might as well the data to as many potentially as By morphological phylogenetics, we take a main for morphological research. with the of biology in (Fautin and Watling, this the that potentially students not be to and this of students may seriously the future and of our science for largely SEA failed to any scientific arguments for the of phylogenetics to molecular research. In that morphology not be to resolve the of the of SEA (2003:543) an because single data molecular or can be to be the of phylogenetics, as they by (2003:543) that even genomes not a fully The only that I can of for or the of morphological evidence for phylogeny reconstruction as by SEA is when we know a that these data be positively SEA failed to show that we have this Instead, they a few from phylogenetics the of morphological data to the phylogeny was However, as these provide enough to the general value of morphology for of the of In the of evidence to the I that an molecular and morphological phylogenetics is our for future I on the by and an of the under number
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ronald A. Jenner (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: