This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Chronic visceral pain is extremely debilitating and often resistant to pharmacological and surgical treatments (Giamberardino, 1999). Therefore, the Holy Grail for its treatment would be a non-invasive procedure that alleviates visceral pain without side effects. In this issue of the European Journal of Pain, Fregni and colleagues (2011) reported that slow frequency, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) of the right secondary somatosensory cortex (SII) was able to elicit long-lasting pain relief in patients with chronic pancreatitis. They showed significant analgesia following rTMS, compared to sham stimulation. rTMS also elicited bilateral augmentations of glutamate and N-acetyl aspartate levels, as measured in SII with single-voxel proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (1H-MRS). The findings of this study are important since they suggest that a non-invasive, drug-free procedure which consists of delivering a flow of current into the SII cortex, through magnetic pulses applied to the scalp, could specifically alleviate chronic visceral pain. This interesting work is one of a number of TMS approaches that have been developed over the last few years with the aim of alleviating pain, as well as treating several other neurological and psychiatric disorders (Bolognini and Ro, 2010). However, as in previous rTMS studies, this work also raises several questions, including the rationale for choosing the most effective stimulation parameters and cortical target. Moreover, since the main objective is to obtain a specific, long-lasting and maximum relief of pain, the question remains as to the relationship between the effects produced by rTMS and the top-down modulation mechanisms that are triggered. Although it remains to be determined to what extent the stimulation spreads to anatomically neighbouring structures such as the insular cortex, the authors chose the SII cortex as the target for rTMS on the basis of their pilot study that showed significant pain relief only following stimulation of the right SII. In contrast, they found that left SII stimulation with low or higher frequency rTMS significantly increased pain. These results are intriguing as they do not fit with a diffuse analgesic effect elicited from SII. Also, it is not clear whether changes in glutamate and N-acetyl aspartate levels could be correlated with analgesia, since they occur bilaterally in SII. A recent study of rTMS effects on two models of cutaneous experimental pain showed that selective analgesia was elicited following rTMS stimulation of either the motor or the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Such effects were not topographically distributed and probably occurred at supraspinal levels, since rTMS did not affect spinal pain processing as assessed with the RIII reflex (Nahmias et al., 2009). A previous study claimed that motor cortex stimulation was more effective for relieving facial neurogenic pain than pain occurring in the limbs. However, rTMS targeted the hand and not the trigeminal-related cortical area (Lefaucheur et al., 2004). Overall, these studies suggest that rTMS stimulation is not target or modality specific, since its capability to elicit analgesia depends neither on the manipulation of cortical regions where the pain focus is represented, nor on the pain sub-modality (cutaneous versus visceral, experimental/acute versus chronic). Perhaps the effectiveness of rTMS depends on the ability to trigger top-down modulation of activities in widespread regions of the brain. Nevertheless, Fregni's findings suggest that relief of pain from chronic pancreatitis is mediated by asymmetrical, CNS mechanisms of pain modulation, as shown by the analgesia elicited by rTMS applied on the right SII and the worsening of pain when the same stimuli were applied on the opposite, left, SII cortex. Interestingly, Craig (2005) proposed that lateralised representations of homeostatic sensory activity in the forebrain provide a basis for subjective human feelings, with this lateralisation being related to left/right forebrain asymmetry in the opposing parasympathetic and sympathetic activities, respectively. Accordingly, the cortical representations of both autonomic efferent, and homeostatic afferent, processing are asymmetric and converge in the insula and ventrolateral prefrontal cortex. The left side is activated predominantly by homeostatic afferents associated with parasympathetic functions (such as taste in the insula) and the right side is activated predominantly by homeostatic afferents associated with sympathetic functions, including pain. In the homeostatic model proposed by Craig (2005), this asymmetry in energy management relates directly to affect and emotion, with left side feelings regarded as parasympathetic or ‘enrichment emotions’ whereas emotional feelings associated with right-sided activity are generally viewed as ‘aroused or sympathetic emotions’. Also, Craig (2003) proposed to consider pain perception as a homeostatic emotion, that is, both an aspect of interoception and a specific behavioural motivation (Craig, 2003). Indeed, the most important, widespread source of top-down modulation arises from the cortex. A number of cortical regions mediate subtle forms of plasticity by adjusting both thalamic and pre-thalamic maps and consequently altering all the modulatory mechanisms downstream as a result of sensory experience (Villanueva and Fields, 2004). The sensory pathways that convey nociceptive impulses are simultaneously collecting information from many sources. This basic somaesthetic activity not only is relevant for pain, but could have a role in terms of a continual transmission of information relevant to the integrity of the body. This information is being constantly selected and modulated in the context of an appropriate response. Accordingly, pain experience has been described as an active process, an attribute assigned by the brain as a quality among the options available for sensory experience and thus a phenomenon associated with an output rather than a particular input (Wall, 1999). Taken together, rTMS studies support the concept that manipulation of endogenous, CNS modulation mechanisms with the aim to produce analgesia do not merely consist of producing neuronal inhibition or excitation. Such manipulations produce probably changes of dynamic brain states at the origin of many modes of human behaviours, within a single sensory emotional behavioural system. Perhaps the efficacy of rTMS procedures to alleviate pain is not related to a reduction of nociceptive inputs, but to the ability to turn back the so-called ‘pain matrix’ to an operating state, liberated from pain. The author is grateful to Drs. S.W. Cadden and R. Noseda for advice in the preparation of the manuscript.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Luis Villanueva (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: