Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Is patriotism a virtue? Popular U.S. opinion would seem to say “yes.” Indeed, the answer would be so obviously “yes” that popular opinion would be perplexed by even asking the question. Loving one’s country, it would seem, is as natural a duty as loving one’s children. The unpatriotic person is as vile and malformed as Medea. But if patriotism is a virtue, then everyone ought to be patriotic, not just Americans. The French should be patriotic, the Germans should be patriotic- even Iraqis should be patriotic. But would popular opinion grant this? French and German citizens who supported their government’s refusal to back the U.S. invasion of Iraq were not given even a grudging respect in U.S. newspaper opinion pages. And Iraqis who still declare their loyalty to Saddam Hussein are hardly praised for their patriotism-they are condemned as monsters. “Good Germans,” loyal to Hitler, or at least unwilling to oppose him openly, have been not crowned as patriots, but reviled as moral cowards. How can “patriotism” be good in Americans, but venal in Nazis? It might be objected that this puzzle only arises if one fails to distinguish patriotism from jingoism. The latter, the objector might say, is an immature and ignorant insistence on the righteousness of one’s own country, no matter what—“my country right or wrong.” True patriotism, on the other hand, is not blind. It does not require us to ignore gross injustice or blatant evil. Nor does it require us to believe patent falsehoods. Whatever attitude a “good German” had toward the Nazi regime, or that a loyal Ba’athist had toward Hussein’s oligarchy, that attitude is not “patriotism.”
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Louise Antony (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: