Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Objectives: Getting medical students to acknowledge and confront their prejudices can be challenging, particularly if the students do not feel secure in the setting. We have developed a component of the third-year family medicine clerkship at Jefferson Medical College that has helped to predictably and comfortably draw students into a discussion about their own experiences with prejudice, as well as how their own prejudices could affect their delivery of health care. The seminar, entitled Prejudice and Medicine, took its current form in 1998. It was developed to complement a week of community medicine experiences that were specifically chosen to reveal stereotypes that students may have. As part of the rotation, students attend an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting, attend rounds in a nursing home/independent living facility for the elderly, take medical histories from adolescents in a homeless shelter, deliver care on home visits, accompany nurses on hospice visits, and provide patient education in an underserved community center. Description: The 90-minute seminar takes place toward the end of each six-week rotation in the Department of Family Medicine at Jefferson Medical College. This is to ensure that the students have completed most of the community medicine portion of the rotation, thereby allowing for a common point of discussion. The initial 20 minutes of the seminar typically involve an open discussion of the community medicine experiences. There is an emphasis on what the students saw that surprised them. Once we have eased into the topic of stereotypes and generalizations, we then break the students into small groups, usually four groups of three students each. Everyone is given a sheet of paper that starts off with “Have you ever …” which is followed by 16 statements that are designed to provoke discussion. Examples are “Have you ever, as a female medical student, been called `nurse' by the patient when you walked into the room?” and “Have you ever seen a morbidly obese patient and thought that they were lazy?” The topics cover race, culture, obesity, substance use, gender, sexual orientation, the elderly, nurse practitioners, and others. Each group of students is given four of the 16 statements; they are told they can discuss one or more of the four. The small-group discussion lasts 30 minutes. The entire class then reconvenes for the final 30 minutes, highlighting individual group discussions and allowing for further comment. Discussion: This format has been very successful in that the small groups of students immediately begin animated and often passionate discussions. The small group size allows for intimacy in divulging potentially difficult information, and giving the small groups flexibility within the list of statements promotes discussion of the topics that most interest them. In two years of evaluation, the students have ranked the seminar 3.9 (on a five-point scale) on value for future practice and 4.0 on whether they would recommend the experience to their classmates. Overall, the students discover that experiential learning with discussion is beneficial in their continuing growth towards becoming compassionate physicians to a diverse population.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sifri et al. (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: