Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Since competition is the theme of this paper, it is appropriate in view of recent discussion to define my usage of the term at the outset. I am inclined to accept Milne's (1961) definition, which is rather similar to Birch's (1957) 'Meaning 1' and to regard competition as occurring between organisms when any resource is in short supply. In this paper, the resource involved is food so that difficulties in the interpretation of what is meant by 'resource' may be happily avoided. Scrutiny of only part of the vast literature on this topic is enough to indicate a paradox regarding the incidence of competition in nature. It is one (Mather 1961) of the cornerstones of Darwinian evolution yet Darwin considered a majority of species as rare. Andrewartha & Birch (1954, 1960) are inclined to accept rarity as evidence of the infrequency of competition in nature, although their view is perhaps being modified (Andrewartha & Browning 1961). Usually, populations are measured in terms of numbers per unit area or volume and the term 'rare' applied when numbers are low in comparison with other populations or with resources. Examples of such rareness come easily to mind in my own field experience and also those of most ecologists. Recently, however, Huffaker (1957) has pointed out that before rareness unaccompanied by shortage of resource (i.e. without competition) can be established, the needs of these organisms must be carefully determined. Again, Pimentel (1961) has attributed rareness in predators to a genetic feedback mechanism which reduces competition and provides an alternative explanation of the rareness of organisms. The paradox also emerges when the viewpoints of the theorist and the student of laboratory populations are compared with those of many, but not all, field ecologists. The former, impressed with the potential for geometric increase in populations and the ease by which a state of competition is achieved in the laboratory, are inclined to regard the phenomenon as commonplace in nature. But potential geometric increase need not result in competition, it depends on the pattern of mortality in the life-cycle and seems more likely to occur in physically favourable environments and less likely in physically harsh environments. Field ecologists, impressed with the difficulty of establishing the fact of competition in nature (e.g. to mention a few, Buxton 1955; Milne 1957; Ross 1957; Sokoloff 1957; Thompson 1956; Andrewartha & Browning 1961), are inclined to regard the phenomenon as being much rarer. Indeed current ecological texts (Andrewartha & Birch 1954; Macfadyen 1957) and reviews (Crombie 1947; Elton & Miller 1954; Solomon 1957) are unanimous in regarding evidence of competition in nature as being slight, but some authors (e.g. Lack 1954) do not consider the phenomenon as unusual. This may simply be another way of saying that adequate studies of the problem are few. Another approach to explaining the paradox is the view expressed by several writers (Solomon 1957; Frank 1959; Hutchinson 1961) that outlook is a product of individual experience.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Trefor B. Reynoldson (1964) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: