Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
There is no doubt that the operator is one of the key “components” in nearly any system used in forestry (Mola-Yudego et al. 2015; Malinen et al. 2018). However, we need a collective understanding of what an operator effect or rather a human influence really is in forest work science. Most of us probably regard psychological, cognitive, and motor abilities as human influences (or, more strictly, potentially influential human factors or variables) that may affect results in various ways, but it is equally important to consider what is not a human influence. For instance, an operator consciously and recurrently conducts certain working manoeuvres and tactics in specific ways that will clearly affect performance. Should these also be regarded as human influences? During the era from the 1970s to the beginning of the 2000s Nordic forest researchers published studies on the operator effect relatively frequently (Harstela 1975; Gullberg 1995; Björheden 2001), especially considering that substantially fewer scientific articles were published then. However, for unknown reasons this essential part of forest work research has been largely neglected for more than a decade in the Nordic forest scientific literature. Since an article by Lindroos (2010) that deeply and critically addressed this important issue it has been ignored. This is unfortunate because in forest work research we typically analyse alternative working methods or technological innovations and even if we are not often directly interested in operators, they impact the results and thus complicate our analyses. Nordic forest researchers have traditionally considered the operator as a block effect in statistical models, and hence applied blocking to account for human influence. In practise this means that each operator applies all alternative technologies or working methods monitored or tested in a study. This is basically correct, but there are many issues to consider and discuss. Here I focus on three of these issues: 1) risks of human influence being confounded with different working tactics, 2) pooling data across the operators in order to obtain generalizable results, 3) defining operator effects as either random or fixed, and whether it matters.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jussi Manner (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: