Key result
Finger pulse contour analysis using the Finometer monitor was unreliable for measuring absolute cardiac output in hemodialysis patients.
Why the study?
Does finger pulse contour analysis accurately measure cardiac output in hemodialysis patients compared to the Transonic monitor?
Observational (n=25)
Does finger pulse contour analysis accurately measure cardiac output in hemodialysis patients compared to the Transonic monitor?
Finger pulse contour analysis is unreliable for measuring cardiac output in hemodialysis patients, likely due to uremic vascular disease.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Caution against Finometer for absolute cardiac output in hemodialysis; leaves open validation of noninvasive alternatives in this population.
Reliable methods for cardiac output determination are essential for studying the pathophysiology of intradialytic hypotension. Use of the current gold standard, the Transonic monitor, requires an arteriovenous fistula. We wished to verify the accuracy of a method based on finger pulse contour analysis, namely the Finometer monitor (FNM) for further use on patients dialyzing on a central vascular catheter. Fifty simultaneous cardiac output measurements were obtained during hemodialysis sessions in 25 patients. The internal variability of the FNM measurements was assessed by comparing 24 pairs of immediately successive measurements. The variability of successive FNM measurements was small (bias 0.28%, SD +/- 6.1%; NS). The absolute cardiac output values reported by the FNM were unreliable (bias 20.1%, SD +/- 35.3%; P<0.001) as were the relative intradialytic changes (r(2)=0.01). Excluding participants from the analysis due to old age, high dialysis vintage or a suspicion of atherosclerosis did not improve the results. Our findings do not support the use of pulse contour analysis for measuring cardiac output in hemodialysis patients. Uremic vascular disease may be the cause of the observed inaccuracy.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cordtz et al. (2010) conducted an observational in Hemodialysis (n=25). Finometer monitor (finger pulse contour analysis) vs. Transonic monitor was evaluated on Absolute cardiac output values (bias 20.1%, p=<0.001). Finger pulse contour analysis using the Finometer monitor was unreliable for measuring absolute cardiac output in hemodialysis patients.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: